Unsettling news for landlords: Online retailers killed it this holiday season

Holiday spending increased 3.4 percent from Nov. 1 to Dec. 24, one report found

TRD NATIONAL /
Dec.December 27, 2019 02:15 PM
Holiday spending was up this year — especially online (Credit: iStock)

Holiday spending was up this year — especially online (Credit: iStock)

Americans spent more money than ever this holiday season — but shoppers are increasingly doing so online.

Overall retail spending jumped 3.4 percent over the holidays, according to a recent report from Mastercard. But the biggest gains came from shopping on e-commerce platforms, as online purchases made up 14.6 percent of the sales. That’s an increase of 18.8 percent over last year.

It’s undeniable that the rise of online shopping has taken a toll on slow-to-adapt retailers. So far in 2019, U.S. retailers have moved to close 9,275 stores this year, a figure that has far exceeded the store closures of 2018, according to the latest store tracker report from data firm Coresight Research.

Charlotte Russe, a discount young women’s apparel store that mostly has stores in enclosed malls, acknowledged it failed to balance its need for a strong online presence when it filed for bankruptcy earlier this year. The move led to hundreds of store closures.

Still, the trend toward online shopping doesn’t mean outright doom-and-gloom in the world of brick-and-mortar.

Anjee Solanki, the national director of retail services USA for Colliers International, told The Real Deal that consumers tend to spend more when shopping in-store than online. Web-based brands are also increasingly opening physical storefronts to better deal with competition, too.

“It’s no wonder that some e-commerce brands are shifting to brick-and-mortar to protect their profit margins,” she said.

Partly due to a later than usual Thanksgiving holiday, retailers in 2019 opted for an omnichannel approach by meeting consumer demand at physical locations as well as online, said Steve Sadove, senior advisor for Mastercard and former CEO and chairman of Saks Incorporated.

The National Retail Federation’s early December report found that over 189 million Americans — the most ever recorded, and 14 percent more than last year — shopped from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday. In fact, the spending done on Cyber Monday, where shoppers can take advantage of online deals, made up a sizable chunk of total holiday retail sales this year. Purchases that day comprised almost a quarter of the purchases, according to Mastercard’s figures. That’s compared to 15.4 percent on Black Friday, per Mastercard, which tracked sales from Nov. 1 to Dec. 24.

Meanwhile, the NRF found that over the five-day Thanksgiving weekend period it tracked, 124 million people shopped in stores, 142.2 million shopped online, and about 76 million did both.

Americans also spent more than they had in prior years. Shoppers on average shelled out almost $362 over those five days, a 16 percent spike from 2018, according to the NRF.

One online retailer that did particularly well this holiday season was Amazon. The e-commerce giant on Thursday said that the number of items delivered with Prime free one-day and Prime free same-day shipping quadrupled from last year, and the most popular items stemmed from the toys, fashion, home and beauty departments. Amazon said customers ordered more than 500 million items from those categories.

Department stores lagged this year, as these stores saw a 1.8 percent drop in retail sales, according to Mastercard. And while shopping on department store websites increased 6.9 percent, that was the lowest growth among the categories Mastercard tracked.

Overall, apparel companies, which had seen a wave of bankruptcies and store closures this year, saw a 1 percent year-over-year bump in purchases and a 17 percent growth in online purchases — the highest growth among the groups Mastercard monitored.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Ex-Barneys CEO Daniella Vitale (Credit: Getty Images, Google Maps)

Barneys’ lights still on, but workers left in dark

Faith Hope Consolo (Credit: Getty Images, iStock)

The real story behind Faith Hope Consolo’s glamorous life

Sen. Michael Gianaris and Long Island City (NY Senate, Wikipedia)

“Amazon killer” Gianaris wants to overhaul subsidy programs that could have net billions for HQ2

Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos, 1133 Sixth Avenue and Douglas Durst (Credit: Getty Images)

Durst prevails in $21M lawsuit over soured Amazon deal

Savanna's Chris Schlank and One Court Square (Credit: iStock)

One Court Square recapitalized in $880M deal

Bed Bath & Beyond (Credit: Getty Images)

Bed Bath & Beyond is selling its real estate to private equity

Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos (Credit: Getty Images, iStock, Wikipedia)

New York’s initial offer to Amazon included $2.5B of incentives

Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos with 410 Tenth Avenue and 1251 Sixth Avenue with Mitsui Fudosan America’s John Westerfield (Credit: Google Maps, Getty Images, Wikipedia)

Amazon’s West Side deal tops list of Manhattan’s biggest December office leases

arrow_forward_ios
Loading...