NIMBYs plague rezonings in the Hamptons, too

Judge halts development plan after resident with no legal background sued, citing density concerns

Tri-State /
Aug.August 02, 2021 07:00 AM
Judge halts Hampton Bays downtown revitalization plan

Revitalization Initiatives for the Hampton Bays (South Hampton Town Gov.)

Plans to revitalize the Hampton Bays downtown district hit a snag after an unlikely legal challenge to halt rezoning succeeded in state court.

On July 20, a state court judge reversed the Southampton town board’s decision to adopt new zoning plans for the hamlet that would encourage development of a new mixed-use downtown modeled after Sag Harbor and Southampton Village, according to Southampton Press.

The decision came after Gayle Lombardi, a Hampton Bays resident with no formal legal training, filed an Article 78 proceeding to appeal the new zoning plans. Despite long odds, Lombardi’s suit successfully demonstrated that Southampton’s environmental review failed to consider the full scope of the rezoning’s impact on local water supplies, according to the report.

The saga began in February 2020, when the Southampton Town Board approved plans for a new Hampton Bays Downtown Overlay District. The plan was developed after years of consultations with residents and contractors, and laid out preferred design aesthetics for a revitalized downtown. The plan would have consolidated 13 square miles of projected development into 45 acres of land, Lombardi told Southampton Press.

Troubled by the relatively high density — the plan would limit building height to the lesser of 35 feet or two stories — Lombardi began reviewing her legal options. That June, she filed the Article 78, which allows residents to appeal local government agency decisions.

Most government projects in New York require an environmental review, meant to identify and mitigate any potential harms the development may inflict on the surrounding environment. State Supreme Court Judge Joseph Santorelli found that Southampton’s review failed to fully consider how the new district would affect Hampton Bays’ troubled water supply system.

In recent years, the town has battled discolored, low-pressure water, with a recent investigation finding “significant deficiencies in the water supply system.”

Southampton Town Supervisor Jay Schneiderman called the judge’s ruling “a temporary setback forcing us to examine concerns we have already fully vetted.”

[SP] – Joe Lovinger





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
     Lloyd and Barbara Macklowe and Hard Rock Cafe's Peter Morton with  51 West End Road (Getty, Google Maps)
    Macklowe Gallery founders sell East Hampton home to Hard Rock founder
    Macklowe Gallery founders sell East Hampton home to Hard Rock founder
    (Getty)
    Hamptons home prices dip, but North Fork’s hit another record
    Hamptons home prices dip, but North Fork’s hit another record
    Ian Bruce Eichner, 45 East 22nd Street
    Eichner’s Madison Square Park saga enters final act
    Eichner’s Madison Square Park saga enters final act
    Steve Roth finally flips Madoff’s former Montauk home
    Steve Roth finally flips Madoff’s former Montauk home
    Steve Roth finally flips Madoff’s former Montauk home
    Douglas Elliman's Todd Bourgard (Douglas Elliman, Getty)
    Elliman taps new head of Long Island
    Elliman taps new head of Long Island
    A rendering of 2900 Central Avenue
    Howling good time: Dog waterpark and bar to open in Florida
    Howling good time: Dog waterpark and bar to open in Florida
    89-acre Vanderbilt Berkshires Estate, formerly Elm Court
    Law and Associates buy 89-acre Vanderbilt estate for $8M
    Law and Associates buy 89-acre Vanderbilt estate for $8M
    Prada CEO Gianfranco D’Attis and 16 Gould Street (Getty; Google Maps)
    East Hampton board rejects Prada CEO’s request for 11 variances
    East Hampton board rejects Prada CEO’s request for 11 variances
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...