It ain’t easy for the East End’s top residential brokers

TRD’s annual ranking of agents shows that it’s the magic combo of new tools and old-school tactics that’s key to success in the changing marketplace

Jun.June 11, 2018 01:00 PM

The three-bedroom home at 135 Crestview Lane in Sagaponack was listed at just under $50 million by Justin Agnello and his team at Douglas Elliman.

UPDATED: July 2, 1:120 p.m. To keep their edge in the rapidly evolving East End real estate market, Zachary and Cody Vichinsky of Bespoke Real Estate are investing very heavily in technology, including a proprietary database that helps their firm analyze the luxury segment.

“We have a very robust marketing division that is myopically focused on systems and marketing methodologies that are specific to $10 million-plus properties,” said Zachary.

For the second year in a row, the brothers nabbed the top spot on The Real Deal’s annual ranking of the East End’s top brokers, though it should be noted that this year, TRD looked at closed sales dollar volume versus 2017’s ranking based on exclusive listings volume. The brother-broker duo brought in nearly $230 million in sales between April 2017 and March 2018.

However, perhaps thanks in part to their myopic focus on ultraluxury, and the fact that the Vichinskys appear to represent every single one of the listings Bespoke brings in, the firm only placed eighth on TRD’s ranking of top East End brokerages by closed deals, bringing in that same $247 million sales figure. Bespoke had 16 deals over the April 2017 to March 2018 period, compared to Corcoran’s 496 and Elliman’s 584, the most of any ranked brokerage.

The good news for all the top brokerages is that if the adage “a rising tide lifts all boats” holds true, then things are looking up, as reports indicated that the luxury sector is shaping up to be healthier in 2018.

Ultra-high-end sales — the type Bespoke specializes in — are up in the Hamptons so far this year, according to Town & Country Real Estate’s first-quarter report. Four homes have sold for more than $20 million in the first quarter of 2018, compared to just one last year, the report said.

Both inventory and buyers are fairly limited at the tippy-top of the market; however, top agents are making plenty selling slightly lower-priced homes. There were 37 sales at or above $5 million, a 37 percent increase over the same period a year ago, according to Douglas Elliman’s first-quarter sales report for the Hamptons.

In the luxury market as a whole, which represents the top 10 percent of sales, the average price rose 36.1 percent to $9.1 million, while the median jumped 27.5 percent to $6.6 million. For overall sales, the average price rose 15.2 percent to $1.98 million from the same quarter in 2017, thanks to the uptick in high-end sales, the report said. The median sales price was $995,000.

Still, agents say it’s hard out there. “It is a tough market, undoubtedly,” said Beate Moore of Sotheby’s International Realty, which clinched fourth place on TRD’s brokerage ranking with more than $442 million in closed sales. The Corcoran Group took the No. 1 slot with $1.09 billion sold, while Douglas Elliman was close behind with $1.08 billion.

“When you listen to the news, I think there is an overall feeling that things aren’t all that great. Then we had a really tough, long winter. That wasn’t so great for the business,” Moore said.

At the top of their game

The Vichinsky brothers make a point of promoting properties to the wealthiest people in the world: “That’s the ultimate focus … It’s complete dedication to the luxury segment,” Zach said. And specializing in the $10 million-and-up market means sales add up fast. And although that means saying no to a lot of potential listings, the brothers said the benefits “far outweigh” the limitations.

But other agents are racking up volume as well. Harald Grant of Sotheby’s landed the No. 2 spot on TRD’s list with almost $140 million in sales, including 86 Bay Lane in Water Mill, a 4.6-acre property on Mecox Bay that sold for $18.75 million. Among his current listings is a 20,000-square foot, sixteen-bedroom property on Meadow Lane in Southampton, priced at $150 million.

Susan Breitenbach of Corcoran took the bronze; her more than $132 million earned her the third place on the ranking. Breitenbach’s current listings include a 40-acre waterfront estate on Sagg Pond in Bridgehampton with ocean views, a tennis court and a pool, listed for $35.6 million.

Brown Harris Stevens’ Christopher Burnside took fourth place with about $115 million in sales, and Douglas Elliman’s Enzo Morabito was in the  No. 5 spot with a total sales volume of more than $111 million.

Staying at the top of their game is a constant effort, brokers said, and the uncertainty in the market keeps them hustling, each in their own way.

“I think what brokers need to figure out for themselves is how do you remain relevant in a changing marketplace?” said Tim Davis of Corcoran Group, who ranked No. 6 among top East End brokers with more than $95 million in sales. “Given the changes in tech, how do you remain relevant to the buyer or seller on one of the most important [deals] of their life?”

