Here’s one way to tell if a tower is in trouble

If appraised values are way bigger than what ratings agencies come up with, a building could be more likely to default

Feb.February 11, 2019 01:00 PM

(Credit: Moody’s Investor Service, Trepp and Unsplash)

Want to understand if a major property is at risk of defaulting on their loans? One way to tell is to look at the difference between private appraisals of the building and those done by ratings agencies.

An analysis of large commercial mortgage-backed securities deals by The Real Deal found that ratings agencies routinely shave more than 20 percent off bank appraisals in the lead-up to bond offerings. In some cases, they may shave up to 50 percent when trying to gauge the true value.

Part of the difference is that ratings agencies look at the worst possible outcomes over the course of a 10-year loan when they give a valuation, said Moody’s CMBS analyst Kevin Fagan. And, according to a recent Moody’s study of loans from years 2002 to 2007, the larger the discrepancy between appraiser values and ratings agency values, the more likely the chance of default.

“For appraisers, the market valuation is about one point in time — often tied to a sales price,” Fagan said. “For ratings agencies, we’re looking for the very stressed version of what may happen in the event of default of these loans that results in a bond loss … the higher the rating, the lower our assumed stress value.”

The root of the problem, insiders say, is a conflict of interest. Appraisers are supposed to be impartial. But they are hired and compensated by people who aren’t, which makes them vulnerable to pressure.

To see the full story from the February issue, click here.

Related Articles

With a cooling trade war, stocks perform well, including real estate. (Credit: iStock)

Real estate stocks push up this week as U.S.-China trade tensions ease

416 West 25th Street and Maverick Real Estate Partners principal David Aviram (Credit: Google Maps and LinkedIn)

Chelsea landlord claims “predatory” lender is charging a crippling interest rate as punishment after losing foreclosure case

Amazon leases nearly 154 million square feet of warehouse space compared to the 4 million square feet it owns (Credit: iStock)

How Amazon became the leasing king of e-commerce

Blackstone Chairman Stephen Schwarzman (Credit: Blackstone via YouTube)

It will make you laugh, it will make you … cringe: Blackstone’s latest holiday video

Paul Volcker (Credit: Getty Images)

Paul Volcker, Fed Chair who infuriated real estate, dies

Renderings of The William Vale and Denizen Bushwick with a Tel Aviv Stock Exchange ticker

All Year eyes sale of William Vale to pay off bonds

Redwood Trust’s CEO Christopher J. Abate (Credit: iStock)

Wall Street is collecting rent payments

From left: 1407 Broadway, 805 Third Avenue and 195 Broadway (Credit: Google Maps)

These were the 10 largest Manhattan real estate loans in November