Lawsuit over WTC design is whittled down

Judge takes dim view of architect’s claims but lets three proceed

TRD New York /
Oct.October 14, 2019 08:00 AM
The architect claims the design, construction and marketing of the tower rips off the design of a tower he planned and modeled for his thesis

The architect claims the design, construction and marketing of the tower rips off the design of a tower he planned and modeled for his thesis

The copyright infringement suit over the design of One World Trade Center has survived an effort to kill it, but not by much.

A recently unveiled judge’s ruling preserved three claims of a case that stems from an architectural student’s design years before 9/11 attacks that led to the massive tower’s construction.

Georgia-based architect Jeehoon Park in 2017 sued four giants: architectural firm Skidmore Owings & Merrill, Tishman Construction and the tower’s developers, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey and The Durst Organization.

Park claimed the design, construction and marketing of the tower ripped off a design he planned and modeled for his thesis at the Illinois Institute of Technology in 1999. He said his thesis adviser was an associate partner at SOM and a second senior partner from the architectural firm also reviewed his work.

Manhattan Judge Richard Sullivan granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss many of Park’s claims but allowed three to move into discovery. Park’s lawyer, Daniel Kent, called it “a big step forward.”

“Judge Sullivan recognized the obvious and substantial similarity between Mr. Park’s design and the infringing building,” he wrote in an email. “The Court could have dismissed all of Mr. Park’s claims, but did not, and the remaining claims appear to have significant value.”

The judge, however, wrote in a September order that these claims survive “only by the skin of their teeth, owing principally to the highly deferential standards on a motion to dismiss.”

A spokesperson for the architectural firm said in a statement, “While it is positive that so much of the case was dismissed, SOM is still in the position of having to defend itself against these specious claims.”

The claims still in play relate to the defendants’ use of allegedly infringing images throughout construction, leasing and the selling of tickets to One World Observatory; and in the sale of souvenirs, such as models of the tower. Kent noted that Park could still appeal the dismissals at the end of the case.

The SOM spokesperson called it “inexplicable” that “Park filed his suit after Tower One was completed and a full decade after the building’s design was first unveiled.”

Durst and Port Authority did not respond to requests for comment.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Anna Wintour of Condé Nast, One World Trade Center and Douglas Durst (Wintour by Dia Dipasupil/Getty Images; 1WTC via iStock; Durst by Patrick McMullan via Getty Images)

Condé Nast wants out at 1WTC. Durst may not be OK with that

Condé Nast wants out at 1WTC. Durst may not be OK with that
Durst Organization chairman Douglas Durst and Advance Publications president Donald Newhouse with One World Trade Center (Newhouse by Ilya S. Savenok/Getty Images for The Association for Frontotemporal Degeneration; Unsplash)

Condé Nast may be moving out of 1 WTC

Condé Nast may be moving out of 1 WTC
Moody's CEO Raymond McDaniel and 1 World Trade Center (McDaniel by Alex Wong/Getty Images; Pixabay)

Moody’s looks to sublease its 1 WTC office

Moody’s looks to sublease its 1 WTC office
Robert Durst (Photo by Alex Gallardo-Pool/Getty Images)

Pandemic pushes back Robert Durst murder trial yet again

Pandemic pushes back Robert Durst murder trial yet again
4 Times Square (Google Maps, TikTok)

What happens if Trump banishes TikTok, savior of NYC’s office market?

What happens if Trump banishes TikTok, savior of NYC’s office market?
From left: Port Authority Bus Terminal, Grand Central and Penn Station (Wikipedia, Pixabay, CDC)

TRD Insights: Focus may shift to Manhattan’s 3 transport hubs in post-Covid office market

TRD Insights: Focus may shift to Manhattan’s 3 transport hubs in post-Covid office market
Durst Organization chairman Douglas Durst and Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos with 1133 Sixth Avenue (Getty, Google Maps)

Another blow to Amazon in court battle with Durst Organization

Another blow to Amazon in court battle with Durst Organization
A rendering of the site at 44-02 Vernon Boulevard in Long Island City and Douglas Durst

Owners of LIC’s “Lake Vernon” notch win in tug-of-war with Durst

Owners of LIC’s “Lake Vernon” notch win in tug-of-war with Durst
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...