Latest landlord lawsuit claims rent law violates Fair Housing Act

Randy Mastro, a deputy mayor in the Giuliani administration, argues that minorities are hurt by statute

New York /
Jan.January 27, 2020 02:41 PM
Randy Mastro (Credit: Getty Images)

Randy Mastro (Credit: Getty Images)

Another group of landlords has filed a lawsuit challenging New York’s new rent law, hiring Randy Mastro to argue that the statute hurts minority tenants as well as property owners.

Mastro, a former deputy mayor in the Giuliani administration who is now at Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, argues in a 77-page federal complaint that the law passed in Albany last June expands an unfair advantage for rich tenants, in violation of federal law.

The case was brought by G-Max Management, Green Valley Realty, Siljay Holding, Jane Ordway, Dexter Guerrieri, and eight other landlords who collectively own 14 buildings with 375 units, most of them rent-regulated. This is at least the fourth lawsuit to challenge the law, which went into effect in June.

Attorney General Letitia James (Credit: Getty Images)

Attorney General Letitia James (Credit: Getty Images)

It names as defendants the state of New York, Attorney General Letitia James and RuthAnne Visnauskas, the Cuomo administration’s top regulator of rent-stabilized housing; as well as the governments of New York City, Yonkers and Westchester County.

“The only real winners here will be the wealthy white tenants who, according to U.S. Census Bureau data, already disproportionately benefit from rent regulation, and who are now poised to receive a massive windfall at the expense of minority renters who will be frozen out of historically majority-white neighborhoods,” the complaint says.

RuthAnne Visnauskas

HCR Commissioner RuthAnne Visnauskas

It continues, “By exacerbating the law’s disparate impact, the [law] perpetuates residential racial segregation in New York and negatively impacts the diversity of New York rental housing, harming owners, tenants, and the community as a whole, in violation of the federal Fair Housing Act.”

The lawsuit also cites all the other arguments against the law that landlords have made in court filings and in the court of public opinion: That its drastic reductions in allowable rent increases for repairs and renovations, and the removal of the primary ways to remove apartments from rent regulation, amount to an illegal taking of owners’ property.

It also argues that many landlords bought their properties with an expectation based on the law that they would eventually be able to remove them from rent regulation. But the new law closed off virtually all paths to deregulation and was made permanent, unlike preceding versions, which had expiration dates and required the government to certify that a “housing emergency” remained in effect.

The federal lawsuits against the rent law could take years to resolve, and could be taken up together at some point by the Supreme Court.

The new suit’s argument about disproportionate benefits is a criticism of the city’s rent regulation that has been made for years: That units with the most discounted rent — compared to what they would fetch on the open market — are in prime Manhattan neighborhoods and largely occupied by white tenants with healthy incomes. Supporters of the system say its benefits to low-income tenants outweigh its imperfections.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Asbury Park, New Jersey (iStock)
Asbury Park residents choose less stringent rent control
Asbury Park residents choose less stringent rent control
Assembly member Pamela Hunter and Sen. Julia Salazar (Facebook, Getty)
Next up: Coalition pushes for good cause eviction
Next up: Coalition pushes for good cause eviction
All in all, the $212 billion budget is a mixed bag for the industry. (Getty/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
Real estate’s wins and losses in new state budget
Real estate’s wins and losses in new state budget
Seth Hoy of Manhattan Legal Services with with 74 Post Avenue. (Google Maps, LinkedIn)
Inwood tenants claim landlord using blaze to hike rents
Inwood tenants claim landlord using blaze to hike rents
Vincent Viola and 2 Pierrepont Street (Getty, Google Maps)
Lawsuit accusing Vincent Viola of violating rent laws can proceed
Lawsuit accusing Vincent Viola of violating rent laws can proceed
Gotham's Joel Pickett and Gotham West. (Gotham)
Gotham faces rent overcharge lawsuit in Hell’s Kitchen
Gotham faces rent overcharge lawsuit in Hell’s Kitchen
In an unintended consequence of New York’s 2019 rent-stabilization law, landlords are leaving cheap units off the market. (Getty)
Why affordable housing sits empty
Why affordable housing sits empty
A Manhattan judge dismissed a lawsuit from five New York City landlords to overturn the rent reforms. (Getty)
Judge says landlords have no constitutional right to “unregulated market”
Judge says landlords have no constitutional right to “unregulated market”
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...