City Council advances protections for lease-breakers

Bill would prevent residential landlords from seeking early termination fees

New York /
Nov.November 23, 2021 09:00 AM

From left: Luise Barrack of Rosenberg & Estis, Bronx City Council member Kevin Riley and Tashi Lhewa of the Legal Aid Society (New York City Council, Getty Images, the Legal Aid Society, iStock)

Landlords’ leverage over lease-breakers has been slipping away like a tenant in the night.

Security deposits once offered months of cushion. And if a renter cut out early, an owner could sue for the remaining balance rather than hustle for a replacement.

Then state lawmakers took landlords behind the woodshed in 2019. Landlords can no longer demand advance payment of the final month’s rent in addition to a security deposit. Another state measure forced upon owners the “duty to mitigate damages” — that is, re-rent the unit for a fair-market rate or whatever the previous tenant paid, whichever is lower. A new renter would let the previous one off the hook.

Monday, the City Council advanced an addition to those tenant protections. The Housing and Buildings Committee passed a bill that limits the fees a landlord can recover from a departing tenant to the “fair market cost” of getting the apartment in good-enough shape to relist. The bill also requires owners to give tenants an itemized list of what the charges would be.

Luise Barrack, attorney at Rosenberg & Estis, says the change is no great divergence from the 2019 overhaul of rent stabilization.

“I’m not really sure what [the City Council] thinks it added to the New York state law,” she said. “We’re all clear about it now. Owners can’t take advantage of a tenant who leaves an apartment early.”

The city’s bill applies to all apartments, not just rent-stabilized ones. But it may be more window dressing than anything — a resume-padder for the two-thirds of City Council members term-limited out of office next month, when the full chamber could vote on the bill.

Tashi Lhewa, consumer attorney at the Legal Aid Society, said generally, her organization does not see landlords suing for early termination fees when a residential tenant breaks a lease.

“These fees primarily arise in a commercial lease context,” she said.

And the city’s tweaks do not preclude a landlord from suing for rent or for the costs of finding a new tenant, such as advertising or repairs.

The difference is that the new law would clarify for the court what tenants owe. Lhewa siad “fair market cost” is an easier standard than the existing one, established via case law.

Councilmember Kevin Riley, who introduced the bill, was not present at the hearing held Monday, when the bill passed 8-0 alongside another bill that aims to put artwork on construction fences.

Barrack added that even before the rent law passed, most owners opted for re-renting an apartment quickly over trying to sue for damages. Litigation, she said, risks “the chance that you bring an action to recover the money, but don’t recover the money.”

“Most wise owners typically don’t want to sue people,” she said.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    WeWork CEO Sandeep Mathrani (Mathrani/Wikipemedia, Getty)
    WeWork says it must correct financial statements
    WeWork says it must correct financial statements
    601 Madison Ave. and Ben Soleimani (Google Maps, Ben Soleimani)
    Ben Soleimani leases 12,000 square feet on Madison Avenue
    Ben Soleimani leases 12,000 square feet on Madison Avenue
    Rolling Gardens Apartment Homes at 405 Franklin Turnpike in Mahwah NJ (Apartments.com)
    Morgan Properties trades NJ multifamily portfolio for $57.5M
    Morgan Properties trades NJ multifamily portfolio for $57.5M
    645 Madison Avenue (Google Maps)
    645 Madison ground lease trades to Titan Golden for $27M
    645 Madison ground lease trades to Titan Golden for $27M
    Blackstone's Stephen Schwarzman (Getty)
    Blackstone buys logistics portfolio for $2.8B
    Blackstone buys logistics portfolio for $2.8B
    Virtual real estate speculators notch another record deal
    Virtual real estate speculators notch another record deal
    Virtual real estate speculators notch another record deal
     Jeff Sutton of Wharton Properties, 25 West 34th Street in NYC (Google Maps)
    Jeff Sutton’s Midtown hotel project snags Sonder as first tenant
    Jeff Sutton’s Midtown hotel project snags Sonder as first tenant
    City law protecting commercial tenants upheld on appeal
    City law protecting commercial tenants upheld on appeal
    City law protecting commercial tenants upheld on appeal
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...