To make sure he brings value, Davis makes it a point to travel globally to keep his network strong, meeting brokers and family office professionals around the world and attending property shows in London. “My clients don’t want to think I’m sitting in the office, waiting for the phone to ring,” he said. “I meet with people who can potentially feed business to my marketplace. My clients want to know I’m being proactive about marketing their home.”

But there is more than one way to get to the top of one of the most competitive markets in the country.

Creating strong relationships within the Hamptons construction workforce is another way to stay ahead of rivals, counseled Elliman’s Morabito. “The secret to getting people out here to do stuff in a hurry is if they send me a bill, we pay it the next day,” he said. “The people who fix the homes and maintain them, the people who fix the pools, we take care of them.”

By moving along processes like getting the certificate of occupancy and other paperwork, he said, “We make it easy for our team to relax and make the sale.”

Many brokers say there is no substitute for long-standing relationships in the Hamptons market when it comes to making sales. “There have been professional relationships I’ve built over my 38-year career that I can reach back on for guidance and referrals and offer my guidance and counsel in a market that’s changed dramatically in that time period,” said Davis.

For her part, Carol Nobbs, a broker at Douglas Elliman, believes there have been fundamental changes in the marketplace.

“It was a different market years ago,” she said. “It was a lot easier. There was more pent-up demand. There was more money to be made. The heads of the companies, the most senior management, they’re the ones getting all the bonuses. All the young Turks are not getting all of those bonuses they were getting prior to 2010. They’re not trickling down.”

And things move faster than ever. To make sure buyers and sellers are served quickly in an age of instant gratification, and that deals get closed, some brokers are sharing commissions. Nobbs said she is adding agents to her listings to do open houses.

“The world is changing,” she said. “The brokerage community has to accommodate the changes. I’m splitting my commission and working with people so my sellers are accommodated 24/7. I also work with someone who will accommodate the buyer in case I am busy with something else. I’m not a team. But I am sharing on an as-needed basis with agents I know are professional and whom I respect.”

Of course, with change often comes uncertainty. And East End brokers and brokerages are seeing some cooling.

“The market is, I believe, quite soft out here,” said Justin Agnello, also of Douglas Elliman. He is part of the Atlantic team, with partners Hara Kang and James Keogh; they are currently showing Elie Tahari’s Sagaponack estate at 135 Crestview Lane, which is listed for $45 million. The property, which is about 4,500 square feet, is located on 2.5 acres of oceanfront land. “We haven’t had much action on it,” Agnello admitted.

To maintain their edge in this environment, Agnello and his partners, who have worked together for 14 years, personally show the properties they are listing. “Every buyer who walks into the house will ask a question that needs to be answered,” said Agnello. Buyers may not realize, for instance, that it’s possible to clear another quarter acre and put in more yard, he noted — and the broker who is there to address their concerns will have an edge, he said.

Working the volume angle

Elliman’s Morabito mainly focuses on homes closer to the area’s median price. He said his team consistently sells 50 to 60 homes a year.

“We do volume,” Morabito emphasized. However, one of his team’s current pricy listings is an eight-bedroom, six-bathroom home on the ocean in Westhampton Beach South, asking $6.9 million.

Sotheby’s Moore is also open to showing houses that cost less. “They don’t all have to be big and pricey,” said Moore, but she qualified that by adding, “If I take on something for around $1 million, it has to mean something to me.”

The competition among brokerages is intense, with Saunders & Associates, ranked #3, closing 286 deals adding up to about $754.5 million in sales. Meanwhile, at the bottom of the list, Nest Seekers — home to “Million Dollar Listings” star Ryan Serhant — came in at No. 10, with $72.7 million in sales across just 65 deals.

Technically speaking

No matter what the price, to get buyers to the properties, social media and tech are playing an ever-greater role for firms and brokers in the Hamptons.

Moore, for instance, promotes properties on Instagram and Facebook in addition to putting some of the priciest listings in Sotheby’s auction catalogue and relying on the brokerage’s Referral Network, a global platform.

Corcoran now has a group of more than 60 full-time employees who work on technology, said CEO Pam Liebman. They just refreshed the firm’s website, she said, and the firm is launching some new mobile tools for the agents, so it’s easier for them to work from wherever they are.

