The Real Deal New York

How Related won Hudson Yards bid

Backing of Goldman Sachs was crucial to getting win
By Alec Appelbaum | June 02, 2008 05:52PM

The right partner apparently made all the difference in a successful bid for Hudson Yards.

Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation was so central to the Related Companies’ original bid to develop Hudson Yards that its proposal was dubbed “Murdochville.” But when Murdoch dropped out, Related was forced to effectively drop its bid for the 26-acre waterfront project in February.

But Related got a second chance: While the firm lacked an anchor tenant, it did have a top-notch investment bank behind it. And so when Tishman Speyer pulled out last month, the backing of Goldman Sachs gave Related another shot at developing the massive site on Manhattan’s far West Side.

Related’s strong financial backing propelled it ahead of a Durst Organization-Vornado Realty Trust joint venture and Extell Development, said Gary Dellaverson, MTA’s chief financial officer.

The other surviving bidders, who all tried to re-enter bids after Tishman left,
evidently could not round up as much
money as Related with Goldman’s backing.

“Extell really worked very hard to address earlier bid problems,” said Dellaverson, “but Related understood that if there are difficulties in the market, it would still have to perform.”

A source affiliated with the Durst/Vornado bid, insisting on anonymity, confirmed that the joint venture did not have outside equity investors but refused to discuss whether it could have matched Related’s price. Extell did not return requests for comment.

Related accepted Tishman’s deal with only minor adjustments and signed a letter promising to build a $2 billion platform over the active rail yards only six days after Tishman gave up.

Related CEO Stephen Ross said that when News Corp. pulled out a day before second-round bids were due in March, Related had no time to rework its entire bid. At that time, the MTA was very keen on having an anchor tenant, and Tishman had Morgan Stanley as both an anchor and a backer.

Tishman lost Morgan Stanley as a partner, but went through all the negotiations and set a price of $1.054 billion.

Then it insisted on the right to walk away with few penalties if the market remained weak.

That left an opening for Related and Goldman, which didn’t need the protection that Tishman wanted, to step into a deal that had already been worked out. With Goldman Sachs’ rock-solid capital, Related could offer the same $1.054 billion and promise to build the entire rail yards, half of which the city still has to rezone.

Dellaverson, the MTA’s chief negotiator, said the agency was impressed with Related’s “desire to perform in any economy.”

The current deal also has parallels to the past: Related built the Time Warner Center on a former MTA property in the early 2000s, when economic worries also cast a cloud over big projects.

Now Goldman’s ability to fund the project means Related will not risk running short of credit or cash during the complex buildout.

“The initial platform will be financed with equity,” said Jeff Blau, Related’s president. “Goldman Sachs is our partner, but we will bring in additional limited partners throughout the process.”

Blau told The Real Deal that other investors, also likely to bring equity, would join Related later on in the project. Who they might be remains unclear, but Related has reached far and wide for investors before. In December, Goldman and others, including a fund backed by computer magnate Michael Dell and an Abu Dhabi investment group, sank $1.4 billion into Related for future big projects.

Related plans 5,500 units of housing, including affordable rents for at least 20 percent of the rentals, plus a hotel and large park connecting to the High Line and Hudson River. Ross said that the multimedia pavilion the developer presented last fall vanished when News Corp. quit the project, but he promised “a great park.” The city also needs to build a boulevard along the site.

Blau said that it helps to have investors in it for the long haul rather than lenders, a conclusion that Dellaverson shared.

“Others wouldn’t have made this choice,” Dellaverson said. “Steve Ross and the MTA are focused on the long term.”

Related has signed a series of agreements called a conditional designation letter, and has paid $11 million into escrow, said Jeremy Soffin, an MTA spokesperson.

Comments are closed.