The pandemic gave NYC office buildings $29B haircut

First decline in billable values in 2 decades: Comptroller

New York /
Oct.October 11, 2021 09:47 AM
State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli (iStock, Getty)

State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli (iStock, Getty)

The pandemic’s impact on the New York City office market remains unrelenting, according to figures from the state comptroller.

The market value of office buildings in the city dropped by $28.6 billion — 16.6 percent — during the last fiscal year, per the report from State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli. That marks the first decline since at least 2000.

In the previous fiscal year, the total market value of office properties in the city reached $172 billion.

Other indicators from the second quarter tell the story of the pandemic’s crippling effect on the office market. Asking rents averaged $70.26, below the $72 average seen by each of the last five years. The office vacancy rate hit a 30-year high of 18.6 percent, easily outpacing the 15.2 percent rate at the end of 2020.

Among the city’s three major business districts, Midtown South is showing the least amount of resilience. The average asking rent has declined more than 10 percent since the first quarter of 2020, while the vacancy rate has soared 9 percent. In Midtown and Downtown, asking rents are down between 3 and 4 percent, while the vacancy rate has increased between 6 and 7 percent.

The city stands to lose about $1.7 billion in property tax revenue during the current fiscal year, more than half being driven by the loss in office building values.

Some of the city’s most expensive properties have taken massive hits in the wake of the pandemic. The World Trade Center’s market value has dropped 23.1 percent during the pandemic, per the comptroller’s report, and other buildings stand to lose at least 10 percent of market value, including the GM Building, the Bank of America Tower and the Solow Building.

Amid the uncertainty over the future of the city’s office market, recent weeks have presented glimmers of hope.

The third quarter saw Manhattan’s office market hit an inflection point as demand finally exceeded supply, The Real Deal previously reported. Colliers International’s quarterly market report said leasing volume from July to September rose to 7.23 million square feet, up by 58.8 percent from the second quarter. Quarterly net absorption turned positive at 0.87 million square feet.

Google last month shattered a pandemic record with its purchase of St. John’s Terminal in Hudson Square for $2.1 billion. The sale was the biggest of an office building in the United States since the pandemic began.

In a report released late last month, Cushman & Wakefield predicted a migration back to the office beginning in the first quarter of 2022. The study cited vaccine mandates and the leveling off of Delta variant infections in the coming months as encouraging indicators for back-to-office deadlines finally happening.

“Most businesses are hoping to get back as soon as possible,” David Smith, a co-author of Cushman’s study, told TRD’s Akiko Matsuda. “Based on surging tour activity, we know demand is there — so it’s not a matter of if office buildings will re-populate, but when.”





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    A photo illustration of Related Companies' Jeff Blau (Getty)
    Related proposes 1,500-room resort in Hudson Yards casino bid
    Related proposes 1,500-room resort in Hudson Yards casino bid
    Jared Kushner and 666 Fifth Avenue (Getty, David Shankbone, CC BY 2.5 - via Wikimedia Commons)
    Congress probes Jared Kushner’s dealings amid 666 Fifth Avenue sale
    Congress probes Jared Kushner’s dealings amid 666 Fifth Avenue sale
    Related Companies' Stephen Ross and Related Group's Jorge Pérez (Getty; Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
    End of a Related era: Steve Ross confirms split with Jorge Pérez as firms expand in South Florida
    End of a Related era: Steve Ross confirms split with Jorge Pérez as firms expand in South Florida
    Council member Pierina Ana Sanchez and RSA’s Joseph Strasburg (Getty; Twitter)
    Citing Bronx fire, Council pushes building violation crackdown
    Citing Bronx fire, Council pushes building violation crackdown
    SB Development’s Joseph Stern and Northwind’s Ran Eliasaf with rendering of Nova (LinkedIn, NOVA)
    SB Development, Hazelton Capital score $62M loan for LIC condo tower
    SB Development, Hazelton Capital score $62M loan for LIC condo tower
    Illustration of Mayor Eric Adams (Getty; Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
    Oh, rats! Eric Adams contests summons for infestation
    Oh, rats! Eric Adams contests summons for infestation
    Brookfield's Bruce Flatt with 1100 Newark Turnpike (Loopnet, Brookfield)
    Brookfield buys CSX industrial site in Northern New Jersey for $67M
    Brookfield buys CSX industrial site in Northern New Jersey for $67M
    (Getty; Illustration by The Real Deal)
    TikTokers are office work’s biggest cheerleaders
    TikTokers are office work’s biggest cheerleaders
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...