Landlords of the world, unite?

New statewide coalition is real estate industry’s version of grassroots organizing

TRD New York /
Dec.December 13, 2019 09:30 AM
New York Capital Region Apartment Association spokesperson Jaime Cain (Credit: iStock, Boylan Code)

Real estate attorney and Under One Roof NY spokesperson Jaime Cain (Credit: iStock, Boylan Code)

A new statewide alliance of landlords called Under One Roof NY is hoping to open some doors in Albany.

The group represents some 1,500 upstate and New York City landlords, according to its spokesperson, Rochester-based real estate attorney Jaime Michelle Cain. It includes property management firms and landlord groups from the capital region and southern New York, as well as national and New York City-based landlord lobby groups.

The coalition aims to fill a gap that facilitated the passage of a tenant-friendly rent law in June, when downstate legislators dismissed the concerns of constituent landlords and upstate lawmakers barely heard from theirs.

The New York Capital Region Apartment Association, one of the groups anchoring the coalition, recently organized a packed event at a Utica casino where upstate landlords discussed lobbying strategies and potential litigation to challenge the state’s new rent law, as well as membership dues. The formation of this coalition appears to be the group’s first concrete step toward statewide organizing.

Its first priority is to snuff out Brooklyn Sen. Julia Salazar’s bill to establish good-cause eviction, a hot-button issue for landlords across the state. The legislation would prevent landlords from evicting tenants for nonpayment of rent that has been raised by more than 1.5 times the consumer price index.

“We intend to provide the legislature with specific revisions to text in the laws,” said Cain. “We’re focused on educating them and giving them real data. Landlords are here because they have an economic interest in their neighborhoods. We don’t want to see good and responsible landlords exiting the market.”

The group has a $30,000 grant from the National Apartment Association, an umbrella group representing owners. The NAA is one of five national groups providing financial support for a lawsuit brought by two New York City landlord organizations — Community Housing Improvement Program and the Rent Stabilization Association — challenging the constitutionality of New York’s new rent law.

Other members include the Chemung County Landlords Association; the Institute of Real Estate Management Chapter 58, which represents building management workers in Rochester; Capital Region Chamber, the largest chamber of commerce in the Capital region; the Park Avenue Landlord Association of Rochester; Glendale Communities, a Western New York property manager; and WEBB Rentals.

CHIP's Jay Martin

CHIP’s Jay Martin

“What brought us all together is this drive for universal rent control,” said Jay Martin, executive director of the Community Housing Improvement Program, an Under One Roof member. “We’re all against just-cause eviction and universal rent control.”

Still, the upstate and New York City groups don’t see eye-to-eye on everything: Cain said the upstate groups are not looking to help fund the constitutional challenge. But Martin indicated that will not divide them.

“I’m under no illusion we’re going to be able to solve that chasm,” said Martin. “We’re looking for areas of mutual agreement.”

Related Articles

250 Fort Washington Ave and 310 Convent Avenue with Housing Rights Initiative’s Aaron Carr (Credit: iStock, Facebook, Google Maps)

Two more rent-overcharge lawsuits get class-action status

Clipper Equity's David Bistricer (inset) and the US Supreme Court (Credit: RealInsight and Getty Images)

US Supreme Court denies Clipper’s rent regulation petition

Edgar Moncayo (inset) and his property at 32-42 102nd Street (Credit: Google Maps)

Queens landlord dies after tenant knocks him down stairs: police

Sen. Michael Gianaris and Long Island City (NY Senate, Wikipedia)

“Amazon killer” Gianaris wants to overhaul subsidy programs that could have net billions for HQ2

Judge Janet DiFiore and attorney Deborah Riegel (Credit: North Country Public Radio and Rosenberg & Estis)

High court hearing rent overcharge cases puts lawyers on the spot

The drop in evictions may be a result of confusion over the implementation of the law. CHIP's Jay Martin (inset) (Credit: iStock and Twitter)

Evictions fell 18 percent in NYC after rent law passed

(Credit: Getty Images, iStock)

Small Talk: Real Estate Predictions for 2020

From left: Manhattan state Sen. Brad Hoylman, Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, Governor Andrew Cuomo, Assemblymember Harvey Epstein and Senator Julia Salazar  (Credit: Getty Images)

Five ways that Albany could punish real estate in 2020