Brooklyn-Queens streetcar project may not fund itself

Leaked city memo claims the financial model could be a problem

TRD New York /
Apr.April 14, 2017 03:18 PM

Rendering of BQX (Credit: Friends of the Brooklyn Queens Connector)

A leaked internal city memo shows the proposed Brooklyn-Queens streetcar is facing “serious financial challenges” and may not actually generate enough money to cover its costs.

The confidential memo, obtained and reviewed by Politico, shows the project’s financial model is one of the problems. The document was sent by “BQX Project Team” to Deputy Mayor Alicia Glen in February, according to the publication.

The proposed trolley line would connect Red Hook and Astoria along the East River waterfront. The de Blasio administration has said the streetcar’s positive impact on property values will produce between $2.4 billion and $3 billion in additional tax revenue over 40 years to pay for the system. The building costs is pegged at $2.5 billion, and the city also estimates it will cost $31.5 million each year to operate and maintain. That particular financing model is called as “Value Capture.”

The memo lists four “serious challenges,” according to the publication. One is that “Value Capture is not providing sufficient revenue to fund the entire project as originally stated.” That’s partially because it’s very costly to work on the water, gas and sewer mains that are on the potential path between Sunset Park and Astoria.

If it does turn out the project is not financially feasible, city officials will consider options, which include abandoning the project altogether, according to Politico. Though it’s not yet certain what the city will do, slowing down the project could also make the entire project even more expensive. It would, however, allow the for officials to do further analysis on the project’s real cost and value.

“There may be merit in undertaking additional study/review and options prior to the city making a final decision on the project,” according to the memo cited by Politico.

Critics of the project have complained the streetcar will benefit developers and have a negative impact on housing affordability.

A spokesperson for the city said the “numbers change constantly” and that the “project will improve transportation for hundreds of thousands of people, and we continue to work to move it forward.” [Politco]Miriam Hall

Related Articles

From left: Bruce Molser, David Schechtman, Bob Knakal, David Greenbaum, and Judi Pulice

New York’s real estate bigwigs offer predictions for 2020

Mayor Bill de Blasi0, a rendering of Halletts Point, and Douglas Durst (Credit: Getty Images, Durst)

Feud with de Blasio pushes Durst to shelve Halletts Point

Mayor Bill de Blasio and subway damage caused by Hurricane Sandy (Credit: Getty Images)

Program to rebuild Sandy-damaged homes needs extra $92M

From left: Deputy Mayor of Housing and Economic Development Vicki Been, Sen. Brian Kavanagh (inset), Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams, State Division of Homes and Community Renewal Commissioner Ruthanne Visnauskas (inset), Council member Keith Powers, with Governor Andrew Cuomo and Mayor Bill de Blasio (background) (Credit: Anuja Shakya, Getty Images)

Politico shows and no-shows: What public officials attended the REBNY gala?

Donald Trump with Rep. Emanuel Cleaver II, Rep. Ron Kind and Sen. Cory Booker (Credit: Getty Images, iStock)

Trump’s Opportunity Zone program is under investigation

Councilman Stephen Levin (Credit: Facebook, Getty Images)  

NYC bill would boost rental vouchers for homeless

From left:  Council member Rafael Espinal, Mayor Bill de Blasio and Council member Antonio Reynoso (Credit: Getty Images, iStock)

Bushwick rezoning impasse puts de Blasio’s housing plan at risk

Neir’s Tavern (Credit: Google Maps)

City’s oldest bar, of “Goodfellas” fame, gets last-minute lifeline