Former deputy mayor Randy Mastro, lawyer in Lucerne controversy, lists UES home

Building on East 83rd Street was defaced earlier this year

New York /
Jan.January 22, 2021 12:45 PM
Randy Mastro and 21 East 83rd Street (Photos via Getty; Google Maps)

Randy Mastro and 21 East 83rd Street (Photos via Getty; Google Maps)

UPDATE, Jan. 22, 6:05 p.m.: A lawyer who defended relocating homeless men on the Upper West Side is himself relocating.

Attorney Randy Mastro, who once served as chief of staff and deputy mayor to Rudy Giuliani and is now a partner at Gibson Dunn, is selling his townhouse at 21 East 83rd Street for $18 million.

Mastro was tapped last year to represent a group of Upper West Side residents who opposed the placement of approximately 200 homeless men at the Lucerne, located on West 79th Street near Amsterdam Avenue. The group filed a lawsuit seeking to relocate the men to a Lower Manhattan hotel, a move that generated pushback from advocates for the homeless. (It remains tied up in court.)

His Upper East Side home became a target after the Lucerne battle became public. In October, a group splashed the townhouse’s door with red paint, and spray-painted messages like “Randy Mastro you can’t replace us” on the facade and the sidewalk.

After the attack, Mastro said in a statement, “if they thought they were going to intimidate me, they picked the wrong guy.”

Mastro purchased the 5,500-square-foot home in 2016 for $14 million. The circa-1925 building, which is located less than a block from Museum Mile, has six bedrooms, three and a half bathrooms, five wood-burning fireplaces, a full-floor master bedroom suite and a large back garden.

“We love everything about the townhouse and the neighborhood, but we have been living outside the city for most of the past year and intend to continue to do so,” Mastro told The Real Deal via email. “Hence, at this point in our lives, we simply don’t need such a large place in the city.”

Brian J. Manning and Christopher E. Franklin of Brown Harris Stevens are marketing the property; they could not immediately be reached for comment.

UPDATE: This story was updated to add a statement from Randy Mastro. 





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Two penthouse apartments were sold at 150 East 78th Street with the intent of combining them (Compass)
    Double penthouse asking $33M is priciest listing snapped up
    Double penthouse asking $33M is priciest listing snapped up
    Ford estate fetches $105M, a Hamptons “record” but far below ask
    Ford estate fetches $105M, a Hamptons “record” but far below ask
    Ford estate fetches $105M, a Hamptons “record” but far below ask
    HRI founder Aaron Carr and Virginia Attorney General Mark Herring (Facebook, Getty)
    Housing Rights probe pins voucher discrimination on VA landlords, brokers
    Housing Rights probe pins voucher discrimination on VA landlords, brokers
    School and office reopenings led to fewer reservations at the end of summer. (iStock)
    Hamptons rental market had strong summer, begins to cool
    Hamptons rental market had strong summer, begins to cool
    Zillow CEO Rich Barton (Getty, iStock)
    Zillow hits the brakes on iBuying
    Zillow hits the brakes on iBuying
    More than 27,000 Long Island households behind on rent
    More than 27,000 Long Island households behind on rent
    More than 27,000 Long Island households behind on rent
    91 Sergio Franchi Drive and Sergio Franchi (Sotheby's, Getty)
    Sergio Franchi’s 200-acre Connecticut estate lists for $12.6M
    Sergio Franchi’s 200-acre Connecticut estate lists for $12.6M
    Automatic for the people: SmartRent CEO on why landlords are going all-in on connected homes
    Automatic for the people: SmartRent CEO on why landlords are going all-in on connected homes
    Automatic for the people: SmartRent CEO on why landlords are going all-in on connected homes
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...