Houlihan Lawrence fails to get dual agency lawsuit dismissed

Consent requires more than a signature on a disclosure form, the judge said

TRD TRI-STATE /
May.May 01, 2019 01:30 PM
The lawsuit claims that the 1,300-agent-strong residential brokerage makes dual agency part of its fundamental business plan (Credit: iStock)

The lawsuit claims that the 1,300-agent-strong residential brokerage makes dual agency part of its fundamental business plan (Credit: iStock)

UPDATED, May 1, 4:28 p.m.: The highest court in New York is allowing a dual-agency lawsuit against Houlihan Lawrence to move forward.

In a ruling earlier this month, the Supreme Court of the State of New York said it would let the claims about breach of fiduciary duty and deceptive or unfair sales practices to proceed. The court noted that establishing consent for dual agency requires more than a client’s signature on a disclosure form, Inman reported.

The ruling didn’t comment on the alleged agent bonuses or forged documents.

Last year, a class-action lawsuit accused Houlihan Lawrence of “predatory behavior” over its dual agency practices. The lawsuit claims that the 1,300-agent-strong residential brokerage makes dual agency part of its fundamental business plan and obscures its agents’ roles. Houlihan Lawrence also provides less disclosure than other brokerages about its agents’ dual roles, according to the lawsuit, which says the brokerage represented both sides of the deal in nine out of 10 of Houlihan Lawrence’s biggest Westchester sales.

A motion to dismiss the suit was filed in October, with the brokerage’s attorneys arguing that since the buyer and seller plaintiffs each signed statutory disclosure forms consenting to dual agency, their breach of fiduciary duty claims should be tossed.

In response, Judge Linda Jamieson referred to state law, which states, “An agent acting as a dual agent must explain carefully to both the buyer and seller that the agent is acting for the other party as well. The agent should also explain the possible effects of dual representation, including that by consenting to the dual agency relationship the buyer and seller are giving up their right to undivided loyalty.”

“By these very words … it appears that the mere signing of the [statutory disclosure] form is insufficient, and the legislature required more,” Jamieson wrote.

The ruling also noted that the lawsuit argues commonality but that the facts of every transaction are different. In a statement to Inman, Houlihan Lawrence said, ““We are pleased that the Supreme Court of the State of New York (Westchester County) has dismissed a proposed class action claim filed by a former client alleging a failure to comply with New York law on dual agency. No class has been established.”

The brokerage added that the ruling “confirms that the plaintiffs had no right of action under New York law governing dual agency relationships.”

The court dismissed claims alleging failure to provide statutory disclosure forms in a timely manner and unjust enrichment. Claims from seller plaintiffs Ellyn and Tony Berk were dismissed on a technicality, the report said. [Inman] — Meenal Vamburkar


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
(Images courtesy of Victor Group)

The Getty condo chops prices up to 53%

The Getty condo chops prices up to 53%
442 Union Street and 257 Berry Street (Google Maps)

Brooklyn’s luxury market reaches new pandemic high

Brooklyn’s luxury market reaches new pandemic high
Walker Tower at 212 West 18th Street with in-contract buyer Ron Vinder (left), and prior owner Khadem al-Qubaisi (right) (Images from JDS Development, Morgan Stanley, Pixabay)

Walker Tower board fights “low-ball” sale of 1MDB-linked penthouse

Walker Tower board fights “low-ball” sale of 1MDB-linked penthouse
Marwan Kheireddine (inset), Jennifer Lawrence and 400 East 67th Street (Getty, Compass, BDL Accelerate)

Jennifer Lawrence’s Upper East Side PH sold at 37% loss

Jennifer Lawrence’s Upper East Side PH sold at 37% loss
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (Schumer by Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images; McConnell by Ting Shen/Xinhua via Getty)

Schumer v. McConnell on SALT: Who’s gonna give?

Schumer v. McConnell on SALT: Who’s gonna give?
111 Leroy Street and 817 Fifth Avenue (StreetEasy, Google Maps)

Luxury deals plummet in Manhattan — again

Luxury deals plummet in Manhattan — again
From left: Jared Kushner, 715 Park Avenue, Deutsche Bank CEO Christian Sewing, and Rosemary Vrablic (Credits: Kushner by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP via Getty Images; 715 Park via Google Maps; Sewing by by Thomas Lohnes/Getty Images; Vrablic by PAUL LAURIE/Patrick McMullan via Getty Images)

Apartment sale to banker for Trump and Kushner probed

Apartment sale to banker for Trump and Kushner probed
Renderings of 17 Jane Street and Edward J. Minskoff (Renderings via Kristen Krajewski; Minksoff by Patrick McMullan/Patrick McMullan via Getty Images)

Minskoff sells first condo in West Village project for $22M

Minskoff sells first condo in West Village project for $22M
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...