The firm’s year-old Agent Studio, an education center, offers more than 20 classes a month to keep agents up to date on the latest innovations in tech. Beyond that, a proprietary platform enables agents to automatically share content created by Corcoran on their own social profiles. “Technology is a tool,” said Liebman. “The real success behind Corcoran is the quality of the agents.”

Elliman has also been proactive. To keep up with social media, among other things, the firm just added Samantha Yanks, the former editor-in-chief of Modern Luxury’s Gotham and Hamptons magazines, as chief marketing officer.

She’ll direct its digital marketing as well as brand management, creation and positioning. With the firm now operating in California, Florida, Massachusetts, Brooklyn and Long Island, including the East End, and with more than 7,000 agents across 113 offices nationwide, Yanks has been charged with developing and tailoring specific messaging for those markets. She will also lead the agency’s national marketing program and oversee the firm’s “Elliman Insider” blog.

The firm has already built an enormous following on Instagram and Facebook. Agnello said he’s constantly promoting his properties on Elliman’s social media platforms. “A lot of times, we can promote our products on there and feed live data,” he said. “I can then look at who looked at it, who reached out to me, and give that data to my clients.”

“People are so addicted to their phones, it’s almost taking over for email blasts,” said Agnello.

Elliman has also invested in its own site,, one of the most highly trafficked real estate websites, the company said.

Besides listings, it includes the AskElliman tool, which lets consumers ask questions about homebuying and get quick answers from a team of experts.

Morabito, too, sees the value in using newer platforms for advertising.

“Right now, social media is the most affordable advertising on the face of the earth,” he said.

He likes it that he can target buyers carefully. “We can dial into who we are in front of based on what their preferences are, how much money they make and what types of real estate they are interested in,” he said.

Morabito believes that Facebook advertising is the most cost-effective avenue — “I can put it in front of 10,000 people for $150 a week,” he said — and that Snapchat works particularly well for reaching millennials.

Meanwhile, Agnello and his partners are doubling down on video, working with Lifestyle Productions in Miami. “Right now, I’m spending a lot of money on videos that actually make the property come to life; instead of doing a fake rendering, they’re going to digitally create the house finished, and then video it,” he said. “That’s something new and innovative.”

All of this takes time, and, like Agnello, many agents are outsourcing. Nobbs has been paying a company to do professional Instagram posts for her that feature a 30-second video of the property.

“They’re very quick,” she said. “It’s just a click to catch your attention.”

Nobbs and other brokers say sellers now expect them to be on top of social media. “You have to accommodate both sellers and buyers in a nanosecond,” she said.

Correction: An earlier version of this article provided the incorrect total for Zachary and Cody Vichinsky’s sales as an agent team, and for Bespoke Real Estate as a firm. Both charts have been updated to reflect the revised totals. The earlier version also misstated Douglas Elliman’s total sales volume and number of transactions due to a clerical error. 

Related Articles

Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
 Fredrik Eklund and the property (Getty, Steve Frankel)
Fredrik Eklund lists Bel Air mansion for rent as family moves to “forever home”
Fredrik Eklund lists Bel Air mansion for rent as family moves to “forever home”
Gordon Ramsey and his Lucky Cat restaurant (Lucky Cat)
Gordon Ramsay to open first South Florida restaurant in Miami Beach
Gordon Ramsay to open first South Florida restaurant in Miami Beach
68 Gold Street with CW Realty CEO Cheskie Weisz and 1340 East Bay Avenue (Google Maps)
CW Realty purchase makes TRD’s mid-market i-sales list
CW Realty purchase makes TRD’s mid-market i-sales list
NAR Pending Home Sales Index Up Record 44 Percent in May
TRD Insights: What a record month for contracts says about the US housing market
TRD Insights: What a record month for contracts says about the US housing market
Corcoran's Pam Liebman, Compass's Robert Reffkin and Elliman's Howard Lorber jockey for position atop the resi rankings. (Illustration by Nate Kitch)
Selling the whole city: TRD’s resi brokerage ranking expands beyond Manhattan
Selling the whole city: TRD’s resi brokerage ranking expands beyond Manhattan
Clockwise from top left: Macy’s Jeff Gennette, Redfin’s Glenn Kelman, Vornado’s Steve Roth, Realogy’s Ryan Schneider, Cushman & Wakefield’s Brett White and CBRE’s Bob Sulentic (Credit: Getty Images; Illustration by The Real Deal)
Second Take: Pay cuts at the top of the RE food chain
Second Take: Pay cuts at the top of the RE food chain
Special Report Stimulus Package
What the $2 trillion stimulus does for real estate
What the $2 trillion stimulus does for real estate

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.