For retailers, bankruptcy more likely to end in liquidation

Fitch Ratings has J.C. Penney, Fresh Market and J. Crew on watch list

Jan.January 23, 2020 02:30 PM
A report found that 45 percent of retailer bankruptcies over the past 15 years led to liquidation (Credit: iStock)

A report found that 45 percent of retailer bankruptcies over the past 15 years led to liquidation (Credit: iStock)

Nearly half of the major retailers that filed for bankruptcy protection over the past 15 years eventually shuttered all of their stores, Fitch Ratings found in a report.

Of 55 retail and supermarket bankruptcies, 25 were liquidated, the report showed.

Meanwhile, bankruptcies among all U.S. companies led to liquidation just 13 percent of the time, according to the Wall Street Journal, which covered the Fitch research.

Brick-and-mortar stores are facing mounting challenges from online retailers and changing consumer behavior. Fitch also found that retailers are struggling with high debt loads, leases and interest payments, the Journal reported.

Major retailers that have liquidated and shuttered — or will shutter — all of their locations include Toys ‘R’ Us, discount shoe store Payless and high-end department store Barneys New York.

Fitch is watching nine retailers that it believes are at risk of bankruptcy or default on loans or bonds: J.C. Penney, Fresh Market, J. Crew, Fairway Market — which filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection Thursday — Serta Simmons Bedding and Ann Taylor parent Ascena Retail Group, according to the Journal.

Fairway’s filing came a day after the supermarket chain disputed a report in the New York Post that it was filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy and preparing to close all 14 of its stores. Chapter 7 bankruptcy signals a company is dissolving, while Chapter 11 allows a company to shed debts and restructure.

Fairway said it has a stalking horse bid from Village Super Market to buy up to five of its New York City supermarkets and Fairway’s distribution center for $70 million.

Other major retailers that announced plans to close scores of stores this month are clothing store Express and home goods chain Pier 1 Imports. Express this week said it will close 100 stores by 2022, and greeting-card store Papyrus said 254 stores will go dark. Pier 1 is shuttering 450 locations. [WSJ] — Mary Diduch

Related Articles

Pier 1 store (Credit: Google Maps)

Pier 1 files for bankruptcy, seeks sale

Macy’s Herald Square (Credit: iStock)

Macy’s new skyscraper missing one key thing

Simon Property Group CEO David Simon and Brookfield Property Partners CEO Brian Kingston (Credit: Getty Images)

Done deal: Forever 21 sold to Simon, Brookfield venture for $81M

Forever 21 cancels auction (Credit: Getty Images)

Forget the Forever 21 auction: Simon Property Group, Brookfield to buy retailer

The Strand at 828 Broadway and Book Culture at 450 Columbus Avenue (Credit: Wikipedia, Google Maps)

Strand to take over former Book Culture location on UWS

Macy's CEO Jeff Gennette and the Herald Square location (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

Macy’s to close 125 stores, slash 2K jobs

Simon Property CEO David Simon and Forever 21 (Credit: Getty Images)

Forever 21 takeover group plans to keep struggling retailer open

From left: Authentic Brands Group CEO Jamie Salter, Simon Property Group CEO David Simon, and Forever 21 CEO Do Won Chang (Credit: Getty Images)

Forever 21 will sell to Simon, Brookfield-led partnership at bargain-basement price