Brooklyn developer duo hit with foreclosure lawsuit

Joseph Brunner and Abe Mandel allegedly defaulted on loan for Bushwick redevelopment

TRD New York /
Sep.September 29, 2020 09:45 AM
A rendering of 121 Morgan Avenue in Bushwick and Benefit Street Partners’ managing director Micah Goodman (Photos via EXR; Benefit Street Partners)

A rendering of 121 Morgan Avenue in Bushwick and Benefit Street Partners’ managing director Micah Goodman (Photos via EXR; Benefit Street Partners)

UPDATE, Sept. 30 2020, 2 p.m.: Brooklyn developers Joseph Brunner and Abe Mandel are caught in a foreclosure lawsuit involving close to $20 million in mortgages for a Bushwick building.

The lender, Benefit Street Partners Realty, charged in a suit filed in New York State Supreme Court that the developers, operating as 121 Morgan Holdings and Morgan BMB, defaulted on three mortgages totaling $19.75 million. The developers also allegedly failed to meet multiple deadlines to complete improvements to the former manufacturing facility at 121 Morgan Avenue.

“This is a mortgage foreclosure action brought by a lender that has bent over backwards — time and again — to accommodate a defaulting borrower that has opted to look a gift horse in the mouth,” court documents read.

Brunner and Mandel are known together as Bruman Realty, one of the biggest landlords in Brooklyn. Most recently, the firm reportedly sold a portfolio of about 1,275 residential rental units to KKR and Dalan Management for around $860 million.

Brunner is named in the suit for his role as principal of Morgan BMB, and Mandel as guarantor of payments. Their co-defendants include Joseph Tabak and Toby Mandel.

Stephen Meister, an attorney for 121 Morgan Holdings, said in a statement that the lawsuit is an “outrage.” He claims it stems from Benefit Street’s displeasure over the borrowers’ refinancing of another mortgage held by the firm, though he declined to specify which one.

The Real Deal previously reported that Brunner’s Bruman Realty secured a $130 million refinancing deal with Starwood Mortgage Capital for a large multifamily development at 871 Bushwick Avenue, consolidating multiple loans, including ones from Benefit Street.

Ethan Kobre, an attorney for Benefit Street, and representatives for the firm itself did not respond to a request for comment. But in the absence of a response in court from the developers, Kobre filed a new motion on Sept. 27, seeking a default judgement to resolve the case in favor of Benefit Street.

The court filing said that the developers agreed to a July 1, 2019, “completion date” for “Phase I” improvements to the Morgan Avenue building, which has been marketed as a “high-end retail space,” according to listing websites.

After failing to meet the initial deadline, the developers asked for an extension, which Benefit Street granted. But, the lawsuit alleges, they again failed to meet multiple deadlines, and the lender ultimately offered to push back the minimum interest payment date and loan maturity date as long as the borrowers agreed to “certain provisions,” although those were not specified. The borrowers refused to accept the offer, leading to the ongoing dispute.

When Benefit Street notified the defendants of their various defaults, the borrower “essentially thumbed their nose at” the lender, “vowing to exploit the upheaval created by the Covid-19 pandemic to continue their defaults” even though they missed completion deadlines even before the pandemic, according to the lawsuit.

Kobre, Benefit Street’s lawyer, wrote in the filing that the lender made accommodations for the borrowers based on their reputation as “respectable and sophisticated real estate owners and developers” but was “rewarded” by “multiple willful defaults.”

Meister disagreed with that characterization of what happened, and said borrowers in June requested that Benefit Street issue a payoff letter so they could pay back the mortgages in full through refinancing. He claimed that Benefit Street wanted to charge more interest than the loan agreement called for in retaliation for not getting more deals from the developers.

“We believe the court will see Benefit Street’s actions for what they are — reprehensible, vindictive, predatory, and illegal,” Meister said. “They won’t take what they are owed.”

Benefit Street was also recently involved in a legal dispute over the Williamsburg Hotel. After Toby Moskovits’ Heritage Equity Partners defaulted on a $68 million loan from Benefit Street, the hotel was placed in receivership.

CORRECTION: A previous version of this article identified Joseph Tabak and Toby Mandel as co-plaintiffs in the lawsuit. They are co-defendants, along with Joseph Brunner and Abe Mandel. 





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Red Apple Group’s John Catsimatidis and Muss Development’s Jason Muss (Getty; iStock)

    Four Brooklyn landlords accused of illegally inflating rents

    Four Brooklyn landlords accused of illegally inflating rents
    Knotel CEO Amol Sarva (iStock)

    Knotel slashes its workforce again

    Knotel slashes its workforce again
    Cohen Brothers' Charles Cohen and Stephen Fredericks (Getty; iStock; LinkedIn)

    Cohen Brothers employees allege harassment, endangerment

    Cohen Brothers employees allege harassment, endangerment
    The Factory building at 30-30 47th Avenue with Square Mile Capital’s Craig Solomon and Invesco CEO Marty Flanagan (Photos via The Factory; Square Mile; Invesco)

    Here’s what tenants are paying at the Factory in Long Island City

    Here’s what tenants are paying at the Factory in Long Island City
    Bob Sulentic (Getty, iStock)

    CBRE income falls nearly 10%

    CBRE income falls nearly 10%
    From left: Paramount CEO Albert Behler, 1301 6th Avenue, 712 5th Avenue, 31 West 52nd Street (Getty; Google Maps)

    Paramount Group back at work, but tenants waiting until 2021

    Paramount Group back at work, but tenants waiting until 2021
    Tony Malkin (Getty, iStock)

    Empire State Realty Trust reports second consecutive quarterly loss

    Empire State Realty Trust reports second consecutive quarterly loss
    Michael Shvo and the Transamerica Building in San Francisco and  (Unsplash)

    Shvo, Deutsche Finance close on Transamerica Pyramid for $650M

    Shvo, Deutsche Finance close on Transamerica Pyramid for $650M
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...