Here’s why Redfin and Purplebricks shares have been sliding

The housing supply slump isn’t helping

TRD New York /
Jul.July 31, 2018 08:00 AM

Left to right: Redfin’s Glenn Kelman, a slide, and Purplebricks’ US CEO Eric Eckhardt

Investors have soured on Redfin and Purplebricks — at least for now.

Shares of both discount brokerages have taken a dive this year, as the broader housing market has posed a challenge. Even as investors and analysts bet on the longer term prospects of the companies, enthusiasm has dimmed in the the current climate.

Seattle-based Redfin has slid about 22 percent this year, though it remains above its $15 IPO price. But the main headwind is out of the company’s control: There’s not enough housing supply.

“The inventory problem could be an extended problem,” said Jason Deleeuw, an analyst at Piper Jaffray. “That’s causing the pace of home sales to be slower.”

Roughly a decade after the housing slump, the supply of available homes is low. The total inventory of homes reached its lowest recorded level at 1.48 million during the fourth quarter of 2017 — and builders are predicted to start fewer than 900,000 new homes in 2018. As a result, prices are rising faster.

For Redfin, that means slower transaction growth, even as its growth numbers have been strong, Deleeuw said. At the same time, the company has hired more agents — and, unlike traditional brokerages, pays them a salary. That expense eats into their gross margin, Deleeuw added.

In the first quarter this year, Redfin’s gross margin was 7 percent, down from 11 percent a year earlier. Its revenue climbed 33 percent to $79.9 million — but net loss widened to $36.4 million versus $28.1 million.

“Agents are hustling, but a lot of that time and energy and expense they’re deploying ends up not being fruitful,” said Tom White, an analyst at D.A. Davidson. “That’s impacted the enthusiasm of investors.”

Meanwhile, U.K.-based Purplebricks has plummeted about 31 percent this year — as its U.S. launch is proving to be a pricey endeavor. The company’s expenses for the first eight months in the U.S. were more than double that of the first eight months in Australia, real estate technology consultant Mike DelPrete said in a report. But the return on investment was a fraction of that in Australia.

The challenge is that Purplebricks chose expensive markets — New York and Los Angeles — to launch in the U.S., DelPrete said. The company, which charges sellers in the U.S. a flat fee, launched in New York after German media giant Axel Springer made a $177 million equity investment in the firm. Purplebricks said will spend $71 million of that money on its U.S. expansion, with a big chunk spent on advertising.

Purplebricks and Redfin are, of course, competitors. And, for both, market share is key. Purplebricks has overtly said that it’s focusing market share growth in the U.S. The company has expanded its footprint in California and launched in Arizona and Nevada.

As Redfin’s presence has been growing — market share ticked up 0.15 percentage points from the first quarter of 2017 — the brokerage is raising money through a stock and debt offering. Those funds may in part be used “to invest in or acquire third-party businesses, products, services, technologies or other assets,” the assets. Further growth could be what sets Redfin apart, White said.

“If Redfin can really put up some sort of dramatic market share gains, which they have shown early signs of doing, then you could see investors have increased belief in the long-term success,” he said.

Related Articles

Keeping lawns freshly cut and outdoor spaces in tip-top shape could result in greater rewards for sellers. (Credit: iStock, IMDB)

Curb your enthusiasm: Homes with spruced-up outsides sell at premium

Elsa Segura (left) was arrested in connection to realtor Monique Baugh's (right) murder (Credit: iStock)

Second suspect charged in real estate agent’s abduction, murder

Clockwise from top left: John Gomes, Ronita Kalra, Eric Beniam and McKenzie Ryan (Credit: Getty Images, iStock, Wikipedia)

“We’re putting ourselves in situations where anything is possible”: Real estate agent’s killing rattles industry

As the years go by_A look back at 17 years of real estate history

A look back at 17 years of real estate history

157 West 57th Street (Credit: iStock)

One57 condo with reduced ask tops a slow week of luxury contracts

Clockwise from top left: 730 Fifth Avenue, Unit #PH21; 730 Fifth Avenue, Unit #18A; The Pierre, Unit #3101; and The Park Imperial, Unit #64

Priciest homes listed last week include $60M pad at Crown Building

250th Issue

The Real Deal celebrates 250 issues

From left: Publisher and founder Amir Korangy, Editor-in-chief Stuart Elliott and VP of Corporate Development Yoav Barilan

TRD’s founders share war stories from over the years