In stunning reversal, de Blasio opposes Eichner’s Crown Heights towers

Mayor cites threat to Brooklyn Botanic Garden and neighborhood character

New York /
Dec.December 22, 2020 11:15 AM
Mayor Bill de Blasio, Bruce Eichner of Continuum Company and a rendering of two 39-story residential towers at 960 Franklin Avenue in Crown Heights (Photos via Getty; YIMBY)

Mayor Bill de Blasio, Bruce Eichner of Continuum Company and a rendering of two 39-story residential towers at 960 Franklin Avenue in Crown Heights (Photos via Getty; YIMBY)

UPDATED Dec. 22, 2:24 pm: On the darkest day of the year, Mayor Bill de Blasio withdrew his support for a residential project in Crown Heights that drew opposition for the shadows it would cast over the Brooklyn Botanic Garden.

De Blasio, who had backed the development all year because of its affordable housing component, told Gothamist Monday that he now opposes the plan by Bruce Eichner of Continuum Company to build two 39-story residential towers in Crown Heights.

The plan was opposed by locals and advocates of the Botanic Garden. The two towers would rise over 400 feet at 960 Franklin Avenue, much taller than any of the developments nearby.

The news shocked opponents and supporters alike, as de Blasio had endorsed the project Feb. 7 when a critic of it called him on Brian Lehrer’s radio show.

“I don’t think it ruins the garden forever. I just don’t. I don’t take that position,” the mayor said at the time. “I would love it if we could have a city that could be a city for everyone and affordable and we could keep some of the exact scale and aesthetics we had previously. I would love it if we could achieve those things, but we’re in this new world.”

But in a statement yesterday, de Blasio said the project was “grossly out of scale with the neighborhood” and would inhibit plant growth at the garden.

That effectively kills the project in its current form because the mayor could veto the rezoning it needs from the City Council. Eichner now faces the prospect of negotiating a project design acceptable not only to the local Council member, Laurie Cumbo, but also to the mayor.

The mayor’s statement was stunning not only because it reversed his previous position, but also because mayors rarely take a public stance on a project still being negotiated by the local Council member.

The project’s opponents were waging a legal battle against the city, complete with research about the effects that the buildings’ shadows would have on the garden. They also said the height and density of Eichner’s buildings would be unprecedented in the brownstone neighborhood and would change the character of the neighborhood.

De Blasio has historically put affordable housing considerations before concerns about building heights — and plants, for that matter.

In his February radio interview, the mayor said refusing to change the low-scale character of neighborhoods would “take another step towards the gilded city … that only those who are doing very well can afford to live in.”

He continued, “When it comes to protecting New York, it is about the people first. It’s not about the aesthetics and the buildings, it’s about the people. And if working class people cannot afford to live here, it will not be the same New York City.”

Eichner had said the project would have helped reduce the city’s need for affordable housing. About half of the 1,578 units of housing would be below market rate, according to the developer.

The mayor’s reversal was also a blow to unions, who were in line to build, finance and work in the project.

“This is an unfortunate turn of events,” Gary LaBarbera, president of the Building and Construction Trades Council of Greater New York, said in a statement. “If we want to recover from this economic crisis, we need to encourage progress and economic development, and a project that commits to a 100 percent union labor force and creates hundreds of units of affordable housing is exactly the type of equitable economic development we need to turn the corner on this crisis.”

But de Blasio said in his statement Monday that the Franklin Avenue development “would harm the research and educational work carried out by one of this city’s prized cultural institutions.”







      This story has been updated to include a statement from Gary LaBarbera.


      Related Articles

      arrow_forward_ios
      Photo illustration of Sen. Brad Hoylman, who championed the pied-à-terre tax. (Getty)

      Pied-à-terre tax revenue estimate slashed by 41%

      Pied-à-terre tax revenue estimate slashed by 41%
      Joan Collins and 110 East 57th Street #8EFG (Getty, BHS)

      Soap star Joan Collins lists longtime Midtown pied-à-terre

      Soap star Joan Collins lists longtime Midtown pied-à-terre
      Tommy Hilfiger and his recently sold estate in Greenwich, CT. (Getty, Janet Milligan)

      Tommy Hilfiger’s Greenwich estate sells for $45M

      Tommy Hilfiger’s Greenwich estate sells for $45M
      Jenna Ryan was part of a group who flew on a private plane from Denton, TX, to Washington, D.C., with the intention of joining the protestors (Twitter.com/DotJenna)

      Texas Realtor faces criminal charges for role in Capitol attack

      Texas Realtor faces criminal charges for role in Capitol attack
      Kirk Goodrich, president of Monadnock Development, is opposed to the bill sponsored by Bran Lander. (Getty, Monadnock Development)

      Council bill favoring nonprofits for affordable housing will hurt minority-led firms: developers

      Council bill favoring nonprofits for affordable housing will hurt minority-led firms: developers
      Porch CEO Matt Ehrlichman (iStock)

      Porch snaps up four startups for over $122M

      Porch snaps up four startups for over $122M
      Sen. Charles Schumers aid President-elect Joe Biden agreed to assist NYC. (Getty)

      NYC loses $2.5B in property taxes, gets $1B from FEMA

      NYC loses $2.5B in property taxes, gets $1B from FEMA
      President-elect Joe Biden's relief plan focuses on the coronavirus and opening schools. (Getty)

      Biden’s $1.9T package would extend eviction ban, boost rent relief

      Biden’s $1.9T package would extend eviction ban, boost rent relief
      arrow_forward_ios

      The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

      Loading...