How a homeowner association dispute racked up $1M in legal fees

HOA battles can be long, drawn-out and, for some, expensive

National /
Mar.March 23, 2019 12:00 PM

(Credit: iStock, Pixabay)

A satellite dish. A St. Francis statue in the garden. An incorrectly parked car.

It started small, but disputes over a Kansas man’s alleged violations of his homeowner association’s rules has led to a complex legal battle that is now the most expensive of its kind.

Owner Jim Hildenbrand, has been locked in conflict with the HOA of Avignon Villa Homes since he moved there in 2012, the Wall Street Journal reports.

What began with a disagreement over the placement of a satellite dish and a decorative wall has escalated into a legal back-and-forth that has cost both parties at least a combined $1 million. It is the most expensive HOA dispute in the country, the Journal found.

HOA’s provide maintenance and upkeep of properties for a monthly fee from residents. They also enforce community rules.

A 2016 investigation by the Kansas Star found that one in five people in the U.S. lives in a homeowners or condo association. Their reporting found that HOAs are often staffed by inexperienced volunteers. [WSJ] – Decca Muldowney


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Bad news for agents: Buyers warming to algorithms
Bad news for agents: Buyers warming to algorithms
Bad news for agents: Buyers warming to algorithms
Sciame Construction CEO Frank Sciame and the Gold Coast Mansion
Frank Sciame buys massive Gold Coast mansion. Now what?
Frank Sciame buys massive Gold Coast mansion. Now what?
Buyers from neighboring countries made up the biggest percentage of foreign sales. (iStock)
Here’s where foreign homebuyers came from and bought during pandemic
Here’s where foreign homebuyers came from and bought during pandemic
Nearly $10M settlement for “cooked” SF condo owners
Nearly $10M settlement for “cooked” SF condo owners
Nearly $10M settlement for “cooked” SF condo owners
From left: JP Morgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon, Citigroup CEO Jane Fraser and Texas Capital Bank CEO Rob Holmes (iStock, LowneyJen/Wikimedia, World Economic Forum/Wikimedia, Texas Capital bank)
Rise in home prices frees banks to offload mortgage risk
Rise in home prices frees banks to offload mortgage risk
Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
PHE at 51 Jay Street and 4 Hunts Lane (Compass)
Dumbo penthouse leads Brooklyn’s luxury market
Dumbo penthouse leads Brooklyn’s luxury market
605 3rd Street and Casper's Luke Sherwin (Leslie Garfield, Getty)
Firm offer: Casper co-founder pays $275K over ask in Park Slope
Firm offer: Casper co-founder pays $275K over ask in Park Slope
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...