Sutton Place co-op in turmoil over terrace fees

Couple sues board for charging only residents with access to outdoor space

New York /
May.May 28, 2020 07:00 AM
16 Sutton Place (Credit: Google Maps)

16 Sutton Place (Credit: Google Maps)

It’s not just New York City parks where tensions about open space are boiling over.

At a co-op building on Sutton Place, the owners of a penthouse unit sued their board Wednesday, claiming “discriminatory and disparate treatment” over maintenance fees for the building’s terraces.

Alixandra and Stuart Baker say the board voted last year to effectively shift the responsibility for maintaining terraces from the building as a whole to the few residents who have access to them.

The couple say the action is invalid because business corporation law prohibits “discriminatory and disparate treatment” and their terrace agreement prohibits such changes without their consent.

This is not the first time the Bakers have sued their building. In 2007, the couple tried to block the board from constructing a rooftop garden, but a judge found they failed to establish that the green space would violate their rights.

The building at 16 Sutton Place, which was built in 1960, has 56 units across 20 stories, according to StreetEasy.

The couple became owners in the building in 1998, and reached a proprietary lease agreement that gave them exclusive use of the building’s rooftop, according to the latest lawsuit.

While they were required to keep the space tidy, the agreement said the building was responsible for its general maintenance.

But the board’s amendment requires them to not only keep the space clean, but to “maintain, repair and replace elements of the terrace,” which includes doors, railings and paint, the suit said.

On March 9, the couple got a letter from Douglas Elliman stating that the board intended to do restoration work on their terrace in April, in connection with a Local Law 11, which aims to protect pedestrians from falling debris.

The total cost of the work, according to the suit, was estimated to be about $50,000.

The pair are now seeking an injunction demanding that the board cover the maintenance costs.

David Salhanick of Gallet Dreyer Berkey, who is representing the couple, and the co-op board’s counsel, John Van Der Tuin of Smith of Gambrell & Russell, did not respond to requests for comment.

Write to Sylvia Varnham O’Regan at [email protected]


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
In the pandemic-stricken residential market, real estate agents are working with influencers to help expand their audiences (iStock; Instagram/huntervought; Instagram/homesteadbrooklyn)

Real estate agents turn to influencers to help sell a lifestyle — and apartments

Real estate agents turn to influencers to help sell a lifestyle — and apartments
“It took off like crazy”: How brokers use TikTok to rent apartments

“It took off like crazy”: How brokers use TikTok to rent apartments

“It took off like crazy”: How brokers use TikTok to rent apartments
532 West 22nd Street and Kate Winslet (Google Maps; Getty)

Kate Winslet letting go of Chelsea penthouse

Kate Winslet letting go of Chelsea penthouse
Jonathan Kalikow and a rendering of 3 Sutton Place

Court overturns ruling that would have upended “the whole land development industry”

Court overturns ruling that would have upended “the whole land development industry”
A federal judge has rejected a lawsuit from a group of New York landlords that sought to challenge pandemic protections for tenants. (iStock)

Landlords lose challenge against pandemic renter protections

Landlords lose challenge against pandemic renter protections
David Bistricer of Clipper Equity and 10 West 65th Street (REIT; Google Maps)

David Bistricer’s latest brush-up with New York’s rent law

David Bistricer’s latest brush-up with New York’s rent law
A rendering of the Staten Island Wheel (Rendering via Perkins Eastman)

Developer of the failed New York Wheel sues its contractor … again

Developer of the failed New York Wheel sues its contractor … again
Yue-Sai Kan and 6 Sutton Square (Getty; Google Maps)

Sutton Square townhouse listed by “China’s Oprah” for $28M

Sutton Square townhouse listed by “China’s Oprah” for $28M
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...