HFZ, Marble Collegiate Church lose NoMad development site

Vanbarton Group took control of property at foreclosure auction

New York /
Apr.April 23, 2021 03:09 PM
HFZ Capital Group's Ziel Feldman, a rendering of 29th&5th and Marble Collegiate Church (Getty, HFZ)

HFZ Capital Group’s Ziel Feldman, a rendering of 29th&5th and Marble Collegiate Church (Getty, HFZ)

After an 11th-hour effort to stave off foreclosure, HFZ Capital Group and the Marble Collegiate Church have lost control of their NoMad joint venture.

Mezzanine lender Vanbarton Group took control of the development site at Fifth Avenue and West 29th Street, where the church has stood since 1854, in a UCC foreclosure auction Friday afternoon, according to Matthew Mannion of Mannion Auctions, which conducted the auction.

Representatives for HFZ and the Marble Collegiate Church were not immediately available for comment, and a representative for the Vanbarton Group declined to comment.

The tug-of-war over ownership of the site, where HFZ planned to develop a 34-story office tower, came to an end after HFZ made a last-ditch effort to retain control. The developer on Thursday applied for a temporary restraining order to delay the auction and, earlier Friday, threatened to throw the project into bankruptcy to gum up the works.

A judge felt the borrowers were in disarray and denied the restraining order, a source familiar with the case said.

In addition to HFZ and Marble Collegiate Church’s efforts to halt the auction, a trio of EB-5 investors also pursued a temporary restraining order in an attempt to avert foreclosure proceedings. Attorneys for the Marble Collegiate Church argued against the EB-5 investors’ application for a TRO.

Friday’s UCC auction was the latest blow for HFZ, which has been embattled by lawsuits and financial problems, including foreclosure proceedings on multiple other development projects in Manhattan, since late last year.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    5 East 59th Street (Google Maps, 5e59.com)
    Singapore bank sues to foreclose on ex-Playboy Club building
    Singapore bank sues to foreclose on ex-Playboy Club building
    (iStock)
    Illinois has highest foreclosure rate in the country
    Illinois has highest foreclosure rate in the country
    Two of the eleven properties under threat of foreclosure (Google Maps)
    Mack Real Estate may “strip” club owner of properties
    Mack Real Estate may “strip” club owner of properties
    Vanbarton pitches Financial District office tower as resi conversion
    Vanbarton pitches Financial District office tower as resi conversion
    Vanbarton pitches Financial District office tower as resi conversion
    Ranee Bartolacci, Nir Meir with the Sunset Islands home (Getty, Massa Construction Group)
    Wife of embattled former HFZ principal alleges Miami Beach luxe rental was filled with rats, moldy bathrooms
    Wife of embattled former HFZ principal alleges Miami Beach luxe rental was filled with rats, moldy bathrooms
    Torchlight Investors CEO Daniel Heflin and 445 Fifth Ave (Google Maps, National Institute of Public Finance)
    Harbor Group owes more money in Fifth Ave foreclosure suit, lender claims
    Harbor Group owes more money in Fifth Ave foreclosure suit, lender claims
    Vanbarton Group’s Gary M. Tischler and Richard Coles with Marble Collegiate Church at 1 West 29th Street (Getty)
    Vanbarton Group, church sued by foreign investors in fallout from HFZ debacle
    Vanbarton Group, church sued by foreign investors in fallout from HFZ debacle
    In Illinois, one in every 3,848 housing units received a foreclosure filing last month. (iStock)
    August foreclosures jump 27% after federal moratorium expires
    August foreclosures jump 27% after federal moratorium expires
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...