New graffiti case hits BK court in wake of 5Pointz ruling

Case asks whether illegally painted mural deserves copyright protections

New York /
Mar.March 16, 2018 08:31 AM

The mural at William Sheridan Playground (Credit: Lawsuit)

Brooklyn’s Federal District Court is becoming a haven for lawsuits about graffiti.

The court received a case last week that will ask whether an illegally painted mural deserves to be protected under federal copyright law, according to the New York Times. The case comes in the wake of a jury’s decision that the graffiti artists at 5Pointz in Long Island City were entitled to $6.7 million after developer Jerry Wolkoff whitewashed over their work.

The new case stems from a fashion shoot by clothing company H&M in Williamsburg’s William Sheridan Playground last year. The production firm they hired wanted to shoot at a handball court with graffiti and asked the city’s Parks and Recreation Department if they needed to pay royalties to use the graffiti. The department replied that they did not know who painted the mural and that it was not sanctioned by the city.

H&M thus shot footage in front of it, and after artist Jason Williams saw it online, his lawyer Jeff Gluck sent a cease-and-desist letter to H&M claiming that they had used Williams’ work without his approval and threatening legal action.

H&M’s lawyers responded that they had done their due diligence and did not need Williams’ permission to use the graffiti since he had created it illegally. They recently filed a lawsuit asking a judge to declare that they are free to use the mural and that Williams has no claims on it.

“Essentially what H&M is doing here is asking the court to declare that any and all unsanctioned or illegal art should be utterly devoid of copyright protection,” Williams’ lawyer Jeff Gluck told the Times. “It really is an assault on artists’ rights.” [NYT]Eddie Small


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Eli Elefant and 452 5th Avenue (IAVA, Property Building Corp)
PBC nears $385M loan for HSBC tower after sale to Innovo collapses
PBC nears $385M loan for HSBC tower after sale to Innovo collapses
Vornado CEO Steven Roth and One Penn Plaza (Vornado Realty Trust)
Health insurer takes 70k sf for HQ in Vornado’s One Penn Plaza
Health insurer takes 70k sf for HQ in Vornado’s One Penn Plaza
From left: Scott Rechler and 5 Times Square; Marc Holliday, Steven Roth and 280 Park Avenue (Getty Images, Eden, Janine and Jim from New York City - via Wikimedia Commons)
Swell of maturing debt pressures office owners
Swell of maturing debt pressures office owners
(photos by Joe Lovinger/The Real Deal)
Day 2 of ICSC: Retailers button up to network, prep for uncertain future
Day 2 of ICSC: Retailers button up to network, prep for uncertain future
Boston Properties' Hilary Spann and Eldridge CEO Todd Boehly in front of 767 Fifth Avenue (Boston Properties, Eldridge, Google Maps)
Firm ditches Park Ave for entire floor of GM Building
Firm ditches Park Ave for entire floor of GM Building
Adam Neumann with 515 West Avenue (Wikipedia, Realtor, iStock)
No buzz, but Adam Neumann will take the $293M
No buzz, but Adam Neumann will take the $293M
Photo illustration depicting landlords being outearned by their lenders (iStock)
More multifamily landlords are making less than their lenders
More multifamily landlords are making less than their lenders
RFR's Aby Rosen and 285 Madison Avenue (RFR, iStock)
RFR seeks extension on 285 Madison loan
RFR seeks extension on 285 Madison loan
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...