Who are NIMBYs anyway? Here’s what the studies say

Here’s who's most likely to show up at community meetings on new resi development

New York Weekend Edition /
Sep.September 16, 2018 12:00 PM

(Credit: Lian Chang, Pixabay)

White, older men who own homes will make up the majority of the audience at any public meeting on housing or zoning. Of that group, more than 60 percent already have their positions set before the meeting even begins–and they are against any proposal being discussed because, as they will explain, of traffic concerns.

Those are the findings of a study conducted by researchers in the Boston area that tracked participants in nearly 3,000 public meetings on housing and zoning proposals between 2015 and 2017, as reported by City Lab.

The average participant lived in their area for about 17 years and would mention their professional background—often in fields like law, architecture or engineering, and present themselves as informed parties. The highest ranking concerns besides traffic included environment, flooding and safety.

Almost 60 percent of the participants weren’t affiliated with a specific party, but for the 40 percent who were, Democrats made up the majority of the crowd while registered Republicans were the smallest group at just over 10 percent. Democrats were more likely to support new development than Republicans, however.

Researchers concluded that “the incentives to show up and oppose new housing are far stronger” than those for supporting it.

In a second study, reported by Next City, that examined racial disparities among the participants of public meetings, researchers found that about 80 percent of participants were white. They noted that “these racial disparities are far worse than they are in other forms of political participation.” [City Lab]Erin Hudson


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Celebrities like Tom Brady, Jennifer Lopez spent lockdown spurring a luxury residential boom in exclusive enclaves in Miami and Los Angeles.
What celeb buyers want during the pandemic
What celeb buyers want during the pandemic
(Getty)
Average size of home mortgage nears $400K
Average size of home mortgage nears $400K
Home prices surpass 2006 peak levels. (Getty, Unsplash, Photo Illustration by Alison Bushor for The Real Deal)
US home prices surged 9.5% in November
US home prices surged 9.5% in November
371 Clinton Street in Carroll Gardens and 6 Strong Place in Cobble Hill (Photos via Compass)
Townhouse sales dominate Brooklyn’s luxury market
Townhouse sales dominate Brooklyn’s luxury market
Gotham's Joel Picket and David Picket with 538 10th Ave. (Google Maps)
Gotham plans massive mixed-use building on Far West Side
Gotham plans massive mixed-use building on Far West Side
(iStock)
Forbearance rate stubborn among home-mortgage borrowers
Forbearance rate stubborn among home-mortgage borrowers
(Engel & Völkers Market Center, 432 Park)
Sugimoto-curated 79th floor at 432 Park quietly hits market
Sugimoto-curated 79th floor at 432 Park quietly hits market
Sharon Davis and 9 East 81 Street (Google Maps, iStock)
UES townhouse trades 40% below latest appraisal
UES townhouse trades 40% below latest appraisal
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...