Landlords sue federal gov’t over rental losses during CDC eviction ban

National Apartment Association estimates federal rent relief will fall short by $27B

National /
Jul.July 28, 2021 03:45 PM
NAA president Robert Pinnegar (iStock, NAA)

NAA president Robert Pinnegar (iStock, NAA)

In three days, the federal ban on evictions is set to expire, allowing landlords in most states to take non-paying tenants to court.

But property owners say they deserve more than the freedom to join a backlogged docket. They want money.

The National Apartment Association, a landlord group, filed a lawsuit in federal claims court Tuesday demanding that the federal government compensate housing providers who have “suffered severe economic losses” during the eviction moratorium imposed by the Centers for Disease Control since September.

The complaint estimates that landlords are grappling with $26.6 billion in debt that will not be covered by the $50 billion in federal rental assistance funds — a mere 6.5 percent of which had been distributed as of last week — and argues that the CDC’s eviction ban violated the constitutional rights of landlords.

The suit alleges the moratorium infringed upon housing providers’ right to access the courts, freedom to enter into contracts without government interference and the right to demand compensation when property is seized through government action.

John McDermott, one of the attorneys representing the plaintiffs on the case, said the Supreme Court case Cedar Point Nursery v. Hassid, decided last month, sets a precedent for the NAA filing. The judge in that case ruled that physical entry onto a property — in this instance, for a few hours — was a physical taking for which owners must be compensated.

NAA’s suit aims to apply that ruling to the eviction ban.

“What happens if somebody’s on your property for months?” said Jay Martin, executive director of the Community Housing Improvement Program, an organization representing New York City property owners.

“If government is instituting the policy which allows someone to stay without paying, then government accepts the responsibility of paying on behalf of the tenant.”

In the Cedar Point case, the judge kicked the decision on what to award in damages down to a lower court, which has yet to rule. Plaintiffs’ attorney McDermott said how much to award is usually “what is at issue.”

Property owners in states and cities with their own eviction bans, such as California, Illinois and New York, cannot participate in NAA’s suit.

However, Martin said he would not be surprised if New York landlords filed a similar action in the event that the state’s emergency rental assistance program proves insufficient in covering arrears. The program is one of the latest in the country to launch, and thus far has reportedly distributed a measly $117,000.

“There will definitely be owners who are not completely made whole,” said Martin. “And there is probably interest from the real estate industry to launch a lawsuit that would demand some sort of compensation for being forced to house people throughout the pandemic.”





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Two more rent law challenges tossed, landlords reserve hope in appeal
    Two more rent law challenges tossed, landlords rest hopes on appeal
    Two more rent law challenges tossed, landlords rest hopes on appeal
    Tritec Principal Robert Coughlan with the project (Tritec)
    Tritec lands $173M for Bay Shore Residences
    Tritec lands $173M for Bay Shore Residences
    A recent report by Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies shows mom-and-pop landlords were hit harder than big firms by rental delinquencies. (iStock)
    Mom-and-pop landlords, Black tenants hit harder by pandemic: report
    Mom-and-pop landlords, Black tenants hit harder by pandemic: report
    New Yorkers who signed concession-laden apartment deals during the pandemic are finding a rude surprise when it's time to renew. (iStock)
    New York: Welcome to the era of sky-high renewals
    New York: Welcome to the era of sky-high renewals
    Gov. Kathy Hochul, who announced today that the state has now approved or distributed $1.2 billion in federal rental assistance funds (Getty)
    After huge head start for rest of US, NY now ranks 1st in rent relief rollout
    After huge head start for rest of US, NY now ranks 1st in rent relief rollout
    1 Boerum Place in Brooklyn and Avery Hall founding partner Avi Fisher (Avery Hall)
    One Boerum Place lands $177M recapitalization
    One Boerum Place lands $177M recapitalization
    National Association of Realtors moves to block antitrust probe
    National Association of Realtors moves to block antitrust probe
    National Association of Realtors moves to block antitrust probe
    NBA store settles rent-collection lawsuit suit with landlord Moinian Group
    NBA store settles rent-collection lawsuit suit with landlord Moinian Group
    NBA store settles rent-collection lawsuit suit with landlord Moinian Group
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...