Brokers, landlords exploiting rent-law uncertainty: tenants

Even when apartment hunters know their rights, they sometimes give in

New York /
Mar.March 05, 2020 09:13 AM
Tenants say brokers and landlords are exploiting uncertainty created by changes to the rent law, and the broker-fee upheaval (Credit: iStock)

Tenants say brokers and landlords are exploiting uncertainty created by changes to the rent law, and the broker-fee upheaval (Credit: iStock)

This should be a happy time for tenants: Sweeping rent-law changes last June capped the cost of rental application fees, and a recent state ruling scrapped some broker fees entirely.

But while the latter issue plays out in court, some tenants say uncertainty over the rules — and the pressure to snag an apartment — is being used against them.

After the state issued a guidance February stating that tenants would no longer have to pay broker fees when a broker was hired by a landlord, Raissa Carpenter and her partner toured a property and submitted an offer, which the agent accepted, according to The New York Times.

“He then suggested we hire him so that it would be legal for him to charge us a fee,” Carpenter told the newspaper.

The couple declined — aware of the state’s position on broker fees — and the broker told them that the room was no longer available. Not long afterward, they saw it relisted on StreetEasy.

In a cutthroat rental environment, tenants are put in a difficult position when faced with what they see as a breach of the rules because there are often many other applicants right behind them.

“When you are looking for housing, you are not in a position to be citing the legislation to a broker or prospective landlord and that you demand they follow the law,” Marika Dias, director of the Tenant Rights Coalition at Legal Services NYC, told the Times.

The real estate industry has fought hard against the broker-fee decision by the Department of State, which shocked many groups, including the Real Estate Board of New York and the New York Association of Realtors.

After a judge granted a temporary restraining order in February, challengers REBNY and NYSAR told agents they would be able to “do business in the same way they did prior to last week’s DOS memo without fear of discipline by the DOS.” [NYT] — Sylvia Varnham O’Regan


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Basketball star Ben Simmons with the Moorestown property (Compass, Getty)
Philadelphia 76ers’ fallen star Ben Simmons lists NJ mansion for $5M
Philadelphia 76ers’ fallen star Ben Simmons lists NJ mansion for $5M
From left: SERHANT CEO Ryan Serhant, 77 Greenwich Street, Trinity Place Holdings CEO Matthew Messinger and Macquarie Capital's Jackie Hamilton (77 Greenwich Street via Binyan Studios)
Trinity Place Holdings beats deadline with $168M refi at FiDi condo
Trinity Place Holdings beats deadline with $168M refi at FiDi condo
Manhattan luxury market logs biggest week since 2013
Manhattan luxury market logs biggest week since 2013
Manhattan luxury market logs biggest week since 2013
Single-family rentals are increasingly seen as a more realistic alternative to ownership, given the hot housing market and income inequality. (iStock)
Single-family rentals soaring in hot housing market
Single-family rentals soaring in hot housing market
(Getty)
Manhattan buyers shun fixer-uppers
Manhattan buyers shun fixer-uppers
Sheldon Solow and the Hamptons estate (Getty, Douglas Elliman)
Sheldon Solow’s Hamptons home gets $10M price cut
Sheldon Solow’s Hamptons home gets $10M price cut
Investors home purchases rose to 15 percent in the second quarter, a year-over-year increase of 3.9 percentage points. (iStock)
Investors take bigger bite of US housing, and pay less
Investors take bigger bite of US housing, and pay less
Chicago Bulls’ DeRozan buys mansion from Michael Jordan’s ex-wife at discounted $4.5M
Chicago Bulls’ DeRozan buys mansion from Michael Jordan’s ex-wife at discounted $4.5M
Chicago Bulls’ DeRozan buys mansion from Michael Jordan’s ex-wife at discounted $4.5M
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...