Landlord must fix, not raze, “deplorable” Chelsea buildings: court

Tenants were forced out of decrepit SROs in July

New York /
May.May 08, 2020 05:45 PM
219-223 West 24th Street (Credit: StreetEasy)

219-223 West 24th Street (Credit: StreetEasy)

A Chelsea landlord must repair three rent-stabilized buildings and pay tenants $126,000 for neglecting maintenance until they had to vacate, a housing court judge ordered this week.

The owners of 219-223 West 24th Street — entities tied to Abraham Lokshin and Clara Sokol — must restore the buildings, according to a May 6 order. The judge, Jack Stoller, suspected the owners’ strategy was demolition.

The city’s Department of Buildings cleared out the three single-room occupancy buildings in July, finding that the landlord had failed to correct a host of problems that made the 48 units unsafe, including a damaged facade, leaking roof, sagging floors and crumbling joists. The properties’ six tenants were moved to temporary housing.

The owners argued that the repairs demanded by the city were economically and structurally infeasible, and that requiring them would violate the U.S. Constitution’s takings clause.

The residents can return to the properties once the repairs are completed, according to the decision. The landlords were also ordered to pay each tenant $21,000 in damages and $2,000 for their harassment claims. Estimates to fix the buildings range from $900,000 to $7.8 million.

Stoller dismissed the idea that the properties, built as far back as 1840, were in poor condition when Lokshin purchased them in 2012 for $4.5 million. The judge noted that the owners were experienced real estate investors yet could not definitively say whether they had the property inspected before buying it.

“A failure to inspect a building that is more than 100 years old evinces an indifference to its condition consistent with its later deplorable state,” Stoller wrote.

He pointed to the owner’s long-term strategy of emptying the building. The owner bought out tenants and kept apartments vacant, according to the order. In 2012, 25 of the buildings’ 48 units were occupied, and that number eventually dropped to six.

“Why would Respondents pay $4.5 million in 2012 for a property appraised at $2.5 million seven years later and so dramatically fail to maintain it?” the decision states. “Respondents clearly wanted the subject premises vacant so they could demolish it and develop the property to be something more lucrative than a rent-stabilized SRO.”

Sokol, who is listed as property manager at the single-room-occupancy buildings, declined to comment when reached on Friday.

“This court decision serves as a warning to owners who fail to maintain their buildings and put tenants at risk,” said James Johnson, head of the city’s Law Department, which filed cross-claims against the landlord in the tenants’ lawsuit.

It is unclear when Gov. Andrew Cuomo will allow all construction work in the city to resume. But emergency repairs have been allowed under his stay-at-home order, and work at the Chelsea properties is likely to qualify.

Reforms to the state’s rent-stabilization law last year disincentivized investors from buying and vacating regulated buildings to flip them to market-rate. Stoller described the strategy in his ruling.

Lokshin has at least six months to make repairs. Marko Lulgjuri, the Chelsea buildings’ superintendent, said on Friday that he’s been living uptown since the vacate order. He’s worked at the properties for seven years, and he’s not sure if he’ll return.

“I lost the place and the job,” he said. “I don’t know what’s going to happen.’’

Write to Kathryn Brenzel at [email protected]


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
A photo illustration of Tishman Speyer CEO Rob Speyer and 28-10 Jackson Avenue in Long Island City (Getty Images, Tishman Speyer, Google Maps)
LIC tenant claims Tishman Speyer violated rent stabilization
LIC tenant claims Tishman Speyer violated rent stabilization
CHIP's Jay Martin (Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal with Getty Images)
Inflation crushing rent-stabilized owners: landlord group
Inflation crushing rent-stabilized owners: landlord group
Supreme Court Justice Sabrina Kraus and HRI's Aaron Carr (Twitter, Facebook, Getty)
Ruling could “open the floodgates” on apartment improvement fraud cases
Ruling could “open the floodgates” on apartment improvement fraud cases
From left: Rosenberg & Estis’ Zachary Rothken, RuthAnne Visnauskas, and Belkin Burden Goldman's  Sherwin Belkin (Rosenberg & Estis, BBG, LinkedIn, Getty)
Proposed rent regs lack legal basis: lawyers
Proposed rent regs lack legal basis: lawyers
Clipper Equity’s David Bistricer and Flatbush Gardens (Clipper Equity, Google Maps)
Clipper Equity lists 21-acre Flatbush Gardens apartment complex
Clipper Equity lists 21-acre Flatbush Gardens apartment complex
Landlord attack dog Jay Martin tries playing nice
Landlord attack dog Jay Martin tries playing nice
Landlord attack dog Jay Martin tries playing nice
RuthAnne Visnauskas (Getty)
New rent regulations would squeeze landlords even more
New rent regulations would squeeze landlords even more
Attorney General Letitia James (Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
For rent law cheaters, the ultimate punishment: Endless stabilization
For rent law cheaters, the ultimate punishment: Endless stabilization
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...