Only in Manhattan? Luxury condo owner files “class action” because unit doesn’t have a wine cooler

The complaint claims kitchens don’t have Miele wine storage units

TRD New York /
Sep.September 13, 2019 07:00 AM
565 Broome Street (Credit: iStock and 565 Broome Street)

565 Broome Street (Credit: iStock and 565 Broome Street)

Across the city, residents sometimes have to tussle with landlords to make sure they are getting basic necessities like heat and hot water.

But at 565 Broome Street, a luxury development in Soho, one resident is fighting to make sure they get their state-of-the-art wine cooler.

Ayal Martin Hayes, who through an LLC bought the $3.6 million unit at the development, alleges in a new lawsuit that buyers-to-be were promised the specialty coolers, which were supposed to be integrated into at least some of the kitchens’ white oak cabinetry. Instead, the owner’s kitchen is missing the feature.

“This devalues the kitchen and the apartment; particularly to wine enthusiasts,” states the complaint, a class-action lawsuit filed Wednesday in New York County Supreme Court.

In an emailed statement, a spokesperson for 565 Broome said the sponsor has provided “multiple options” to deal with the issue.

“This lawsuit, which is being filed by one person over not having a $2,200 wine cooler, is frivolous and completely without merit… We look forward to vigorously responding to this issue in court,” the spokesperson said.

Hayes couldn’t be reached for comment, and the plaintiff’s attorney, Joseph Colbert, did not immediately reply to a message seeking comment.

Hayes bought the 12th-floor, 1,447-square-foot pad in April. In advertisements and in the condo’s offering plan, some units, such as the owner’s two-bedroom, two-and-a-half bath condo, were supposed to come equipped with the integrated wine coolers, the complaint says.

The complaint only lists the single owner as a plaintiff, but it was filed as a class-action lawsuit intended to cover any purchasers impacted by the lack of wine coolers.

Bizzi & Partners Development, Aronov Development and Halpern Real Estate Ventures developed the Renzo Piano-designed project, which is comprised of two glass towers standing 30 stories tall. The building’s amenities include a 55-foot indoor swimming pool, fitness center and spa.

Former Uber CEO Travis Kalanick snapped up a $36.4 million penthouse at the property, and tennis star Novak Djokovic purchased two condos in the tower in 2017.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Clockwise from left: John D. Rockefeller, Izzy Englander, Steven Mnuchin, David Koch, Jacqueline Bouvier, and William Zeckendorf (Credit: Getty Images and StreetEasy)

For 15 years, David Koch lived at the world’s “richest building”

At $225M, Bel Air’s Casa Encantada becomes America’s priciest listing

993 Fifth Avenue and Gilbert Harrison (Credit: Google Maps and GLC)

Retail exec sells Fifth Avenue co-op to Chanel heir for $19M

Kuwaiti royal was defrauded of $160M investment in Mountain of Beverly Hills: lawsuit

Clockwise from left: 240 Riverside Boulevar with  Charles Zegar, 111 Murray Street, and 220 Central Park South (Credit: Google Maps, Getty Images, and CityRealty)

Here are some of the Big Apple’s recent luxury resi buys

Millionaires’ fortunes are shrinking. Here’s what that means for real estate

15 Hudson Yards (Credit: Related-Oxford, iStock)

First he sold a plot of land to Hudson Yards’ developers. Now he owns 7 luxury condos there

Judith and Rudy Giuliani Rudolph and Judith Giuliani are divorcing after 16 years. (Credit: Getty Images, Trulia, Highrises)

Luxury properties at play in Rudy Giuliani’s ugly divorce

arrow_forward_ios