Why one fifth of Manhattan storefronts are vacant

"Ghost town" and "decimated" is how residents now describe their neighborhoods

Sep.September 09, 2018 11:12 AM

(Credit: Max Pixel, Pxhere)

Despite a boom in development and tourism, life for NYC’s retailers is getting worse and worse.

Douglas Elliman’s head of retail leasing, Faith Hope Consolo, goes so far as to call it “the most challenging retail landscape in my 25 years in real estate,” as she described it in an interview with The New York Times.

Elliman’s recent survey of Manhattan found that 20 percent of storefronts were vacant, compared with the brokerage’s 2016 results that found 7 percent vacancy. Borough president Gale Brewer conducted a study last year that found 188 empty stores along Broadway Avenue alone.

The cause of retail’s tough times depends on who you ask. Mom-and-pop shops say landlords are mercilessly jacking up rents and holding out for corporate chains or new zoning changes to woo developers. But landlords told the Times they were willing to flex on lower-than-market rents, but tenants were hard to find as many retailers are increasingly hesitant to sign long-term leases. As The Real Deal has previously reported, Manhattan rents have been steadily declining.

Making matters worse, a flood of new retail space is just coming online via big developments such as the World Trade Center, Hudson Yards and Brookfield Place, as Consolo points out. Earlier this year, Mayor Bill de Blasio also openly contemplated levying a vacancy tax on landlords.

The one thing everyone can agree on is the future looks bleak. As Marty Landsman, the co-owner of a business on Canal Street put it to the Times: “I’ve been here all my life and it was never high-end, but every store was always occupied. But commercially now, it’s a decimated area.” [NYT]Erin Hudson

Related Articles

Clockwise from top left: 312 West 34th Street, 61 North 9th Street, 639 Classon Avenue, and One Fulton Square (Credit: Google Maps)

These were the top 10 NYC retail leases in July

Ricky's at 830 Broadway (Credit: NYC Go)

Ricky’s, iconic NYC beauty shop, faces
more closures

From top, clockwise: Cushman & Wakefield's Joanne Podell, Showfields' Amir Zwickel, Appear Here's Josh Yentob, Brookfield Properties's Mark Kostic (Credit: Getty, LinkedIn)

When it comes to retail, “real estate in New York is fundamentally broken”

Bed Bath & Beyond CEO Mark Tritton (Credit: Getty Images, Mike Mozart via Flickr)

Bed Bath & Beyond to invest $1B in store upgrades and buybacks

Brookfield Asset Management CEO Bruce Flatt

“We underwrite every investment like we’re going to hit a recession”: Brookfield CEO

Kitopi CEO Mohamad Ballout (Credit: Kitopi and iStock)

“Smart” kitchen and delivery startup raises $60M for US expansion

Cadre founder Ryan Williams and Allen Smith

Cadre brings on former Four Seasons CEO as president

AKS Capital Partners Managing Partners Aaron Appel and Walker & Dunlop CEO Willy Walker

Walker & Dunlop acquires Aaron Appel’s AKS Capital Partners