NYCHA’s deal with Fetner Properties for market-rate housing still hasn’t closed — two years later

Holmes Towers is its first 50/50 project

From left: Harold Fetner, Stanley Brezenoff, and a rendering of Holmes Towers at 1780 First Avenue  (Credit: Fetner and Getty Images)
From left: Harold Fetner, Stanley Brezenoff, and a rendering of Holmes Towers at 1780 First Avenue  (Credit: Fetner and Getty Images)

In 2016, the New York City Housing Authority announced plans for an Upper East Side residential project that would help pay for desperately-needed repairs. But more than two years later, the deal still hasn’t closed.

The project, with 50 percent market-rate apartments, would raise millions to fund fixes, the New York Daily News reported. But in the meantime, tenants at Holmes Towers have dealt with a string of problems in the development — and filed six complaints about elevators that stopped working.

Sign Up for the undefined Newsletter

The deal was slated to close in June, but following the Daily News’ inquiry, the Department of Housing Preservation & Development said it would be December or early next year.

“This is not a typical deal for us. We haven’t done anything like this,” spokesperson Elizabeth Rohlfing told the paper. “This is the first time and we want to do it right. I think it was just a little more complicated on both ends.”

Holmes Towers is the first of NYCHA’s planned 50/50 projects. Developers lease the land for 99 years and collect all the rent from buildings, the report said. The city tapped Fetner Properties to build a new 47-story apartment building on the Holmes Towers’ playground site. [NYDN] — Meenal Vamburkar