More rent-law fallout: Landlords back off “absentee” tenants

Major real estate law firms see fewer non-primary residence cases

New York /
Oct.October 09, 2019 07:00 AM
Cases to challenge tenant residency have declined since June (Credit: iStock)

Cases to challenge tenant residency have declined since June (Credit: iStock)

Cases brought against rent-stabilized tenants who allegedly live elsewhere have become a thing of the past.

The reason is the new rent law, according to its proponents and critics alike.

Rent-stabilized apartments are required to be a primary residence. But enforcement is largely left to landlords, who can go to court to evict a tenant not living in a unit full-time. Landlords’ reward was a 20 percent rent increase and the chance to make renovations that substantially boost the rent even more, but the sweeping law passed in June wiped out those incentives.

“Now, clients don’t want to litigate a case where there’s no upside,” Rosenberg and Estis attorney Blaine Schwadel said. “So why bother?”

Schwadel said two of his clients abandoned non-primary residence cases the week after the rent law passed, part of a broad decline in such actions. Prior to the changes to the rent law, he said, it was common for landlords to check tenants’ residency even before buying a building, because “who [tenants] are and whether they’re going to stay affects the value of the building.”

“Back in the day, in the early 2000s, we had at any point in time 30 to 50 pending cases,” said Jeffrey Goldman, a partner at Belkin Burden Wenig and Goldman, which represents landlords. “Are those the kind of numbers now? Definitely not.”

Sam Himmelstein, an attorney whose firm Himmelstein, McConnell, Gribben, Donoghue and Joseph attorney represents tenants, said that before 1994, when vacancy became a way to remove a unit from rent regulation, “landlords never really cared if an apartment was a tenants’ primary residence.” But when vacancy decontrol was passed, that all changed.

“In the 1990s and 2000s I was in court on five non-prime [residency] cases a week,” Himmelstein said. “Now, I think I have two total. They’re just not there.”

Landlords who wanted to investigate rent-stabilized tenants would call their attorneys, who in turn would tap private investigators. Private investigator John Leto said his firm, JL and Associates, used a wide array of techniques to spot tenants who weren’t really living in their rent-regulated apartment.

Leto’s 31 investigators would scour databases, glean addresses from mail, install cameras outside apartments and even pose as potential subletters to record conversations. Most of the time, Leto said, those efforts succeeded.

“There’s always three sides to the story. What they allege, what the facts are and what we find out,” Leto said. “It’s like a divorce. If one party suspects there’s something going on … usually something’s going on.”

The residency requirement is intended to ensure that rent-regulated units do not serve as pieds-à-terre or sublets. Under the new law, the 20 percent vacancy bonus is gone, rent increases for improvements are limited to $83 a month until the expense is reimbursed, and it is nearly impossible to deregulate an apartment.

Real estate attorneys call the end of non-primary residency cases an “unintended consequence” of the rent law, but tenant advocates say it isn’t so bad for them.

Esteban Girón of the Crown Heights Tenant Union said he often saw landlords bring such cases to stop tenants from organizing. In his own building, key fobs and security cameras were used to “provide evidence for non-primary residence cases,” according to Girón, who was among scores of tenants arrested at a June 4 demonstration in Albany.

“I was getting my ass arrested in Albany to destroy their whole business model from the root,” Girón said. “Totally worth losing the key fob fight, I believe!”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
 Justice Sandra Sciortino and Newburgh mayor Torrance Harvey (Facebook, Daniel Case, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons)
“Good cause eviction” struck down in Newburgh
“Good cause eviction” struck down in Newburgh
City Council Member Robert Holden (Getty)
Bill would expose Council members’ rent-stabilized status
Bill would expose Council members’ rent-stabilized status
From left: Hudson Valley Property's Richard Lanzarone, Attorney General Letitia James, Belkind Burden Goldman’s Matthew Brett, and Kingston Mayor Steve Noble (Kingston, Belkind Burden Goldman, Getty, LinkedIn)
Kingston rent stabilization blocked, possibly for good
Kingston rent stabilization blocked, possibly for good
Equity Apartments' Sam Zell and 155 Washington St Ste A in Jersey City (Equity Apartments, 
Getty)
Sam Zell’s hard lesson about Jersey City rent control
Sam Zell’s hard lesson about Jersey City rent control
CHIP's Jay Martin and HCR Commissioner RuthAnne Visnauskas (Getty)
Lies, damn lies, and statistics: Did rent-stabilized vacancies really fall?
Lies, damn lies, and statistics: Did rent-stabilized vacancies really fall?
For the Many’s Brahvan Ranga (For the Many, Getty)
Kingston tenants score New York’s first rent rollback
Kingston tenants score New York’s first rent rollback
From left: Landlord attorney Sherwin Belkin and Housing Rights Initiative executive director Aaron Carr (Getty, NYC Department of Finance, Housing Rights Initiative)
Tenants predict wins in 421a overcharge suits. Landlords beg to differ
Tenants predict wins in 421a overcharge suits. Landlords beg to differ
Hudson Valley Property Owners Association's Richard Lanzarone and Kingston Mayor Steve Noble (LinkedIn, City of Kingston, Getty)
Landlords sue to stop Kingston rent stabilization
Landlords sue to stop Kingston rent stabilization
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...