Council looks to expand tenant discrimination laws

One bill would ban criminal background checks, despite potential to backfire

New York /
Sep.September 14, 2020 06:11 PM
The City Council on Tuesday will consider a series of bills aimed at curbing renter discrimination (iStock)

The City Council on Tuesday will consider a series of bills aimed at curbing renter discrimination (iStock)

The City Council on Tuesday will consider a series of bills that would increase protections against renter discrimination.

The measures would ban discrimination based on renters’ criminal histories and lawful sources of income — namely federal, state, or local public assistance.

Under current law, landlords cannot reject applications for apartments in properties with six or more units based on a prospective tenant’s income source. A bill sponsored by Council member Keith Powers would expand the law to properties with three or more apartments.

Another bill seeks to bar real estate brokers, landlords or their affiliates from conducting criminal background checks or asking applicants if they have ever been arrested or convicted.

“We need to stop the prison-to-shelter pipeline and to end the use of discriminatory background checks in housing,” Council member Stephen Levin, one of the bill’s sponsors, said during a Council meeting last month.

He called a stable home critical for success after incarceration. “It increases an individuals’ ability to gain employment and foster supportive relationships, both of which contribute to greater public safety and lower taxpayer costs,” said Powers.

The Council member noted that other cities including San Francisco, Richmond and Seattle have similar laws.

But “ban the box” laws — which forbid employers from asking job applicants about their criminal history — have actually hurt minorities, economists say: Employers guess which applicants have criminal histories, and thus screen out young Black and Latino men.

The New York bills will be heard by the City Council’s Committee on Civil and Human Rights.

Also on Tuesday, the City Council’s zoning subcommittee is hosting a hearing on the controversial proposal to rezone Industry City.

During a press conference Monday, Andrew Kimball, the CEO of the Sunset Park business campus, indicated he would offer the City Council a deal under which the expansion of the Sunset Park campus would depend directly on the number of jobs created.

Kimball said if the rezoning is not approved, the development team may move forward with an office-only or last-mile warehouse distribution project. The Council must make a decision by early November.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Corey Johnson (Getty, iStock)
    When NIMBYs attack: Why CoJo’s master plan won’t fly
    When NIMBYs attack: Why CoJo’s master plan won’t fly
    Queens Council member Costa Constantinides is sponsoring the bill. (Getty, Costa Constantinides)
    Real estate industry calls sewage-overflow bill “extreme”
    Real estate industry calls sewage-overflow bill “extreme”
     Jeffrey Leb and Related chairman Stephen Ross (Wikipedia Commons, Getty, OU Advocacy Center/Photo illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
    Why real estate is spending big on City Council races
    Why real estate is spending big on City Council races
    Queens Council member Adrienne Adams and Mayor Bill de Blasio (NYC Council, Getty, iStock/Illustration by Alexis Manrodt for The Real Deal)
    City Council renews tax lien sale for one year
    City Council renews tax lien sale for one year
    Madison Square Garden with New York City Council members Alicka Ampry-Samuel (top), Justin Brannan (right) and Keith Powers (bottom) (iStock; New York City Council)
    Madison Square Garden donates to City Council candidates
    Madison Square Garden donates to City Council candidates
    Corey Johnson (background) and (from left) Ross Moskowitz, Ken Fisher and Paul Selver (Getty)
    Land use overhaul faces challenging path forward
    Land use overhaul faces challenging path forward
    Council member Mark Gjonaj and Robert Holden (Photos via City Council)
    Yimby group backs City Council candidates
    Yimby group backs City Council candidates
    Commissioner Melanie La Rocca and Brooklyn Council member Robert Cornegy (New York City Council)
    Council passes bill to speed up opening of new and renovated properties
    Council passes bill to speed up opening of new and renovated properties
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...