Judge tosses lawsuit seeking to block development at Pier 6

Construction on Brooklyn Bridge Park project has been ongoing

TRD New York /
Feb.February 16, 2018 04:40 PM

Rendering of Pier 6 and RAL’s Robert Levine (Credit: ODA and RAL)

A state Supreme Court Judge on Friday tossed a lawsuit seeking to block a two-tower development planned for Brooklyn Bridge Park, finding that the project was an appropriate scale.

Judge Carmen Victoria St. George dismissed a lawsuit filed by the Brooklyn Heights Association (BHA) seeking to stop RAL Development Services and partner Oliver’s Realty Group from building a 28-story condominium and 14-story rental building at Pier 6, which have a combined 266 units. The lawsuit alleged, among other things, that the project violated the park’s 2006 General Project Plan, which required that any development on Pier 6 only be done to “enliven the area” and assure the financial stability of the park.

The community group argued that smaller scale buildings would’ve satisfied this requirement. The group pointed to the fact that 25 percent of the square footage of the projects was being set aside for affordable housing as proof that buildings of that size and scale weren’t needed to sustain an already wealthy park. BHA previously alleged that the towers would create $300 million in extra revenue in the next 50 years — a calculation that officials contested.

The judge also didn’t buy the group’s argument.

“Respondents are entitled to consider the future financial needs of the park and the potential fluctuations in the economy in their financial analysis and to make conservative projections to ensure future financial stability in a worst-case scenario,” the judge said.

When reached by phone on Friday, RAL CEO Robert Levine said he was pleased with the decision. He said construction on the project continued as the lawsuit made its way through the court. The court ruled in July that construction could commence before a final decision on the lawsuit was made — though, at the developers’ peril. Levine said he wasn’t concerned about the court ruling in the group’s favor.

“The merits of the initial arguments in court provided us confidence that we would prevail,” he said.

Representatives for BHA didn’t immediately return a call seeking comment on the decision.

The Brooklyn Bridge Park Corp., the nonprofit that controls the 85-acre park, tapped RAL and Oliver’s in July 2016 to develop Pier 6.

“In addition to critical long-term funding for Brooklyn Bridge Park guaranteed by today’s decision, the Pier 6 project will also provide much-needed affordable housing and union construction jobs,” Eric Landau, president of Brooklyn Bridge Park, said in a statement.

The lawsuit also alleged that Oliver’s failed to register with a database of companies that do business with the city — something that’s required of companies that donate to local political campaigns. The judge noted that though the failure was “troubling,” it didn’t impact the developer’s contract.

Related Articles

These are the tallest towers underway in NYC

These are the tallest towers underway
in NYC

A new competition asks what would houses on Mars look like (Credit: Getty Images, Pixabay)

Architecture’s final frontier: Here’s what houses on Mars might look like

Billy Macklowe and Key Food at 120 Fifth Avenue in Brooklyn (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

Billy Macklowe looking to break into Brooklyn

From left: The Blau and Berg Company's Karine Blanc, TD and Partners' Nana Duncan and Lemor Development Group's Kenneth Morrison (Credit: Blauberg, TD+Partners and Lemor)

Black developers say partnerships aren’t always equal

Stanford White

The great works and untimely death of New York architect Stanford White

85 4th Avenue in Brooklyn (Credit: Google Maps)

New details of Boerum Hill’s next big project unveiled

TF Cornerstone president Frederick Elghanayan and 595 Dean Street (Credit: CityRealty, Google Maps)

TF Cornerstone’s Prospect Heights two-tower project unveiled

Assemblyman David Chiu and Gov. Gavin Newsom (Credit: Wikipedia and iStock)

California passes landmark rent control law