Is gentrification a blessing or a curse? New Yorkers discuss

Latest TRD Talk questions what should be done about the city’s yuppies

New York /
Aug.August 28, 2020 07:30 AM

College-educated yuppies fanning out to low-income communities in a search for affordable housing has become a major point of tension in New York City.

But as investment follows, it has raised a question: Is gentrification a blessing or a curse?

The answer is, it depends. The nuances were explored on Wednesday’s edition of TRD Talks Live by Bronx Community Board 6 district manager John Sanchez and the Manhattan Institute’s Kay Hymowitz.

Sanchez said efforts to improve neighborhoods seem to come only when gentrification does.

“I’m never going to cast blame or cast shame on someone that wants to live in the Bronx because it’s the only place they can live in,” Sanchez said. “The frustration from a lot of communities of color is that once so-called gentrifiers come in, then the investment comes.”

Hymowitz, the William E. Simon fellow at her free-market think tank, raised a different point.

“Another way to think about gentrification, at least in many cases, is integration,” she noted.

The conversation revolves around whether gentrification causes displacement, a subject of research by economists and a major motivator of opposition to New York real estate projects.

An often-cited study by Churches United for Fair Housing tracked demographic changes following the Greenpoint/Williamsburg waterfront rezoning in 2005 and the Park Slope/4th Avenue rezoning in 2003. It shows the Black and Latino populations fell in both areas over more than a decade beginning in 2000, despite increasing in the city as a whole.

However, another study, by the National Bureau of Economic Research, found gentrification did not supercharge displacement of individuals. Using Medicaid records to track the paths of children living in New York City from January 2009 to December 2015, it showed that low-income families move often, even in non-gentrifying neighborhoods.

The difference is that in gentrifying neighborhoods, those families are more likely to be replaced by residents who are wealthier and white.

“A lot of people have an image, when you talk about displacement, of eviction, people who are being forced out by landlords,” said Hymowitz.

Advocates for development have said more housing construction in gentrifying areas would absorb newcomers, reducing displacement and curb rents. At the same time, others have emphasized that adding apartments in high-income areas would allow others to enjoy their advantages and ease gentrification elsewhere.

Sanchez, a candidate for City Council in the Bronx, argued for increasing housing in all neighborhoods. In a recent op-ed for Gotham Gazette, he wrote that restrictive zoning in areas like Soho and Riverdale prevents mixed-income housing, which would allow more minorities to reap the benefits of living in those areas.

“We shouldn’t be limiting homes, we shouldn’t be limiting the amount of people that can live in our city, we shouldn’t be limiting our tax base,” Sanchez said. “And that’s my approach to land use. Housing is a basic need.”

Contact Sasha Jones at [email protected]


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
1065-1075 Gerard Avenue in the Bronx 
Prana pays Related $36M in Bronx multifamily play
Prana pays Related $36M in Bronx multifamily play
448 East 143rd Street in the Bronx (Credit: Google Maps)
Private developer’s NYCHA project in Mott Haven lands $79M in financing
Private developer’s NYCHA project in Mott Haven lands $79M in financing
1159 and 1184 River Avenue with Maddd Equities' Jorge Madruga (left) and Joy Construction's Eli Weiss (right) (Credit: Google Maps)
Maddd Equities, Joy Construction score $64M for massive Bronx project
Maddd Equities, Joy Construction score $64M for massive Bronx project
NYCHA approves $60M, 101-unit affordable development in Bronx
NYCHA approves $60M, 101-unit affordable development in Bronx
NYCHA approves $60M, 101-unit affordable development in Bronx
Apple to open first Bronx store, 11 location in New York
Apple to open first Bronx store, 11th location in New York
Apple to open first Bronx store, 11th location in New York
The Grand Prospect Hall at 263 Prospect Avenue with former Mayor Robert Wagner (Getty, Jim.henderson/Wikimedia, NYPAP/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
How (not) to save a beloved building
How (not) to save a beloved building
Vornado's Steve Roth with (clockwise from top left) 155 Spring Street, 828 – 850 Madison Avenue, 478-482 Broadway and 759 – 771 Madison Avenue (VNO, Getty)
Vornado to sell five Manhattan retail properties, takes loss of $7M
Vornado to sell five Manhattan retail properties, takes loss of $7M
Grand Prospect Hall at 263 Prospect Avenue in Brooklyn (Google Maps, iStock)
Grand Prospect Hall to be demolished
Grand Prospect Hall to be demolished
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...