How NYC landlords are trying to get around the new rent law

Tenants being asked to sign leases that say they went into effect before legislation was finalized

New York /
Jul.July 12, 2019 10:00 AM

Landlords are exploring “creative” ways of mitigating the impacts of the new rent law. (Credit: iStock)

It was standing room only at 1 MetroTech Center in Brooklyn on Wednesday night. More than 100 landlords and investors packed into a conference room that Marcus & Millichap scrambled to reserve after receiving a flood of registration requests.

“I hope you brought a bottle of Advil,” Belkin Burden Wenig & Goldman’s Daniel Altman told the crowd. “And we have social workers and counselors in the back.” It wasn’t long before someone from the crowd yelled, “We’ll need more than that!”

Altman, who co-led the presentation, instructed audience members to brace themselves for widespread changes in the wake of “the rent revenge act of 2019.” His colleague Alexa Englander told attendees that there is “no safe harbor” for landlords under the new rules, which affect about 1 million stabilized apartments in the city.

What landlords are trying

As lawyers carefully went through each key point of the new law, gasps or eruptions of disbelief were heard from the crowd.

But there are some routes landlords can take to juice the rents, and many are exploring “creative” options under the new law.

“A vacancy is now the only path to raise rents to the legal rent if a tenant has preferential rent,” Marcus & Millichap’s John Horowitz said. “So you’re going to see a return of buyouts.”

But a quicker workaround seems to be gaining popularity with some landlords. “We have some clients getting ‘creative’ signing leases at an earlier date, which might not hold up, and depending on the tenants, is a risk some might want to take,” said Englander.

Blaine Schwadel at Rosenberg & Estis is wary of that tactic.

“If it’s true that’s fine, but if it’s fraud — take your pick. So we’re going to lie? No. If a tenant wants to file an overcharge complaint, they know exactly when they moved in. People are outsmarting themselves.”

Though there remains some confusion, the legal community seems to agree that if a lease goes into effect before the rent laws were signed on June 14, the old rules apply. Otherwise, lawyers at Belkin Burden Wenig & Goldman suggested getting a new lease altogether.

It’s a branding problem?

After the seminar concluded, landlords stood around in groups of three or four, some yelling Margaret Thatcher quotes and others shaking their fists at Charles Barron — the Assemblymember who locked horns with Rent Stabilization Association’s Joe Strasburg during a public assembly hearing on the rent laws.

Some landlords on Wednesday night said they were frustrated the industry’s messaging.

Odin Realty’s Thomas Laskaris, who claims to own 24 apartment units, offered a cheeky approach to rehabilitating real estate’s image.

“We need a rebranding. The name ‘landlord’… it just doesn’t work,” Laskaris said. “How about ‘sweat equity general?’”

Another developer, who left his native Ukraine for Rockland County and declined to give his real name, was aghast at the changes. “Not even Karl Marx in his manifesto would have dreamed up such laws,” he said.

Sam Sarcona, senior project manager at Macklowe Properties, said that the new changes won’t necessarily hurt the landlords who were reaping the fattest profits under the previous rules. Instead, he said, small landlords will bear the brunt of the costs and larger firms will come in and clean house.

“The big corporate guys have the financing to sweep out all the little guys, buy out everyone, and put in luxury towers.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Five small landlords, represented by Randy Mastro, have sued New York attorney general Letitia James (Getty)
Lawsuit challenges New York eviction ban’s constitutionality
Lawsuit challenges New York eviction ban’s constitutionality
Redfin CEO Glenn Kelman and RentPath CEO Dhiren Fonseca (Redfin, RentPath/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
Redfin to buy RentPath for $608M
Redfin to buy RentPath for $608M
From mid-March to the end of 2020, only 11,690 units citywide were affordable to essential workers (iStock)
Affordable, market-rate apartments surge 40%, but remain rare
Affordable, market-rate apartments surge 40%, but remain rare
Manhattan and Brooklyn renters sign leases in record numbers. (Getty)
Manhattan and Brooklyn renters sign leases in record numbers
Manhattan and Brooklyn renters sign leases in record numbers
Sen. Brian Kavanagh (Getty/Illustration by Alexis Manrodt for The Real Deal)
Landlords hail relief bill as end of “cancel rent”
Landlords hail relief bill as end of “cancel rent”
(iStock/Illustration by Alexis Manrodt for The Real Deal)
Rental payments improve in February after stimulus payments
Rental payments improve in February after stimulus payments
Clockwise from left: 248 McKibbin Street, 586 Hart Street and 345 Eldert Street (Google Maps)
Carnegie Management sued for damaging non-paying tenants’ credit
Carnegie Management sued for damaging non-paying tenants’ credit
New York Community Bank's Thomas Cangemi and headquarters in Westbury, New York (Photos via Google Maps; iStock)
Dramatic reversal buoys city’s biggest multifamily bank lender
Dramatic reversal buoys city’s biggest multifamily bank lender
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...