Rent-controlled units need 11% rent hike, but landlords will get 1%: analysis

State report says owners’ costs soaring as 2019 law keeps rents down

New York /
Dec.December 07, 2021 08:00 AM
DHCR's RuthAnne Visnauskas and CHIP’s Jay Martin (Twitter, iStock)

DHCR’s RuthAnne Visnauskas and CHIP’s Jay Martin (Twitter, iStock)

Landlords whose tales of soaring expenses were largely ignored by the Rent Guidelines Board can now say, “Told you so.”

A statewide analysis of rent-controlled apartments — a subset of rent-stabilized housing — shows the deficit between expenses and revenue may be even steeper than owners claimed.

The board’s vote in June dealt a major blow to landlords, who sought a 2.75 percent increase, in line with the 3 percent rise in costs estimated by the board’s staff. Instead they got six months of 0 percent on top of 2020’s full-year freeze, then a 1.5 percent hike for one-year leases.

Owners’ groups called that “unsustainable” and “incomprehensible.” Now a preliminary report by the state’s Division of Homes and Community Renewal estimates that to keep pace with costs, a rent-controlled unit’s owner would need to raise rents by 11.4 percent during the 2022-2023 leasing cycle.

The report informs the Maximum Base Rent Program, which ensures that rent-controlled owners get enough income to cover maintenance and improvements. Every two years, the state averages the percent change of landlords’ costs, including for taxes, water and sewer, operations and maintenance. It then allows stabilized landlords to apply for a rent raise in line with those costs.

Because buildings with rent-controlled units have rent-stabilized units in them as well, the 11.4 percent estimate should reflect the rising costs of all rent-stabilized units, said a spokesperson for the Community Housing Improvement Program, a landlord group.

Before the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019, owners could request a hike that would get rents closer to the Maximum Base Rent — up to 7.5 percent over a two-year period until the rent reached that maximum.

Under the new rent law, however, hikes are capped at either 7.5 percent or the average of Rent Guidelines Board increases over the past five years, whichever is lower. With three freezes in the past five years, the new stipulation has severely limited what landlords can request.

Owners of rent-controlled units are looking at a 1 percent increase next year.

Landlord groups see the report as evidence that the 2019 law devalued their buildings. In the wake of the state law’s passage, owners predicted its caps on rent raises for improvements would undermine maintenance of their buildings. A Furman Center report showed the value of properties in which half of the units were rent-stabilized had dropped just six months after the law passed.

Within the state’s findings — called the Standard Adjustment Factor report on Maximum Base Rent — the category contributing the most to the need for a higher rent was “Return on Capital Value Allowance.” CHIP described it as a gauge of a building’s value considering depreciation caused by high vacancy rates or decreased rent collection.

“It is fair to say the declining value of buildings is the biggest driver for the MBR SAF going up 11.4 percent,” said the spokesperson.

Asked whether the 2019 law is preventing landlords from collecting the rent needed to operate and maintain buildings, a spokesperson for Homes and Community Renewal said the agency protects the rights of rent-regulated tenants by enforcing the state law.

In the report, the agency acknowledged that the law created a discrepancy between the rent owners need to maintain buildings and the amount tenants ultimately have to pay.

Other analysis has found that landlords cut back on maintenance to offset declining rent revenue during the pandemic.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Nestio's Caren Maio (Credit: Emily Assiran)
    “Like TurboTax”: Nestio launches online leasing
    “Like TurboTax”: Nestio launches online leasing
    (Credit: iStock)
    What you need to know about landlords’ challenge to New York’s rent law
    What you need to know about landlords’ challenge to New York’s rent law
    Among Brooklyn's priciest spots is DUMBO; pictured is the neighborhood's Main Street Park (Credit: iStock)
    Why fewer Brooklyn and Queens tenants are moving
    Why fewer Brooklyn and Queens tenants are moving
    TENNY Policy Director Martha Star and New York City Comptroller Brad Lander (NYU Wagner, New York City Comptroller)
    Last Stand: Property tax reformers recruit Lander to lawsuit
    Last Stand: Property tax reformers recruit Lander to lawsuit
    Dermot Shea, former NYPD commissioner (Getty Images, iStock/Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
    Related hires Ex-NYPD commissioner to head property management
    Related hires Ex-NYPD commissioner to head property management
    Thomas Cangemi, chief executive officer, New York Community Bank (New York Community Bank, iStock)
    Looming interest hikes prompt multifamily lending spree
    Looming interest hikes prompt multifamily lending spree
    Scott McIntyre, chief executive officer, Guidehouse (Guidehouse, iStock/Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
    New York rent relief contractor boasted about profits as program struggled
    New York rent relief contractor boasted about profits as program struggled
    Tax assessments rise 9%, signaling higher bills for landlords
    Tax assessments rise 9%, signaling higher bills for landlords
    Tax assessments rise 9%, signaling higher bills for landlords
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...