St. Barts court quashes proposed $170M hotel

Court revokes building permit issued in 2019

New York Weekend Edition /
Jan.January 01, 2022 09:00 AM

Denise Dupré of SAS Saint Jean Beach Real Estate (Mercersburg Academy, St. Barth Essentiel, iStock/Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)

A proposed $170 million hotel on the Caribbean island of Saint Barthelemy was stopped in its tracks by local authorities.

The St. Barthelemy Administrative Court canceled a building permit for the hotel on the Bay of St. Jean, The New York Post reported. It was being developed by SAS Saint Jean Beach Real Estate, led by Denise Dupré, who is married to billionaire Mark Nunnelly.

The building permit was issued in December 2019, according to the Post. It was modified in June before being scrapped last week. If Dupré wants to continue the project, she would have to start from scratch.

Nonprofit environmental group St. Barth Essentiel is celebrating the decision. The group cited experts in saying construction would decimate St.-Jean Beach.

“We applaud the decision of the court to revoke Hotel Etoile’s building permit,” St. Barth Essentiel President Hélène Bernier told the Post. “We hope that this sends a clear message to all who seek to build properties on our island that the environment must come first for the sake of all who reside here.”

It isn’t clear whether Dupré will pursue the project. Her company didn’t comment on the court’s decision.

The Post previously reported that the L’Etoile Hotel would be double the size of the previous hotel on the site, including 16 buildings and multiple swimming pools. The foundation for the hotel was in the process of being built as the latest legal battle loomed.

One issue the group took up was an underground garage the size of a football field. the planned garage. They said it could create instability in the event of a flood.

Dupré can instead focus her attention on another hotel she owns with her husband on the island, the Le Barthelemy in Grand Cul-de-Sac. According to the Post, that hotel has also run afoul of the community, receiving two notices from the government for dumping toxic waste into the water.

[NYP] — Holden Walter-Warner





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Lever House set for $100M redevelopment, restoration
    Lever House set for $100M redevelopment, restoration
    Lever House set for $100M redevelopment, restoration
    BFC Partners managing principal Donald Capoccia and renderings of 1607 Surf Avenue on Coney Island (BFCNYC)
    BFC breaks ground on next phase of Coney Island affordable project
    BFC breaks ground on next phase of Coney Island affordable project
    John Arrillaga (Raymond Purpur of the Stanford Athletic Department)
    John Arrillaga, pioneering Silicon Valley developer, dead at 84
    John Arrillaga, pioneering Silicon Valley developer, dead at 84
    Southampton Town supervisor Jay Schneiderman (jayschneiderman.com, Google Maps)
    Southampton Town considers buying 40 acres
    Southampton Town considers buying 40 acres
    From left: Don Mullen, chief executive officer, Pretium Partners; Kelli Lawrence, chief executive officer, Onyx+East (Pretium Partners, Onyx+East, iStock)
    Pretium to launch $600M JV for build-to-rent development
    Pretium to launch $600M JV for build-to-rent development
    Sergey Ryback, founder, principal, Ryback Development (Google Maps, Ryback Development)
    Bad vibes threaten Rybak’s Upper East Side project
    Bad vibes threaten Rybak’s Upper East Side project
    Keith Powers, Democratic District 4 representative on the New York City Council, in front of 45 East 45th Street (Getty Images, The Roosevelt Hotel, iStock/Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
    Local lawmakers aim to landmark shuttered Roosevelt Hotel
    Local lawmakers aim to landmark shuttered Roosevelt Hotel
    Goldman Sachs CEO David Solomon and National Affordable Housing Trust CEO Lori Little (Getty, National Affordable Housing Trust, iStock)
    Goldman Sachs to launch fund supporting Black affordable developers
    Goldman Sachs to launch fund supporting Black affordable developers
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...