City protects big companies, hurts small landlords: lawsuit

Gap, Old Navy, Victoria’s Secret defaults cited as examples

New York /
Jul.July 23, 2020 04:56 PM
Documents filed in court say big retailers’ lawsuits show the protections go too far — and curb landlords’ right to commercial speech. (iStock)

Documents filed in court say big retailers’ lawsuits show the protections go too far — and curb landlords’ right to commercial speech. (iStock)

In suing their Times Square landlords, Gap and Old Navy cited a city law that protects their lease during the pandemic, even if they didn’t pay rent.

Now that may come back to bite them.

The law, which prohibits a landlord from harassing a commercial tenant hurt by Covid-19, is among three statutes being challenged by two small landlords. Documents filed in court today say big retailers’ lawsuits show the protections go too far — and curb landlords’ right to commercial speech.

The City Council had billed the measures as efforts to help small businesses survive the pandemic. National chains’ use of them to withhold rent doesn’t fit that narrative, and might be a legal vulnerability as well.

“In order to survive constitutional scrutiny, you have to have a narrowly tailored statute,” said the landlords’ lawyer, Stephen Younger, a partner at Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler. “This is anything but, and the fact that Old Navy and Gap are taking advantage of this confirms to us that the statute is overly broad.”

The chains sued their landlord at the Bow Tie Building, at Seventh Avenue and West 44th Street. Other lawsuits included as exhibits in the case involve The Gap’s 170 Broadway location, Bath & Body Works’ 304 Park Avenue store and Victoria’s Secret’s Herald Square flagship. The latter two lawsuits are against SL Green.

Younger’s clients aim to overturn laws shielding commercial and residential tenants from harassment and another measure protecting the personal assets of tenants who break commercial leases, all of which were enacted in May, by showing they harm small landlords.

Marcia Melendez and Ling Yang, the plaintiffs, are first-generation immigrants who own two properties each. Melendez owes over $20,500 in taxes and Yang has incurred approximately $100,000 in losses related to the pandemic.

However, Melendez and Yang’s properties do not house large retailers, according to Younger.

“We’re using [the lawsuits] as emblematic of the extraordinarily broad reach of these laws. The laws are so broad that they cover parties that shouldn’t be getting relief from the government,” Younger said. “And correspondingly, the burden of this is being put on the property-owning community of New York City.”

Concerns about the bills’ constitutionality were raised upon their introduction. City Council member Kalman Yeger noted in April that the city can’t interfere with such agreements between landlords and tenants.

But other lawmakers have continued to side with commercial tenants over landlords. On Wednesday, the state Assembly passed a bill that would deter commercial landlords from holding out for higher rent after a tenant quits a lease early, so the departed tenant would not be liable for rent during a long period of vacancy.

While such bills have been hailed by restaurants and retailers, landlords have been seeking ways to penalize non-paying tenants. In the residential sector, landlords across the country have been suing local governments to lift eviction moratoriums.

Contact Sasha Jones at [email protected]


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
258 8th Avenue (Google, Target)

Target planning yet another NYC store in Chelsea

Target planning yet another NYC store in Chelsea
Churchill Real Estate's Justin Ehrlich and 381 Broadway (Google Maps)

Two-year Tribeca foreclosure saga continues with lawsuit over $20M

Two-year Tribeca foreclosure saga continues with lawsuit over $20M
Adam America's Omri Sachs and Dvir Cohen with 2503-2509 Broadway (Google Maps; Adam America)

Adam America secures $63M in financing for Upper West Side project

Adam America secures $63M in financing for Upper West Side project
Convene CEO Ryan Simonetti (Convene)

Convene closes Manhattan locations as corporate events fail to return

Convene closes Manhattan locations as corporate events fail to return
New York City District Council of Carpenters’s Monitor Glen McGorty (iStock; LinkedIn)

NYC carpenters union changes how it roots out mob ties

NYC carpenters union changes how it roots out mob ties
The Economic Innovation Group identified 145 real estate investments in Opportunity Zones (iStock)

Real estate deals dominate Opportunity Zones. Is that bad?

Real estate deals dominate Opportunity Zones. Is that bad?
11 Penn Plaza and Apple CEO Tim Cook (VNO; Getty)

Apple snags more space at Vornado’s 11 Penn Plaza

Apple snags more space at Vornado’s 11 Penn Plaza
Vanke US managing director Kai-yan Lee, RFR’s Aby Rosen and 100 East 53rd Street (Photos via Foster + Partners and Getty)

Vanke seeks to remove RFR from Midtown condo project

Vanke seeks to remove RFR from Midtown condo project
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...