Another angry couple wants “Windy City Rehab” to take back their leaky house

Shane Jones and Samantha Mostaccio say a custom-designed garage project was botched, and their $1.3M home leaks

TRD CHICAGO /
Apr.April 16, 2020 09:00 AM
1700 W. Wabansia Ave in Wicker Park and  HGTV host Alison Victoria Gramenos (Credit: Google Maps)

1700 W. Wabansia Ave in Wicker Park and  HGTV host Alison Victoria Gramenos (Credit: Google Maps)

Another day, another lawsuit for “Windy City” Rehab host Alison Victoria Gramenos.

A Wicker Park couple is suing Gramenos, her former contractors Donovan Eckhardt and Ermin Pajazetovic and HGTV for fraud over work performed at their $1.3 million home.

The lawsuit centers around a garage that homeowners Shane Jones and Samantha Mostaccio say they paid Gramenos extra for during their home renovation. According to the lawsuit, the couple said Gramenos initially quoted them $15,000 to convert the garage into a workout studio, but increased the price to $37,000. They say the work wasn’t completed on time, and it caused water damage in the garage, according to the Chicago Tribune.

Jones and Mostaccio also say Gramenos and her contractors didn’t obtain the proper permits when it began demolishing the garage, and a stop-work order was issued. Because the roof remained open, the garage door no longer works and the gas lines rusted, the lawsuit claims. They accused Pajazetovic of painting over the rust to hide it from a city inspector. The garage failed inspection anyway.

In a statement to the Tribune, Gramenos’ attorney said the dispute centers on the garage project and not Gramenos’ original design of the house. However, the homeowners told the newspaper that 10 days after closing in April 2019 rainwater damaged the home and caused mold and cracked concrete columns.

Jones and Mostaccio want to exchange the home at 1700 W. Wabansia Ave. and be reimbursed for repairs and attorney fees. They claim they lost $4,000 a month in income because Mostaccio, a personal trainer and Pilates instructor, was not able to use the studio.

The suit is just the latest legal action swirling around the popular HGTV program. Gramenos and Eckhardt are no longer working together following a bombshell lawsuit from a Lincoln Park couple to claim that their $1.36 million house was plagued by leaks and shoddy workmanship.

Eckhardt is also embroiled in a lawsuit with Pajazetovic, who claims he was not paid for completed work. Gramenos is also suing a notary public whom she claims forged her signature on loan documents, operating agreements and lien waivers.

Chicago’s Department of Buildings also issued numerous stop-work orders that have prevented Gramenos and her new team from taking on new projects. In a conversation with a podcast host last week, Gramenos said she was concerned about Covid-19’s potential impact on business.

The second season of “Windy City Rehab” is expected to premiere in July. [Tribune] — James Kleimann


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Chicago developer Michael Moyer and the Congress Theater in Logan Square (LinkedIn; ThomasIrvin via Wikipedia)

Developer behind historic Congress Theater faces foreclosure

Developer behind historic Congress Theater faces foreclosure
Alison Victoria Gramenos (Getty, Pixabay)

“Windy City Rehab” star Alison Gramenos drops forgery lawsuit

“Windy City Rehab” star Alison Gramenos drops forgery lawsuit
353 N. Clark with Chester Kamin of Jenner & Block (Google Maps)

Actually, you owe us money: Chicago law firm fires back at landlord

Actually, you owe us money: Chicago law firm fires back at landlord
Donovan Eckhardt and Alison Victoria

“Windy City Rehab” stars Alison Gramenos, Donovan Eckhardt sued for fraud yet again

“Windy City Rehab” stars Alison Gramenos, Donovan Eckhardt sued for fraud yet again
5001 South Drexel Boulevard in Kenwood (Trulia)

Lenders want to stop South Side apartment portfolio “fire sale”

Lenders want to stop South Side apartment portfolio “fire sale”
Alison Victoria, 1700 W. Wabansia Ave. (Credit: Slaven Vlasic/Getty Images, and Google Maps)

Alison Victoria: Lawsuit against me is baseless and lawyer should be sanctioned

Alison Victoria: Lawsuit against me is baseless and lawyer should be sanctioned
Placeholder image

Elite Lincoln Park private school accused of shady condo buy

Elite Lincoln Park private school accused of shady condo buy
401 S. State Street (Credit: Google Maps)

Robert Morris U. skipped out on $1M April rent, landlord charges in suit

Robert Morris U. skipped out on $1M April rent, landlord charges in suit
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...