Shelter Island home, circa 1750, lists for $15M

Colonial on 23 acres hits market amid surge in East End buying

Tri-State /
Jun.June 03, 2021 08:30 AM
 81-82 South Midway Road (Saunders & Associates Real Estate)

81-82 South Midway Road (Saunders & Associates Real Estate)

In Shelter Island, a 270-year-old wood-shingled Colonial has hit the red-hot East End market, asking $15 million.

The circa 1750 home was built by George Havens, an early Shelter Island settler who named it “Kemah,” a Shinnecock word meaning “in the face of the wind,” according to the listing. The property is on 23 acres, at 81-82 South Midway Road.

It has been renovated and added to over time. That includes a two-story 1,600-square-foot barn built in 1886, a hand-stacked fieldstone garage built in 1918, a water tower and chicken coop.

The grounds include 385 feet on Great Fresh Pond, 5.6 acres of meadow and 596 feet on Peconic Bay. A large berm constructed to protect the freshwater from saltwater intrusion at the pond — and built before the property was developed — still exists.

The 3,000-square-foot home itself has six bedrooms, two full bathrooms, two half bathrooms, and a wide brick fireplace.

Penelope Moore of Saunders & Associates has the listing.

Long Island — and the East End in particular — has seen massive demand over the past year.

In Southampton, a home once owned by fashion designer and Broadway dancer Luba Marks closed last month for $29 million. It had been asking $37 million.

Last year, the most expensive properties sold in the Hamptons were largely in the $30 million to $40 million range, although one topped $84 million. The priciest sale so far this year has been for $60 million.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    DoorDash's Tony Xu with 51 Eads Street and 6133 Jericho Turnpike
    Startup plans LI convenience stores that shoppers can’t enter
    Startup plans LI convenience stores that shoppers can’t enter
    From left: The Beechwood Organization's principal Steven Dubb and founder Michael Dubb in front of a rendering of Country Point Elwood in Huntington (The Beechwood Organization, iStock)
    Beechwood plans 385 townhomes on North Shore
    Beechwood plans 385 townhomes on North Shore
    Jersey Mike's CEO Peter Cancro in front of 1500 Smithtown Avenue in Bohemia, Long Island (Jersey Mike's, Google Maps, iStock/Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
    Sandwich chain Jersey Mike’s expanding in NY
    Sandwich chain Jersey Mike’s expanding in NY
    Baiting Hollow Golf Club at 100 Club Drive in Baiting Hollow, NY (Loopnet)
    Architect plans 30-home, energy-efficient community in the North Fork
    Architect plans 30-home, energy-efficient community in the North Fork
    World Wide Group's James Stanton, Suchman Group's Jeffrey Suchman and rendering of 66 Nowedonah Avenue in Water Mill NY (World Wide Group, Getty Images, The Water Mill Crossing)
    JS Squared gets financing to build 38 Water Mill townhomes
    JS Squared gets financing to build 38 Water Mill townhomes
    (iStock/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
    Manhattan market cools as mortgage rates rise; Brooklyn busier
    Manhattan market cools as mortgage rates rise; Brooklyn busier
    Town of Oyster Bay supervisor Joseph Saladino (Town of Oyster, Google Maps, iStock)
    Owners reject offer for parking lot by LIRR, so town moves to seize it
    Owners reject offer for parking lot by LIRR, so town moves to seize it
    Prologis' Hamid Moghadam with 600 Grumman Road West (Prologis, Google Maps, iStock)
    Prologis buys Nassau site for $51M, plans project
    Prologis buys Nassau site for $51M, plans project
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...