Two Bridges project opponents lose final appeal

State’s highest court declines to hear bid to stop four towers

New York /
May.May 27, 2021 05:05 PM
Rendering of Two Bridges project with Starrett’s Josh Siegel, JDS Development’s Michael Stern and L&M’s Ron Moelis

Rendering of Two Bridges project with Starrett’s Josh Siegel, JDS Development’s Michael Stern and L&M’s Ron Moelis

The lengthy legal battle to prevent the construction of four massive towers in Two Bridges has come to an end.

The New York Court of Appeals declined to hear cases from two community groups to stop new development projects planned for the Lower Manhattan neighborhood.

The rejection comes a few months after the Appellate Division overturned two decisions by a Supreme Court judge. The Appellate Division’s decision was unanimous, which meant the groups had to get approval from the state’s highest court to get their case heard. Very few such requests are granted.

Community groups had claimed that developers’ proposed modification to the Two Bridges large-scale development plan — a framework approved in 1972 — required further examination by the city and needed City Council approval. The de Blasio administration disagreed and stood behind the agency staffers who signed off on the project.

The projects — JDS Development’s 247 Cherry Street, L+M Development and CIM Group’s 260 South Street and Starrett Corporation’s 259 Clinton Street — would have 2,775 rental units across four towers at three addresses. A quarter of those units would be set aside as affordable.

The developers also plan to upgrade a local subway station and finance repairs at a nearby public housing complex.

A spokesperson for the developers said, “We appreciate the court’s review and look forward to delivering on those benefits.”

The community groups who brought the lawsuits claim they will keep fighting even though the court’s decision essentially ended any chance of stopping the projects in a courtroom.

“There’s not a single shovel in the ground,” the Lower East Side Organized Neighbors said in a statement. “It’s important for residents and supporters of our No Towers, No Compromise campaign to know that this is still not a done deal, and our fight against displacement is far from over.”

Trever Holland of Tenants United Fighting for the Lower East Side said, “Although we are incredibly disappointed by the court’s rejection of our request that they review the Appellate Division decision, we will continue to pursue all options to stop these towers.”

The developments were halted in June 2019 when Supreme Court Judge Arthur Engoron agreed with the New York City Council and Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer that the projects must go through the city’s land use review process. In February 2020, Engoron also ruled in favor of community groups in two other lawsuits challenging the projects.

But the Appellate Division reversed Engoron’s first decision in August 2020 and his other two in February.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Children’s Magical Garden at at 157 Norfolk Street (Google Maps, Facebook)
    Children’s Magical Garden claps back against developer who claimed defamation
    Children’s Magical Garden claps back against developer who claimed defamation
    Clockwise from top left: 2875 Morningside Heights, 38-21 12th Street in Long Island City, 46 Nevins Street in Brooklyn (Google Maps)
    Investors flip NYC industrial, hotel, office buildings in pre-holiday frenzy
    Investors flip NYC industrial, hotel, office buildings in pre-holiday frenzy
    259 Clinton Street (Perkins Eastman/McNamara Salvia)
    Another huge Two Bridges project is for sale
    Another huge Two Bridges project is for sale
    Illustration of Zillow CEO Richard Barton (Getty, iStock/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
    Zestimate: These two Zillow iBuying lawsuits won’t be the last
    Zestimate: These two Zillow iBuying lawsuits won’t be the last
    5 East 59th Street (Google Maps, 5e59.com)
    Singapore bank sues to foreclose on ex-Playboy Club building
    Singapore bank sues to foreclose on ex-Playboy Club building
    Top October loans: Cash cows, big buys, foreclosure avoidance
    Top October loans: Cash cows, big buys, foreclosure avoidance
    Top October loans: Cash cows, big buys, foreclosure avoidance
    Jill, Harry Karman sue Upper East Side neighbor over unfinished renovation
    Jill, Harry Karman sue Upper East Side neighbor over unfinished renovation
    Jill, Harry Karman sue Upper East Side neighbor over unfinished renovation
    Joe Chetrit and a rendering of the Two Bridges project (SHoP Architects)
    Joe Chetrit buying Two Bridges site
    Joe Chetrit buying Two Bridges site
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...