Judge who struck down CDC eviction ban questions new ban’s legal standing

Judge Dabney Friedrich suggested the White House has engaged in “a degree of gamesmanship”

National /
Aug.August 10, 2021 10:00 AM
President Joe Biden and Judge Dabney Friedrich (Getty, Senate/Chris Coons, iStock)

President Joe Biden and Judge Dabney Friedrich (Getty, Senate/Chris Coons, iStock)

A federal judge who previously struck down the CDC’s eviction ban suggested the White House lacked the legal authority to issue its new targeted eviction moratorium in a hearing Monday.

U.S. District Judge Dabney Friedrich held the hearing after a group of realtors and property managers challenged the new eviction moratorium, which was adopted on August 3. Friedrich didn’t make a ruling on the challenge but hopes to do so soon, according to the Wall Street Journal.

Friedrich previously ruled in May that the CDC’s eviction moratorium didn’t pass legal muster. It remained in place pending litigation, however, and narrowly survived a Supreme Court challenge before expiring at the end of July.

In a brief statement, Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote that a new moratorium would require congressional approval, which did not happen. After Democratic lawmakers failed to rally sufficient support for an extension prior to its July 31 expiration, the White House unilaterally issued a new moratorium. Nevertheless, Friedrich expressed doubt about her ability to block the new moratorium.

Biden himself has noted the potential legal problem of the new moratorium, which covers an estimated 90 percent of renters in the U.S.. The administration hopes that it will buy time for the distribution of $47 billion in federal aid, which has still largely not found its ways to landlords and tenants.

“None of these justices gave their reasoning, so we don’t know exactly what they thought,” Judge Friedrich said in the hearing Monday, suggesting that the White House had engaged in “a degree of gamesmanship” in pushing through the extension this month.

The National Association of Realtors is supporting the challenge to the new moratorium, which could have more support than it would have a month or two ago given the rise of the Delta variant. An estimated 3.6 million renters were considered to be in danger of eviction when the previous moratorium expired.

Local moratoriums in some states, such as New Jersey and New York, remain in place.

[WSJ] — Holden Walter-Warner





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Suburbanites with pitchforks as two hands ripping building plans
    Suburban Nimbys oppose more housing. Do they have a point?
    Suburban Nimbys oppose more housing. Do they have a point?
    Gale Brewer (Getty, Gale Brewer)
    City takes aim at landlords’ empty retail space
    City takes aim at landlords’ empty retail space
    From left: Silverstein Properties' Larry Silverstein and New York City Councilmember Julie Won along with a rendering of Innovation QNS (Getty Images, Julie Won for City Council, Innovation QNS Official Site)
    Silverstein’s Astoria megaproject ups affordable housing commitment
    Silverstein’s Astoria megaproject ups affordable housing commitment
    MR Property Builders' Rich Rauff and 45th Street between Pacific and Prospect Streets in Copiague (Getty Images, Google Maps, MR Property Builders)
    Honey, they shrunk the housing: Long Island project withers
    Honey, they shrunk the housing: Long Island project withers
    Village of Lawrence mayor Alex Edelman (Facebook, Getty)
    Shovels down! Hempstead Town halts development in two villages
    Shovels down! Hempstead Town halts development in two villages
    A photo illustration of Daniel Brodsky and 75 West End Avenue (Getty Images, Google Maps)
    Brodsky brings challenge to NYC Airbnb law
    Brodsky brings challenge to NYC Airbnb law
    (Illustration by The Real Deal with Getty)
    How illegal Airbnbs slip through the cracks
    How illegal Airbnbs slip through the cracks
    From left: Boston Mayor Michelle Wu and South Boston Senator Nick Collins with Boston City Hall
    Controversial transfer tax bill advances in Boston
    Controversial transfer tax bill advances in Boston
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...