Analysts still baffled by Brookfield’s big bet on malls

Brookfield Property REIT’s shares have dropped by 13 percent since its purchase of General Growth

Dec.December 23, 2019 03:30 PM
Brookfield CEO Brian Kingston and Garden State Plaza in New Jersey (Credit: Brookfield, Westfield Garden State)

Brookfield CEO Brian Kingston and Garden State Plaza in New Jersey (Credit: Brookfield, Westfield Garden State)

Brookfield Asset Management’s massive investment in malls is looking worse than ever to some observers.

Since its nearly $15 billion acquisition of General Growth Properties in 2018, Brookfield Property Real Estate Investment Trust, a publicly traded vehicle formed after the purchase, has seen its shares decline by 13 percent, the Wall Street Journal reported. The second-largest mall owner in the country, GGP’s portfolio includes 125 buildings — mostly malls.

According to an analysis by Green Street Advisors, Brookfield’s assigned valuation of the GGP portfolio suggests a cap rate in line with malls rated A+ or higher, which may be out of step with the reality of the holdings, more than half of which Green Street rated at B+ or lower.

Brookfield disagreed with Green Street’s assessment, citing its tenants’ high sales per square foot, and defended its investment in shopping malls. “This is part of our strategy in that we’re contrarian investors,” said Brian Kingston, chief executive of Brookfield Property Partners. “This is what it always feels like.”

According to the Journal, Brookfield approached prior institutional investors about buying stakes in other malls, but didn’t get any bites. The investors were concerned about renovation costs and further store closures, the paper reported.

The retail sector has continued its decline since Brookfield’s historic investment, with major tenants Sears Holdings Corp. and Forever 21 among the growing list of retailers who filed for bankruptcy and announced plans to close stores, while J.C. Penney Co., Gap Inc. and Macy’s Inc. saw their shares decline after dismal earnings reports. Meanwhile, investors are requesting to pull $5 billion in commitments to Trumbull Property Fund, a $20 billion investment fund, after it wrote down the value of its retail assets.

Other institutional investors, including Blackstone, have avoided the asset class altogether, instead making bets on logistics space.

Brookfield, though, isn’t shy about experimenting with its retail properties. It bought a series of retail storefronts on Bleecker Street in Manhattan in 2018 for $31.5 million and has been trying new strategies. [WSJ] — Georgia Kromrei

Related Articles

Abercrombie and Fitch CEO Fran Horowitz and an aerial view of 600 Broadway, blocked by 606 Broadway (Credit: Getty Images, Google Maps)

The curious case of 600 Broadway

Opening Ceremony founders Humberto Leon and Carol Lim and the brand's Soho location at 35 Howard Street (Credit: Getty Images, Google Maps)  

Opening Ceremony is the latest Soho retailer to close

Town & Country Crossing in Town & Country, MO; The Crossroads in Royal Palm Beach, FL; and Mission Bay Plaze in Boca Raton, FL

Here’s why open-air strip centers are outperforming enclosed malls

The Wizarding World of Harry Potter (Credit: Getty Images)

Harry Potter-themed store probably won’t get its dragon

591-593 Broadway (Credit: Google Maps)  

Another pricey retail building in Soho is up for sale

675 Eighth Avenue (Credit: Google Maps and Chik-fil-A)

Chick-fil-A is arriving at The Hive in Times Square

The Eugene at 435 West 31st Street and Brookfield's Ric Clark (Credit: StreetEasy and Brookfield)

Brookfield scores $479M refi on Manhattan West resi tower

Time Out Market at 916 West Fulton Market and Revival Food Hall at 125 S. Clark Street 

Does Chicago still have an appetite for food halls?