Empire State Realty’s multifamily play baffles experts, investors

Office REIT’s move into unfamiliar, competitive market strikes many as ill-fated

New York /
Nov.November 03, 2021 08:00 AM
Empire State Realty Trust CEO Tony Malkin (Getty, iStock)

Empire State Realty Trust CEO Tony Malkin (Getty, iStock)

Empire State Realty Trust’s foray into multifamily has analysts scratching their heads — and shareholders selling.

Although the New York City office landlord had signaled that it would pursue opportunities in other asset classes, its $307 million purchase of Manhattan apartments came as a shock. The company, with just its third acquisition since its 2013 public debut, is venturing into an unfamiliar market facing regulatory headwinds.

Even before the pandemic, multifamily REITs were scaling out of politically exposed areas like New York and California in favor of Sun Belt cities that have benefited from population shifts. Air Communities, the AIMCO spinoff, just sold an 11-property New York City portfolio. Equity Residential and AvalonBay, the two largest multifamily REITs by market capitalization, also have been scaling down in the city.

“It’s been communicated to the market that there are some regulatory risks that should be priced into returns in Manhattan multifamily,” said BMO Capital Markets analyst John Kim, who has a “market perform” rating on Empire State Realty.

Among the dangers for landlords is pro-tenant sentiment in New York politics that could lead lawmakers to restrict rent increases and evictions indefinitely. One upside is that rising home prices have boosted demand for rentals.

Sam Zell of Equity Commonwealth (Getty)

Sam Zell of Equity Commonwealth (Getty)

Kim compared Empire State Realty’s multifamily play to the bid that Sam Zell’s Equity Commonwealth, another office REIT, recently made for the industrial landlord Monmouth Real Estate.

“You have all this cash and you’re looking for an opportunistic investment, and then at the end of the day you’re just buying the hot asset class that is already well known and invested in by so many other companies,” Kim said.

Empire State Realty did not respond to a request for comment.

Investors have not warmed to Empire State Realty’s purchase of two Manhattan buildings with 625 apartments in all.

Its stock, already heavily discounted because of the office market’s struggles and a stop in tourism at the Empire State Building, has sunk by roughly 10 percent since disclosure of the purchase. Management has not provided a capitalization rate on the deal, which is expected to close in the fourth quarter, nor has it identified the third party that will retain a 10 percent stake and manage the assets.

Empire State Realty Trust CEO Tony Malkin

Empire State Realty Trust CEO Tony Malkin (Getty)

On the company’s third-quarter earnings call, CEO Tony Malkin was ambiguous about the company’s long-term plans in multifamily. It is unclear whether Empire State Realty Trust ultimately will manage its apartment assets in-house — a factor that analysts deem essential to compete in such a crowded, intense field.

The purchases represent “an opportunity to expand,” Malkin said on the call.

“We like the opportunity relative to what else we might do,” he said. “And while I wouldn’t put it past us at some point to have an internal platform, I would say that the partner we have here is an excellent proven partner and that will become obvious as we’re able to disclose. And we may even have an opportunity to build within that relationship as well.”

Empire State Realty will have a steep climb.

Malkin’s family-controlled entity, Malkin Holdings, owns a few thousand apartments outside New York, and the CEO has touted the managerial expertise within Empire State Realty’s ranks. But the REIT itself does not have a public history owning and operating apartments, nor does it have a favorable cost of capital to grow the business, Danny Ismail, senior analyst at Green Street, said in a research note.

The company trades at a far greater discount to net asset value than the dominant multifamily REITs such as Equity Residential.

Moreover, Empire State Realty’s move into multifamily bucks the REIT industry’s “pure-play” standard since the 2008 financial crisis.

“Mixed-use REITs generally have a ‘muddy’ story with little observable benefit in the public market,” Ismail said. In other words, firms that specialize have done better.

Diversified companies’ prominence in REIT indexes has been on the decline for years. Today, most operate in the triple-net sector, and together they comprise less than 4 percent of the market capitalization of the FTSE NAREIT Equity REITs index, according to John Worth, executive vice president of research and investor outreach at NAREIT, the industry trade association.

Investors typically have gravitated to names with a singular focus because their businesses are easier to read, Worth said. “We’ve definitely seen this trend toward pure-play by property sector, diversification by geography.”

However, office REIT shareholders today have bigger worries than landlords’ forays into other asset types, he said.

“The concerns investors have is about the entirety of the office space and whether demand is going to grow post-Covid the way it was growing pre-Covid,” Worth said. “That’s a more systemic issue.”





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Clockwise from top left: 162 West 13th Street, 325 Avenue Y in Brooklyn, 1281 Viele Avenue in the Bronx (Credit: Google Maps)
    Here’s what the $10M-$30M NYC investment sales market looked like last week
    Here’s what the $10M-$30M NYC investment sales market looked like last week
    Real Capital Analytics data showed that New York’s multifamily market had a very slow July. (Credit: iStock)
    New NYC rent law “beginning to shut down investment”
    New NYC rent law “beginning to shut down investment”
    Numbers were down across the board (Credit: iStock)
    New York’s multifamily market had its slowest first half of the year since 2011
    New York’s multifamily market had its slowest first half of the year since 2011
    Meyer Orbach with One and Two Sutton Place North (CityRealty)
    Meyer Orbach, Josh Gotlib close on $850M of Solow apartments
    Meyer Orbach, Josh Gotlib close on $850M of Solow apartments
    From left: Wafra’s Fawaz Al-Mubaraki and The Westover Companies’ Guntram Weissenberger with 138 East 12th Street (JLL, Getty, Wafra, The Westover Companies)
    Wafra sells East Village’s The Nathaniel for $57M
    Wafra sells East Village’s The Nathaniel for $57M
    Napa Valley hot-air-balloon business lists for $12M
    Napa Valley hot-air-balloon business lists for $12M
    Napa Valley hot-air-balloon business lists for $12M
    A photo illustration of the proposed Lower Platte River Corridor (Getty, Plan Preserve Play NE)
    Nebraska lawmakers mull digging $1B recreation lake
    Nebraska lawmakers mull digging $1B recreation lake
    From left: 608 Fifth Avenue, 22 North Loop Road, 38 West 36th Street (608 Fifth, Weiss/Manfredi, Morphosis, and Handel Architects, Apartments, Getty)
    Top 10 Manhattan loans: Big lending enters deep freeze
    Top 10 Manhattan loans: Big lending enters deep freeze
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...