Judge tosses landlords’ challenge to New York eviction limits

Ruling also clarifies a legal issue with state law around evictions

New York /
Oct.October 15, 2020 01:00 PM
Judge David Zuckerman (iStock)

Judge David Zuckerman (iStock)

A New York state judge dismissed a challenge to eviction limits, and asserted the court’s ability to issue such orders in the future.

The plaintiffs, three landlords in Westchester County, New York, sought to block Judge Lawrence Marks’ administrative order which, until Oct. 1, halted all evictions statewide. That order was superseded by state and federal rules, which nullified the petition, according to State Supreme Court Judge David Zuckerman’s ruling.

In his decision, Zuckerman affirmed the court system’s power to take similar actions in the future, and resolved a legal quandary that arose when language in Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s executive order conflicted with the law he sought to modify.

Specifically, Cuomo’s executive order, which bars execution of judgments or warrants of evictions, modified the Tenant Safe Harbor Act, which sought to bar issuance, rather than the enforcement of evictions. To resolve the difference, Zuckerman ruled that the order modified the law by “specifically barring execution or enforcement of all judgments or warrants of eviction until January 1, 2021.”

“The courts have the right and duty to protect their employees and the public during a public health emergency,” Zuckerman wrote in the ruling.

Attorneys for the plaintiffs did not return a request for comment.

Landlord groups have said that limiting evictions without providing rent subsidies or reducing taxes places an unfair burden on property owners when tenants can no longer afford to pay rent. While residential evictions in New York can now proceed, as of Oct. 12, they are limited by the Tenant Safe Harbor Act, which bars evictions if a tenant can document financial distress during or prior to coronavirus pandemic. They are also limited by federal restrictions implemented in September.

Earlier this year, when Marks issued orders to delay eviction proceedings, he struck a “fair and legal balance between the rights of landlords to pursue the remedy of eviction” and the “prospect of the courts filling with potentially infected litigants,” according to Zuckerman’s decision.

The CDC rule, which some tenants can raise as a defense against an eviction, can be superseded by a more restrictive local law. But because the federal protections exceeded those of New York State at the time it was implemented, it made not only the state administrative orders limiting evictions irrelevant, it also made pointless any challenges to the administrative orders.

Roland Nimis, a supervising housing attorney at Legal Services NYC who does eviction defense work in the Bronx, said that he hopes Zuckerman’s decision will encourage courts to “be confident in their own power to make rules,” both in New York and across the country, where landlord groups have filed similar challenges to eviction limits.

“Tenants are having to choose between their health, and rejoining the economy to pay rent and protect the health of their family by not being evicted,” said Nimis. “It’s an impossible choice, and one they shouldn’t have to make.”





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
     Though landlords aren’t quite ready to say goodbye to their offices, employees are, according to a new survey by JLL. (Getty)
    Sorry, boss: 72% of workers don’t want to return to offices full-time
    Sorry, boss: 72% of workers don’t want to return to offices full-time
    A selection of the properties, from left: 1020 Pacific Street, 818 Bergen Street, 483 St. Marks Avenue and 634 Classon Avenue (Google Maps, Kings County Supreme Court/Illustration by Alexis Manrodt for The Real Deal)
    All Year sues partner over “illegitimate” deed transfers
    All Year sues partner over “illegitimate” deed transfers
    President Joe Biden’s American Rescue Plan was passed over the weekend. (Getty / Photo Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
    What real estate gets in Biden’s $1.9 trillion package
    What real estate gets in Biden’s $1.9 trillion package
    Continuum Company founder Ian Bruce Eichner and the former Spice Factory at 960 Franklin Street (Getty, Google Maps)
    Eichner’s Crown Heights rezoning delayed once again
    Eichner’s Crown Heights rezoning delayed once again
    (Getty, iStock)
    Movie theaters’ future uncertain as studios focus on streaming
    Movie theaters’ future uncertain as studios focus on streaming
    Durst Organization president Jonathan Durst and 1155 Sixth Avenue (Durst, Google Maps)
    Jenner & Block cuts footprint, takes 67K sf at Durst’s 1155 Sixth Avenue
    Jenner & Block cuts footprint, takes 67K sf at Durst’s 1155 Sixth Avenue
    Mack Real Estate CEO Richard Mack and one of his new hotels at 51 Nassau Street. (Getty, ING)
    Mack Real Estate takes over 7 distressed Manhattan hotels
    Mack Real Estate takes over 7 distressed Manhattan hotels
    1440 Broadway and CIM Group’s Shaul Kuba (Google Maps, Getty)
    CIM closes on $400M refi for 1440 Broadway
    CIM closes on $400M refi for 1440 Broadway
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...