Owner of a rustic cabin roofscape sues city after fine, demand for new paperwork

Mysterious complainant alleging work without a permit triggered the city's scrutiny

Jan.January 13, 2018 03:49 PM

(Credit: photo of porch vastateparksstaff/Wikimedia Commons; background, Pexels)

A New York City developer is fielding complaints about a private project he constructed over a decade ago atop his own apartment.

The project is a meadow and porch — yes, that’s right, just a porch that connects through an inner staircase to his loft apartment below — that transforms the roof of the luxury co-op building, 719 Greenwich St., into a picturesque countryside landscape, save the New York skyline surrounding it.

David Puchkoff, the head of DP Associates, which developed 161 Hudson Street among other projects, built the garden and porch in 2003, according to the New York Post, and last year the city received a complaint about Puchkoff doing work without a permit. The Department of Buildings investigated and issued him a fine of $1,200 and directed him to apply for a new certificate of occupancy.

Considering Puchkoff obtained permits more than a decade ago — and hasn’t made any changes since — he’s decided to fight the decision, and whoever complained in the first place, by suing the Department of Buildings.

“It isn’t fair, I’ve already met all the rules and regulations,” he told the New York Daily News. He estimates that even if he wins his case, legal fees will run up a bill of about $30,000, but he’s pressing forward.

“I haven’t done any other work in there except to water my garden, so who am I annoying?” he said in another interview to the Post, adding that he doesn’t know who initiated the complaint, but no one has approached him with concerns. [NYP] — Erin Hudson

Related Articles

Map of essential active construction sites (Credit: NYC Department of Buildings)

City clears another 300 construction sites for “emergency” work

From left: 66 Hudson Boulevard, 200 Amsterdam Avenue and One Vanderbilt (Credit: Tishman Speyer; 200 Amsterdam; KPF)

Some luxury condos, office towers escape construction ban

TRD Talks Live

Watch tonight: Turning to tech on TRD Talks Live

(Credit: iStock)

Strong quarter for Manhattan home sales belies current struggle

US Steel’s sprawling South Works site is about the size of Downtown Chicago. At left, Common, who wants to partner with developers on a mixed-use entertainment district there, and Dan McCaffery, whose vision for a 13,000-home community fizzled out. (Credit: Common by Paras Griffin/Getty Images; McCaffery via McCaffery Interests; aerial by Cushman & Wakefield)

South Works, the 415-acre “magnificent property,” is Chicago’s biggest development opportunity

Manhattan resi listings continue nosedive: report

Manhattan resi listings continue nosedive: report

252 East 57th Street and 196 Orchard Street with Samantha Sheeber and Tal Alexander

Closing in the time of Covid-19: “We’re pulling out all the stops”

Kuwait’s consul general in New York, Hamad Al-Hazeem and 50 United Nations Plaza (Credit: Google Maps)

Kuwait’s consul general buys 50 UN Plaza pad for $16M