Brooklyn developer overcharged tenants by more than $1M at new 421a building: lawsuit

Housing Rights Initiative says Jacob Neiss failed to originally register units as rent stabilized

TRD New York /
Apr.April 25, 2019 04:45 PM
74 Grand Avenue in Clinton Hill and Housing Rights Initiative founder Aaron Carr (Credit: Google Maps and Facebook)

74 Grand Avenue in Clinton Hill and Housing Rights Initiative founder Aaron Carr (Credit: Google Maps and Facebook)

Housing Rights Initiative is accusing a Brooklyn landlord of overcharging rent-stabilized tenants at a newly constructed 421a building in Clinton Hill by more than $1 million.

The tenant-advocacy group, led by Aaron Carr, organized tenants at 74 Grand Avenue to file a class action-seeking lawsuit against developer Jacob Neiss, which was delivered in Brooklyn Supreme Court Wednesday.

HRI, which over the past two-and-a-half years has organized more than 50 lawsuits against landlords alleging abuses of the state’s J-51 tax program, said this is the first step in a “421a crusade.”

“This class action is just the tip of a very dirty iceberg,” said Carr, HRI’s executive director. “The 421a tax program is riddled with fraud.”

According to the lawsuit, Neiss was required under 421a to register all 62 apartments at 74 Grand Avenue with the state’s Department of Housing and Community renewal when the building opened, and to set the initial rents in conjunction with the city’s Department of Housing Preservation and Development.

Neiss was also required to inform tenants that their apartments were subject to rent stabilization laws.

But the developer failed to set the initial rents with HPD or register the units at first, and it was only on subsequent lease renewals that Neiss did register the apartments, the suit claims. Even then, the new rents were allegedly designed to cover up previous overcharges.

Neiss did not return calls asking for comment.

The Brooklyn-based developer conceived 74 Grand Avenue as a condominium building with an initial sellout of $41.98 million, according to filings with the state Attorney General’s office. But Niess withdrew the condominium offering plan in late 2015 and decided to rent the apartments out.

HRI believes his property is one of 194 buildings that received notices from regulators in 2015 that warned developers who had ditched their condo plans that they were required to register their apartments as rent-stabilized.

The Wall Street Journal first reported the lawsuit.

The legal action, which was signed by 11 tenants, seeks to have the court invalidate any improper leases that tenants signed, and looks to recoup illegal rent increases that HRI estimates could be as much as $1 million.

Carr’s group, which has worked on dozens of lawsuits, had its first two class action filings certified in October.

And while Carr pledged more action against landlords who abuse 421a, he pointed the finger at Gov. Andrew Cuomo for what he says is a lack of will to root out fraud.

“Since our founding, we’ve been calling on Governor Cuomo to investigate the pervasive problem of tax benefit fraud,” Carr said. “But having taken more real estate contributions than any governor in the history of New York State, it appears that he has his hands tied.”

Related Articles

Zillow CEO Rich Barton (Credit: iStock)

Zillow and Opendoor aren’t making much on home-flipping

E.L. Tower at 500 South Avenue (Credit: Google Maps, iStock)

Charges dropped against tenant leader

This week, the State Department of Taxation and Finance issued a new memo that notably made no mention of condos. (Credit: iStock)

Regulators quietly change stance on condos in LLC law

40 East 72nd Street and Spiros and Antonia Milonas (Credit: Getty Images, iStock)

“Officially out of money”: Upper East Side condo in disarray

The Sand Castle apartment complex at 7-11 Seagirt Ave in Far Rockaway (Credit: Google Maps)

Queens landlords settle record $1M discrimination case

Realogy CEO Ryan Schneider (Credit: iStock)

Realogy’s plan to stop the iBuyers from gaining a foothold in Chicago

Jerome Powell and New York City construction in October 2019 (Credit: Getty Images)

The Fed lowers rates, and once again real estate is loving it

Housing and Urban Development Secretary Ben Carson (Credit: Getty Images, iStock)

HUD wants to jumpstart bank lending on low-income homes