“Our existence is a tragedy”: Housing Rights calls for enforcement overhaul from Hochul

After $1M settlement, tenant advocacy group founder Aaron Carr called for gov’t action

New York /
Dec.December 07, 2021 12:04 PM
HRI's Aaron Carr and 3045 Godwin Terrace (Facebook, Google Maps)

HRI’s Aaron Carr and 3045 Godwin Terrace (Facebook, Google Maps)

The tenant advocacy group that’s made a name for itself taking landlords to court is rounding out 2021 with another win for tenants — and a message for the governor.

The Housing Rights Initiative this week celebrated its investigation into J-51 rent overcharges that secured a $1 million settlement for a group of Bronx renters. The tenants of 3045 Godwin Terrace in 2018 brought a class-action suit against landlord Richard Albert after HRI revealed the managing member of Godwin Realty had signed tenants on for market-rate lease while reaping the benefits of the J-51 tax break. The program requires buildings to keep units stabilized while receiving the benefit.

The tenants are set to receive up to $100,0000 in refunds and current residents can bank on a rent reduction of 20 to 30 percent and see their units returned to stabilization.

HRI founder Aaron Carr seized on the agreement as an opportunity to turn Gov. Kathy Hochul’s head.

In a tweet thread posted Sunday night, Carr called on the governor and state legislature to “overhaul NYS’s housing enforcement agency and put our nonprofit out of business.”

“People may celebrate our organization for combating real estate fraud, but the truth of the matter is our existence is a tragedy,” Carr said in a statement. “Our state housing enforcement agency should do its job.”

A spokesperson for New York State Homes and Community Renewal, which oversees and regulates housing, rent regulations and the protection of rent-regulated tenants, responded by detailing the agency’s efforts to ensure tenants get their due under J-51. The agency noted that the city’s Department of Housing Preservation and Development and Department of Finance have a role in administering the program.

HCR said its Office of Rent Administration has conducted “hundreds of investigations, returned more than 89,000 units to regulation and recovered over $6 million in overcharges for tenants.”

Additionally, the agency said it is involved in “an extensive outreach effort to compel landlords receiving the J-51 benefit to appropriately register their apartments” and that the names of owners who failed to register stabilized units are listed on the HCR website.

Despite HCR’s efforts, HRI in recent years has found cause to launch a slew of investigations into J-51 fraud, as well as voucher-based discrimination.

The group helped serve big-name brokers Compass and Corcoran for Section 8 discrimination and forced developers Blackstone and Kushner Companies to settle for $1 million and $88,000, respectively. Last month, a judge ruled in a case against Urban American that the landlord had illegally deregulated units while receiving the J-51 tax break.

“If we keep heading in this direction,” Carr said in a tweet referencing the group’s ongoing cases, “we will be able to get back up to a half a billion dollars for the tenants and taxpayers of New York City.” But some of the lawsuits stemming from Carr’s investigations have been dismissed.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Sackman Enterprises president Carter Sackman and 15-19 West 96th Street (Sackman Enterprises, Google Maps, iStock)
    Fed up Chabad sues Sackman over unfinished condo
    Fed up Chabad sues Sackman over unfinished condo
    From left: Mayor Eric Adams, Governor Kathy Hochul, and Assemblymember Edward Braunstein (Getty Images, Assembly District 26, iStock/Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
    Say goodbye to another property tax break
    Say goodbye to another property tax break
    Marble Collegiate Church, HFZ's Ziel Feldman and Vanbarton’s Gary Tischler (Getty, iStock)
    Church seeks to escape hellish partnership with HFZ
    Church seeks to escape hellish partnership with HFZ
    Kathy Hochul, Samy Nemir Olivares, Lee Zeldin, Nikki Lucas, Keron Alleyne, Erik Dilan (Getty Images, iStock, Nikki Lucas, Keron Alleyne, Samy Nemir Olivares, Facebook)
    Real estate’s election winners and losers
    Real estate’s election winners and losers
    From left: Lawrence Friedland and Stanley Zabar in front of 2231 Broadway (Getty Images, Friedland Properties, iStock)
    Friedland sues Zabar family in UWS dispute
    Friedland sues Zabar family in UWS dispute
    From left: CHIP’s Jay Martin; Met Council on Housing’s Kate Ehrenberg (CHIP, Met Council on Housing, iStock)
    Rent stabilization: dysfunctional by design
    Rent stabilization: dysfunctional by design
    From left: Bert H. Dweck and Joe Sitt with 790 Madison Avenue (
    Joe Sitt, Bert Dweck settle Madison Ave dispute with fashion house
    Joe Sitt, Bert Dweck settle Madison Ave dispute with fashion house
    From left: U.S. Assemblymember Thomas Suozzi, Governor of New York Kathy Hochul, and New York City Public Advocate Jumaane Williams (Getty Images, iStock/Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
    Hochul challengers bang pro-tenant drum before primary election
    Hochul challengers bang pro-tenant drum before primary election
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...