FiDi landlord violated rent stabilization regs for years: lawsuit

10 Hanover Square has 500 units but none of them was listed as rent-stabilized as of June, according to the suit

TRD New York /
Oct.October 04, 2019 12:00 PM
10 Hanover Square (Credit: Google Maps)

10 Hanover Square (Credit: Google Maps)

This page was last updated Oct. 7 at 8 a.m.

Two tenants at a building in the Financial District are suing their landlord over alleged violations of New York’s rent stabilization laws.

Bruce Hackney and Timothy Smith, who live at 10 Hanover Square, are suing their landlord UDR Inc., saying it violated the 421-g tax benefits program, which provides tax breaks for landlords but also requires — according to a recent court ruling — that tenants get rent-stabilized leases.

The two men say they did not receive a rent-stabilized lease when they moved into their apartment, and they have not been provided with rent-stabilized renewals, either, according to the suit.

“A rent-stabilized lease is like a unicorn,” said Hackney, “and if you have an opportunity to corral a unicorn and capture a unicorn, you do it.”

The building has almost 500 units, but as of June, none of them was listed as rent-stabilized in UDR’s tax filings, the lawsuit says. A state judge had previously ruled that UDR could use luxury deregulation to exempt units at 10 Hanover Square from New York’s rent stabilization program, and the decision was upheld on appeal. However, on June 25 the state’s highest court ruled against this interpretation, paving the way for the lawsuit by Hackney and Smith.

Landlords who receive 421-g benefits now must provide their tenants with riders explaining what the tax credit is and when it expires. If the riders aren’t included the tenants are entitled to rent-stabilized leases for as long as they live in their apartment, according to court papers. The suit claims that Hackney and Smith are entitled to a rent-stabilized lease for the rest of the time they stay in their apartment.

The apartments are also not registered with the Division of Housing and Community Renewal even though they are supposed to be, the lawsuit says. This was “part of a fraudulent scheme to deregulate the apartments in the building,” according to the suit.

Hackney and Smith are asking the court to provide them with financial relief and prevent UDR from continuing to violate New York’s rent laws.

Representatives for UDR did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The news site the City first reported on Hackney and Smith’s living situation, writing in August that they had been preparing to move out of their $4,700 one-bedroom apartment until getting a letter this year saying they would be eligible for a rent-stabilized lease under the 421-g program. The 1990s-era abatement was created to help convert downtown office buildings into residential buildings.

Lucas Ferrara, an attorney at Newman Ferrara and adjunct professor at New York Law School, is representing the tenants.

“Unfortunately, this is just more of the same old, same old,” he said. “Yet another major landlord caught red-handed, sidestepping New York City’s rent regulation because of its avaricious motivations.”

But Sherwin Belkin, a landlords’ attorney not involved in the UDR case, argued that the property owner’s position was reasonable, given that it was twice upheld unanimously by the Appellate Division before the Court of Appeals ruled 6-1 against it.

Related Articles

Blackstone CEO Steven Schwartzman and Stuyvesant Town (Credit: Getty Images)

After authorities vowed review of Stuy Town deal, Blackstone changes course on vacancies

Real Capital Analytics data showed that New York’s multifamily market had a very slow July. (Credit: iStock)

New NYC rent law “beginning to shut down investment”

Some landlords say they plan to close the door to vacant apartments and wait for the laws to change (Credit: iStock)

Creative ways NYC landlords are getting around the new rent rules

Donald Trump and Dean & Deluca's Soho location (Credit: Getty Images, iStock)

Trump Organization sues Dean & DeLuca over rent defaults

Natasha Page and Jason Walker

Lawsuit: Douglas Elliman broker called me a “mulatto”

Aby Rosen and Lever House at 390 Park Avenue (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

Aby Rosen says Tod Waterman stabbed him in back on Lever House deal

Clockwise from left: 5203-5207 Church Avenue in Brooklyn, 119-40 Metropolitan Avenue in Queens, 855 East 217th Street in the Bronx and 31-35 Steinway Street in Queens (Credit: Google Maps)

Going Once, Going Twice! Portfolio of rent-stabilized properties hits auction block

E.L. Tower at 500 South Avenue (Credit: Google Maps, iStock)

Charges dropped against tenant leader