For US retailers, coronavirus concerns come home. What are their options?

Counterparts in Singapore and Hong Kong have mobilized to demand rent relief; some temporary rebates have been granted

TRD NATIONAL /
Mar.March 06, 2020 07:00 AM
Retailers in Singapore and Hong Kong have mobilized to demand rent relief due to the coronavirus. What other options might U.S. retailers have? (Credit: iStock)

Retailers in Singapore and Hong Kong have mobilized to demand rent relief due to the coronavirus. What other options might U.S. retailers have? (Credit: iStock)

“Community spread” of the coronavirus in the U.S. has led to a growing fear among retailers. Already grappling with supply-chain uncertainty due to the spreading epidemic, retailers are now contending with the prospect of a decline in sales as consumers opt to avoid public spaces.

While American cities have yet to witness the empty-street scenes that have appeared in places like Seoul or Milan, the way retailers in other markets have responded to the crisis can shed some light on options available for their U.S. counterparts.

On Thursday, a group of more than 300 Singaporean retailers called for their landlords to provide 50-percent rent cuts for three months, the South China Morning Post reported.

“We are learning from what the tenants in Hong Kong did,” a member of Singapore Tenants United for Fairness told the Post.

And last month, 50 retailers operating nearly 200 shops in Hong Kong went on strike to demand rent cuts. Retailers there had already been struggling from the months-long anti-government protests before the emergence of the new coronavirus — called COVID-19.

The Restaurant Association of Singapore also called for landlords to provide steep rent cuts last month, as some restaurateurs predicted 80-percent losses in revenue.

Several major landlords, including real estate giant CapitaLand, have pledged cuts, while the Singapore government has offered landlords a 15-percent property tax rebate.

Retail tenants at Singapore’s main airport — who have been particularly hard-hit by a decline in air travel — have been granted a 50-percent rent rebate for six months. Airports in Hong Kong, South Korea and Thailand have taken similar steps.

Singapore’s response to the epidemic has proven a hard-to-replicate success story. The island city-state has seen 117 confirmed cases of coronavirus infection and zero deaths.

The latest tally for the U.S. stands at 163 cases and 11 deaths as of Thursday, including more than 50 cases in California and more than 20 in New York.

Demands for rent relief would be nothing new in the U.S., as retailers large and small have struggled for years to meet their rent obligations amid the retail apocalypse.

But beyond voluntary arrangements with landlords to cut rents or reduce hours, commercial tenants may have few options.

“In general, unless the tenancy agreement provides otherwise, there is prima facie no duty on the landlord to offer any concessions,” Singapore-based lawyers with international law firm Withers LLC wrote in a report last month.

U.S. contract law, which shares English common law roots with the legal systems of Hong Kong and Singapore, does not have a general definition for “force majeure” events or “acts of god.” Contracts are interpreted narrowly on a case-by-case basis. If a lease contract doesn’t explicitly include provisions for an epidemic, a tenant might be out of luck.

Another extreme option is to rely on the “doctrine of frustration”, where “a virtually cataclysmic, wholly unforeseeable event” makes a contract worthless, the Withers report notes. “However, it must be noted that this is a matter to be determined by the courts, which will look at the specific set of facts of each case.”

Because of their rarity, there are few successful precedents when it comes to epidemic-related lease disputes.

One frequently-cited case took place during the SARS epidemic in Hong Kong in 2003, but it wasn’t a retailer. A residential renter attempted to vacate his lease, after a government isolation order made his apartment uninhabitable for 10 days. A court rejected the argument, saying the disruption only lasted for a short time.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Mayor Bill de Blasio announces “a new New York City tradition” as outdoor dining is set to return next year (de Blasio by Lev Radin/Pacific Press/LightRocket via Getty Images; background by ANGELA WEISS/AFP via Getty Images)

Outdoor dining to return next summer — for restaurants that survive

Outdoor dining to return next summer — for restaurants that survive
President Donald Trump (Photo by Doug Mills-Pool/Getty Images; iStock)

Trump says he is “going to stop” evictions

Trump says he is “going to stop” evictions
The closures will primarily affect low-volume sales locations (Photo by Alexi Rosenfeld/Getty Images)

Dunkin’ to shutter 800 US locations

Dunkin’ to shutter 800 US locations
Right to left: 831, 835 and 837 Madison Avenue (Google Maps)

“The ’57 Chevy in that old lady’s garage”: Madison Avenue buildings up for sale in litmus test for retail real estate

“The ’57 Chevy in that old lady’s garage”: Madison Avenue buildings up for sale in litmus test for retail real estate
Lord & Taylor and Men’s Wearhouse are just the latest big retail chains to file for bankruptcy (Lord and Taylor by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images; Men's Warehouse by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

Lord & Taylor, Men’s Wearhouse file for bankruptcy

Lord & Taylor, Men’s Wearhouse file for bankruptcy
Banana Republic CEO Mark Breitbard and Tishman Speyer CEO Rob Speyer (Breitbard by Neilson Barnard/Getty Images for GQ; Speyer by Drew Angerer/Getty Images; Banana Republic via Google Maps)

Banana Republic sues to stay in Rockefeller Center

Banana Republic sues to stay in Rockefeller Center
Lisbon

Landlords slow to embrace Lisbon’s rent guarantee program

Landlords slow to embrace Lisbon’s rent guarantee program
After high demand from renters, @NYSHCR extends application period for relief program by one week (iStock)

New York extends rent-relief window one week

New York extends rent-relief window one week
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...