Controversial Manhattan Housing Court judge to get the boot

Judicial panel recommends giving Susan Avery the boot, citing long list of complaints

New York /
Dec.December 04, 2017 10:00 AM

Susan Avery (Credit: Facebook)

A Manhattan Housing Court judge who showed a “lack of concern” for litigants in her court and had conflicts of interest regarding her family’s real estate holdings is getting the boot.

Susan Avery, who was appointed to her $175,000-per-year job in 2012 by then-Chief Judge Gail Prudenti, is set to get axed by the end of the year following a recommendation by a panel of real estate industry and tenant organization representatives, the New York Post reported.

Avery, 52, has a long list of of complaints against her, including allowing cases involving tenants lacking heat or hot water to drag on.

“Considering the complaints against her, it’s about time for her to leave the bench,” said Alan Flacks, a local resident who has long argued for judicial reform.

The judge showed poor judgment almost immediately after taking the job, such as when she reprimanded a lawyer in with cerebral palsy for sloppy handwriting in 2013, according to a four-page report by the 14-member Advisory Council for the Housing Part of the Civil Court of New York City.

The panel also criticized Avery for “excessive multi-week adjournments” and for conflicts of interest regarding her failure to disclose that a law firm administering her family’s trust also frequently represented landlords in her court.

In 2014, Avery ruled that ripping out a radiator in a building where tenants complained the landlord hooked radiators up to their boilers was the same as repairing it.

The New York Law School graduate received a “not approved rating” by the city Bar Association twice, and was involved in a scandal in 2016 when her boyfriend allegedly made derogatory comments about a rival judge who successfully beat Avery in a race for a civil court position. [NYP]Rich Bockmann


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Eric Adams (Getty, iStock)
City program could supplement state rent relief — if next mayor signs off
City program could supplement state rent relief — if next mayor signs off
The tenants who won the affordable housing lottery at 15 Hudson Yards say the units are in an “entirely separate part of the building and with a different address.” (Hudson Yards, District Court of New York)
Lawsuit claims 15 Hudson Yards discriminates with “poor doors”
Lawsuit claims 15 Hudson Yards discriminates with “poor doors”
Council members call out City Planning on Soho rezoning
Council members call out City Planning on Soho rezoning
Council members call out City Planning on Soho rezoning
Jared McClain of NCLA and Gov. Phil Murphy (Photos via iStock, NCLA, Getty)
NJ tenants can pay rent with security deposits: court
NJ tenants can pay rent with security deposits: court
According to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, around 11.5 million Americans were behind on rent last month. (Getty)
Four landlords allegedly pushed out 5,000 renters during moratorium
Four landlords allegedly pushed out 5,000 renters during moratorium
Democrats look to curtail tax break for “pass-through” businesses
Democrats look to curtail tax break for “pass-through” businesses
Democrats look to curtail tax break for “pass-through” businesses
Gov. Andrew Cuomo and the Surfside condo (Getty, iStock)
After Surfside, NY state lawmakers call for tighter inspection protocols
After Surfside, NY state lawmakers call for tighter inspection protocols
Policy change puts $20 a month in home refinancers’ pockets
Policy change puts $20 a month in home refinancers’ pockets
Policy change puts $20 a month in home refinancers’ pockets
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...