More distraction than disruption: Brokers at TRD panel unfazed by technology-based competition

But real estate experts at Chicago’s State of the Market event also noted a looming recession has made the future "uncertain" and "scary"

Apr.April 17, 2019 07:30 AM
The Real Deal’s Chicago State of the Market forum

The Real Deal’s Chicago State of the Market forum

With a shifting housing market, increased competition from technology-based companies and a looming economic downturn, there’s a lot coming at Chicago brokers.

Instead of fretting about those market forces, the best way for brokers to thrive is to focus on their own personal business, a panel of real estate experts said at The Real Deal’s Chicago State of the Market forum Tuesday.

Housing sales in the Chicago market saw a slight drop last year, and 2019 is forecast to have an even weaker market. On top of that, brokers are dealing with increased competition from discount, online-based brokerages like Redfin and technology-based buyer models. There are also a slew of progressive tax proposals aimed at the real estate market that could further exacerbate these problems.

“I don’t think anyone knows exactly where real estate taxes are going in the city,” said Jim Hanson, principal at Alison Young. “The unknown, it makes decision-making (for buyers) tougher.”

Much has been made about the threat these new, technology-based models pose, but brokers said they are often more distractions than true disruptors.

“The iBuyer model is solely based on preying on the people who are desperate,” said Matt Laricy, broker with Americorp. “I don’t see it working on a wide-scale basis in any major market, at all.”

Mario Greco, broker with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices KoenigRubloff Realty Group, said the iBuyer model doesn’t make sense for many home sellers, especially in a robust market like Chicago.

“It’s a joke,” he said. “I have no concerns about it all.”

Instead, the biggest issues facing a broker’s business are market factors. Declining sales are compounded by depressed inventory and a slew of new progressive tax proposals aimed at the real estate market.

“You mention a recession,” Greco said. “It’s coming for sure. There’s a lot of uncertainty about a lot of things.”

So how do brokers survive in the changing landscape?

One way is to focus on the economics of their business, said Tommy Choi, broker-owner of Keller Williams Chicago-Lincoln Park.

“The Realtor who treats themselves as a business owner will thrive,” said Choi, adding brokers will have to figure out ways to be more efficient in order to stay profitable.

“The oncoming threat is [tech companies] want to make the process easier, and easier is by cutting us out,” he said. “Ultimately, we have to create our value by keeping up, making it smoother and more deals in a shorter amount of time.”

Laricy said brokers need to look down the road, and have a business plan for the changing market. A recession might force a sizable number of brokers out of the business, increasing opportunities for those who survive — and pounce.

“I plan on doubling down,” he said. “I’m going thrive on everyone else’s fear. Instead of going out and buying a Lamborghini because you’re doing well, you should save it and spend on advertising when everyone pulls their advertising out.”

Related Articles

Chairman and CEO of Taylor Morrison Sheryl Palmer and Townhouses at Riverbank Crossing in Geneva

With Chicago area home sales down, homebuilder Taylor Morrison is out

Co-founder, President and CEO of CLK Properties Craig Koenigsberg, Heritage Village Pointe in Des Plaines (Credit: Google Maps)

CLK Properties closes on massive condo deconversion in Des Plaines

No. 9 Walton (Credit: Google Maps, iStock)

Chicago’s ultra-luxury resi market had a no good, very bad year

Peerage Capital Founder & Executive Chairman Miles S. Nadal (Credit: iStock)

Biggest resi brokerage player in Canada to acquire stake in Jameson Sotheby’s: sources

Northwestern Mutual CEO John Schlifske, Morguard CEO Rai Sahi and the Marquee at Block 37 apartments (Credit: iStock)

Northwestern Mutual revealed as lender of massive Loop resi tower buyout

David Schwimmer and The Lofts at 850 West Adams Street (Credit: Getty Images and Realtor)

The one where David Schwimmer sells his Near West Side loft

Retired chairman and CEO of Boeing James McNerney with the home (Credit: Getty Images and Zillow)

With luxury market stalled, retired Boeing CEO lists mansion at deep discount

Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky with Pride Fest and Lollapalooza (Credit: Getty Images, North Halstead)

Chicago Airbnb hosts heads-up: Pride Fest, Lollapalooza among top-earning weekends